I think Ultimate X-Men overall had some VERY strong creative teams who put in some excellent work.
Millar & the Kuberts, Vaughan & Immonen, Kirkman & friends, and then the extremely underrated and overlooked Nick Spencer and Brian Wood runs. The main issue for me is that the original 616 characters are still so strong and relevant that I never really felt the need to read alternative version adventures of them outside of movies, videogames and animated series. Ultimate X-Men has been a very long What If? for me, where you can do some stuff you wouldn't be able to do in the mainline comics, but ultimately just an alternate reality take which became increasingly hard to invest in.
Not only that, but I still maintain that it has something to do with how they're going to introduce mutants in the MCU and creating some synergy there. Hickman is that guy that they bring into their major franchises to kind of revitalize them and churn out some big idea stories which can be adapted to the big screen. A lot of his Avengers work went into the latter parts of the Infinity Saga, and I have no doubt that his 2015 Secret Wars is going to form more of the basis for the Avengers: Secret Wars film than the original 1984 version. My gut tells me they looked at his recent work on the X books, starting with House of X/Powers of X where he set up this nation state of Krakoa and the whole concept of Moira X, and said it's too ambitious and doesn't align with what Kevin Feige and the studio heads are thinking in terms of how they want to bring the mutants to the big screen. They seem to want to lean heavily into the most popular incarnation of the franchise, which is the 90s version operating out of the school.
So my gut tells me that the mutants will be a very big part of this new Ultimate U, and somehow it's going to tie into their plans for the Multiverse Saga and how it will lead to mutants in the MCU. Haven't quite figured it out yet, and I could definitely be wrong about that. But it's a gut feeling.
“Not as good as I once was… but I’m as good, once, as I ever was.”
Well, take it with a grain of salt because I was always one of the ones who hated this era with the white hot intensity of a thousand suns. But the most consistent discontent I see comes down to Hickman laying a bunch of groundwork and then either not following up on it, dragging it out too long or not having satisfying/interesting conclusions too it. A lot of his initial work was darker and more cynical, and then he seemingly didn't keep the other writers on the same page even before he bounced. This left a lot of this supposedly more interconnected era feeling really disjointed. There are more smaller sticking points, but this is already dangerously off topic.
To bring it back to the topic, the way he handled his X era gives me little hope for this project. Multiverse stories with this many characters can quickly become disjointed messes, and the way he handled Moira has been headache inducing. Plus, I prefer my comics with a sense of optimism, which Hickman struggles with, too.
If they only looked at the recent books starting in the Krakoa era, that means they means they've only seen Beast as a villain. Does this mean he'll be one in the movie, too? That's what I've been afraid of, that Cebulski let Percy do this because they were ready to make Beast a villain permanently.
Yeah, I'm sorry for derailing. I have little enthusiasm for this project even though I liked the UU. Everything seems to be so dark and miserable, and sometimes gory too(which I really dislike).
Last edited by Mungho; 03-01-2023 at 09:24 AM.
placeholder signature until I can think of something.
I know discussion of this news has died down. But I made a video on this news in which I react, speculate, and discuss this news. I meant to finish this sooner, but better late than never.
Join me on the official website for X-men Supreme, home of Marvel Universe 1015. Want a fresh take on X-men? Click below to enter the official home of Marvel at it's most Supreme!
Or if you want, check out my YouTube channel, Jack's World.