What made Donna Troy's origin story so confusing?

[D.Z]

Not everything is continuity but most of everything that can fit.

[Phoenixx9]

And maybe again her origin will be retold!! Hahahaha!!

The story may not even cover that topic. I am just happy to see Donna getting some more appearances and attention, in an era where many people fell in love with her.

[Primal Slayer]

Not everything is continuity but most of everything that can fit.

They've flat out said that everything happened in DC Comics. What they touch on and are willing to ignore? Different story.

[marhawkman]

I disagree that it doesn't matter that Dick and Roy have more experience, because it makes weird and wrong to me when people who have way less time in the job than they do are treated as senior to them, instruct them, etc. as can happen in some later versions. I actually do agree the shared universe causes as many problems as opportunities. There are some great things from it, but as it gets larger and has more writers, it opens up plot holes galore, has characters nerfed to prop up others, etc.

And to make it worse, DC is a combination of several things that used to be seperate.

[Phoenixx9]

I also like that we see some Bumblebee. But the costume shown is not her original one is it?

[Rac7d*]

They've flat out said that everything happened in DC Comics. What they touch on and are willing to ignore? Different story.

Her marrige and son
And her best storyline who is Donna troy

[MajorHoy]

I also like that we see some Bumblebee. But the costume shown is not her original one is it?

[D.Z]

They've flat out said that everything happened in DC Comics. What they touch on and are willing to ignore? Different story.

Nah. They flat out ignored that. Do keep up.

[Uncanny X-Man]

Am I the only one who enjoys Donna's "Titan Seed" origin?

Her original origin as an infant rescued from a burning building by Wonder Woman and subsequently raised by the Amazons is perfect and unbeatable in its simplicity, but I always found the Titans of Myth story very interesting and unique; it added a layer of complexity to Donna for sure but it was also uniquely hers, gave her and the Titans a whole new playground (which sadly was never really fully explored) and it was just a powerful story by Wolfman & George Perez in his triumphant return to the book.

IMO it was only John Byrne's ridiculous revisions that muddied the waters and they should die in a fire without getting rescued by Diana, Hippolyta, Rhea or anyone else.

[Phoenixx9]

Ah yes, that is the OG costume that I would iike to see, at least initially. Then they can make slight changes as the series continues.

Thank you MajorHoy for finding these scenes.

[Digifiend]

Robin and Aqualad aren't in their original costumes either - Dan Mora modernised them, primarily by adding pants!

I dont think we know what her current "official" origin is nowadays do we? Apart from the "everything is in continuity"?

It's the rescued from a fire origin, confirmed by the Artemis Wanted one-shot - both Donna and Cassie had their origins shown in flashback there.

[marhawkman]

Am I the only one who enjoys Donna's "Titan Seed" origin?

Her original origin as an infant rescued from a burning building by Wonder Woman and subsequently raised by the Amazons is perfect and unbeatable in its simplicity, but I always found the Titans of Myth story very interesting and unique; it added a layer of complexity to Donna for sure but it was also uniquely hers, gave her and the Titans a whole new playground (which sadly was never really fully explored) and it was just a powerful story by Wolfman & George Perez in his triumphant return to the book.

IMO it was only John Byrne's ridiculous revisions that muddied the waters and they should die in a fire without getting rescued by Diana, Hippolyta, Rhea or anyone else.

I liked the Titan Seed thing as an origin.... the weird place that story went... not a big fan of that.... especially since Donna ended up powerless when it was over.

[Primal Slayer]

Nah. They flat out ignored that. Do keep up.

Nah. They ignore it and just touch of things when they to. Keep up.

[jamgut]

Am I the only one who enjoys Donna's "Titan Seed" origin?

Her original origin as an infant rescued from a burning building by Wonder Woman and subsequently raised by the Amazons is perfect and unbeatable in its simplicity, but I always found the Titans of Myth story very interesting and unique; it added a layer of complexity to Donna for sure but it was also uniquely hers, gave her and the Titans a whole new playground (which sadly was never really fully explored) and it was just a powerful story by Wolfman & George Perez in his triumphant return to the book.

IMO it was only John Byrne's ridiculous revisions that muddied the waters and they should die in a fire without getting rescued by Diana, Hippolyta, Rhea or anyone else.

I also liked the Titan Seed origin primarily because it was not connected to Wonder Woman and wouldn't be subject to revision/deletion if Wonder Woman's origin changed.

[Thor-Ul]

Robin and Aqualad aren't in their original costumes either - Dan Mora modernised them, primarily by adding pants!

Dan Mora must be fan of Brainiac:

It's the rescued from a fire origin, confirmed by the Artemis Wanted one-shot - both Donna and Cassie had their origins shown in flashback there.

Yes, but most of the time the origin of Donna has been explored and explained in the Titans titles. Is like Donna is more Titans character than a Wonder Woman character. I mean, you can argue even than Donna debuted in the Teen Titans book!!