DC Comics Events Ruined By Their Popularity

[Jabare]

wait how were Kingdom Come and Infinite Crisis ruined?

[Timber Wolf-By-Night]

I would assume it has to do with expectations and whether the event lived up to those expectations or not.

I would agree with everything on the list except Kingdom Come. However, several of these are still big sellers on Amazon.

Nah, they got Kingdom Come right. What they got wrong was that everybody knew it was a screed against 90's comics, but most readers endorsed that screed. Hell, "old is better than new" is the ethos of Alex Ross's entire career.

[Buried Alien]

Is this some kind of gatekeeper thing like "it was cool until everybody started liking it?"

Buried Alien (The Fastest Post Alive!)

[D.Z]

Weird thread.

[Gaius]

I reject the notion that Infinite Crisis was ever good.