I'm gonna have a good laugh if it turns out Evil Spider-man is more likable/relatable than he's been this entire run.
I had an epiphany a couple of issues ago where the short version was that Shed was really everything we needed to know about Zeb Wells and I think over time that has just proven more true. To be clear, I mean that as a writer, not as a person, sometimes people just have drastically different writing styles and interests than they do as people, and this is neither the time nor place to judge a man. But a writer, well, that's exactly in our wheelhouse.
What I mean by Shed is everything we needed to know is just that Shed is a story that's about the writer making choices. There is no light in Shed. It's the darkest possible outcome of the Lizard story. It's not out of character or "bad", per se, because the Lizard has attempted to do terrible things several times before, he's always just been held off by Spider-Man or just barely by Connors himself. Shed is the story where he loses that battle, and the darkness wins. The only thing the story is missing is Curt's suicide at the end, which is the only realistic outcome to that situation, for the darkness to be complete. It's not a story that's wrong, but it's a choice. It's a choice to indulge in that bleakness and dark world view. The bad guys will win. Love is transactional and temporary. You can never truly conquer your demons. There are whole series where this is the outlook, and some people enjoy them, and that's their right, for sure. But personally I find it completely unenjoyable. But sometimes the darkness has to win. Not every story has a happy ending, and it's valid that this is how the Lizard's story would end. There's a story that people don't refernce much from like the 80s I think where this kid is being chased throughout the city because he has dangerous powers. Spider-Man fights off his attackers and defends the kid, but eventually he fails. The kid is killed and no one cares, because it's a justifiable kill. And yet Peter is just left devastated by the whole affair. Even if justified it still feels wrong and tragic to him, because he has this outlook that he can fix everything and everything can work out. It's not a bad story though. It's just the devil taking his due. So sometimes those stories are ok. But you would hope that a writer has more tricks than just the one, and it's become quite apparent that Wells just doesn't. This run is just the darkness winning over and over. Of course MJ "moves on", love is meaningless and transactional. Of course he lets Tombstone walk away, there is no triumphing over evil. Of course Norman must save him from his sins, the evil is not overcomable by anyone, for it is the strongest thing there is. It's a bad fit for Spidey. And it's repetitiveness has gotten stale.
Even Moon Knight isn't that grim, at least not these days, given that now under Jed MacKay, it's become the story of a man trying to rebuild himself and his life after hitting rock bottom, rediscovering what's truly important to him that he's willing to fight to defend. It's the kind of story we could and should have also gotten with the basic opening premise for Wells's (not-so-)Amazing Spider-Man, though Xenon's post did sum up very well why we didn't get that and why we may never get that in this run.
The spider is always on the hunt.
I don't mind this. KLH has become an albatross in almost every writer's neck that no one can get rid of, and attempts to reiterate on it or 'spiritually success it' (for want of a better word) have all fallen flat.
spoilers:end of spoilers
Evil Spider-Man doing what Kraven did to him in order to torture him makes enough sense. I don't mind it being not particularly high hanging fruit if it sticks the landing, and Goblin-infused Spider-Man would definitely do something like this.
Discovering/CONFESSING! the nature of evil... one retcon at a time.
I'm mostly amused that he's doing this
spoilers:end of spoilers
and it's not even the same Kraven that buried him in the first place. It's a totally different clone-son. Original Kraven is still a corpse after dying all over again a few years back in Spencer's run.
Can I take this moment to shameless recommend Spider-Man: Lost Hunt to anyone who hasn't read it yet? It may have been tied to that classic story, but it really was more thoughtful and introspective on the consequences, trauma, and redemption Peter felt coping with that experience than I suspect this will be.
I'm aware, but there's also the funny nugget that while villains are shown in the know this isn't actually Sergei (Rhino in Sinister War, then Kafka), Spider-Man doesn't seem to know so far. I'm curious to see whether Wells will go with "already knows he's the Last Son" or "still thinks he's original Kraven".
Discovering/CONFESSING! the nature of evil... one retcon at a time.
But is it?
I don’t think this run has figured out what it means by “sins.” Nor does this run show an understanding of Norman’s and Peter’s characters.
This could be a banger story - well, I guess nearly all ideas could be in the right hands - and it could be a fascinating, resonant, even psychological horror story about Peter looking at the world through Green Goblin eyes, to compare/contrast Peter and Norman - but this story is just “heh heh flip the surface of KLH and make the good guy bad heh heh” without stopping to think about the themes and nuances (and yes, that is obvious from the pages we have, I sincerely doubt the other pages will provide much else). Of course, this run has so far been able to demonstrate anything resembling themes, much less nuance.
“I always figured if I were a superhero, there’s no way on God's earth that I'm gonna pal around with some teenager."
— Stan Lee
"He's pure power and doesn't even know it. He's the best of us."-Matt Murdock
"I need a reason to take the mask off."-Peter Parker
"My heart half-breaks at how easy it is to lie to him. It breaks all the way when he believes me without question." Felicia Hardy