List your all-time WORST DC Comics

[Hol]

It’s funny. If you asked me this back in 2016 or so my list would have been so different. But the quality since then has dropped so much to the point I could never have imagined.

Heroes in Crisis
Hawkgirl
Tim Drake Robin
Dark Crisis Young Justice
Alan Scott Green Lantern


These are all trash. DC should be embarrassed that they published these books.

Williamsons Flash is really bad too but I wouldn’t call it trash. He had some good ideas with terrible execution.

[BohemiaDrinker]

This thread has "bad idea" written all over it.

It does. That's why I feel obligated to post.


1 - Flash Rebirth
2 - Dark Crisis Young Justice
3 - Countdown
4 - Heroes in Crisis
5 - Venditti and Van Jensen Flash

[BohemiaDrinker]

a joke in poor taste is still distasteful. if I insult your mother but shoot you a winky face when I do it, is that not still crossing a line? given the nature of this thread, it's important we not play in each other's faces like that, ya know? like I said, I meant no disrespect to the poster but I'm just saying that was a bit uncouth.

Yes. And my joyless direct response is: that's your opinion and I simply disagree that it was insulting, distasteful or uncouth. I saw it as playful and good-natured. Neither of us being moderators, it's just two people's opinions and it's fine that we disagree. We don't even know if Thomas Crown took offense and the response was directed at them.

I'll have to agree with J9ac9k here. No one called each other names, no one picked a fight, nothing. It was a light joke based on disagreement. If we get over sensitive at stuff like this, no meaningful discussion can ever take place.

[Johnrevenge]

Add in the Threeboot/Waidboot too. I have never seen Waid **** the bed so badly before, and it was on a series he had already rebooted once before that was much better. So bad even he got bored with his own writing. It was so boring it even made Barry Kitson's art boring.

This. Despite all the flaws of Bendis' Legion, it wasn't in the same level of awfullness than the Threeboot. All the characters were whinny and spoiled brats that spend every issue competing with each other to see who was the most unlikable and who could be the biggest jerk besides that version of Brainiac 5 (which was by the Brainiac 5 standards, the worst version of all).

Another worst run was Felicia D. Henderson Teen Titans.

Anything that Marc Guggenheim has wrotten in comics, no matter if its DC, Marvel, independent. All of it is awfull.

[Thor-Ul]

This. Despite all the flaws of Bendis' Legion, it wasn't in the same level of awfullness than the Threeboot. All the characters were whinny and spoiled brats that spend every issue competing with each other to see who was the most unlikable and who could be the biggest jerk besides that version of Brainiac 5 (which was by the Brainiac 5 standards, the worst version of all).

In threeboot, at least they have personalities. Awful personalities, but they had their own identities.

[Johnrevenge]

In threeboot, at least they have personalities. Awful personalities, but they had their own identities.

I honestly found the Bendis Legion much more likable and with more personality than characters of threeboot. Threeboot will always be the worst version, and I'm saying it as someone that generally dislikes and hates many of Bendis work with very few exceptions.

[Thor-Ul]

I honestly found the Bendis Legion much more likable and with more personality than characters of threeboot. Threeboot will always be the worst version, and I'm saying it as someone that generally dislikes and hates many of Bendis work with very few exceptions.

Then we agree to dissagree.