Warren Worthington (616 Adult Warren)
Of all the characters Marvel has in a perfect spot for an awesome total overhaul, Warren is in the number 1 spot. I love mind wiped Warren and all the possibility he holds, and I hope he's just not reset to normal, destroying his recent character development. Let me explain why:
Warren has been treated like a walking wallet that isn’t given the support he needs from the X-men. In fact, if there was an X-man who should cut active ties with the X-men and start his own life on another non-mutant team that is actually supportive of him, Warren is it. I also despise the way Betty and Warren worked as a couple, because it's not good for either of them, and neither seems really committed to it. Warren is an object for the X-men, one that Scott used shamelessly. That's why I like how disassociated Warren is in his amnesiatic state: Even he views himself as an object rather than a person, which is exactly how he's treated most of the time by those around him. But that doesn't stop him from caring and trying to do what's right; really, if any current Marvel character is analogous to DC's Shining Knight, Warren is it.
This is where DC screwed up recently with Shining Knight: Like Warren, Justin is partly an objectified male stereotype of an ideal that makes others see him as a role rather than a person. In making Shining Knight a woman, DC completely failed to recognize that the character is actually about male objectification, something which is every bit as worthy a subject as female objectification. I see Warren's amnesia and disassociation as an encouraging sign that Marvel may get this about Warren and may be willing to explore it (which they should).
Warren's personality could easily tip over into Marty-Stu territory, but Marvel has managed to avoid that by keeping Warren's core personality Warren in spite of the amnesia: he's innocent (yet not stupid), caring, and brave. His willingness to give unwisely and his self-apathy are still his weaknesses. He just doesn’t have all the baggage, which is something I think that needs to stay even if he gets his memory back. The death and mind wipe should be a "you can never go home again" moment for this character in the same way traumatic brain injuries can alter a person's personality and perceptions. If he does get his memories back, I think they shouldn't really change him back to pre-mind wiped Warren, but just be there. Likewise Betty and Warren needs to be over, and any future relationship Warren has needs to be checked for being meaningful and not just desperate and lonely.
Warren's new powers of life vs. Archangel’s powers revolving around death are also very interesting changes that need to stay. It was past time to give him a better skill set that will let him be a meaningful character in stories, and it’s the perfect time to play up the angel concept for this character. And Marvel should play it up as long as they can.
So my suggestions:
- Get Warren off the X-books where he's in the background a couple of time a year. Get him away from mutants and into a team that can actually appreciate him. After the last Archangel arc, Warren just needs to get far, far away from the X-men and what seems to have turned into a toxic/abusive relationship for Warren. This character needs to do some major soul searching and redefining their life and priorities. New Warren should not fall into the traps old Warren fell into. Maybe it's time to stick him with Inhumans as a sort of Nuhuman mutant hybrid?
- Warren's past memories should never have any real emotional weight attached to them if he gets them back. This gives Warren’s death real weight and meaning.
- Warren's new powers need to stay and grow, and Marvel needs to play with the "angel" concept. What is an angel? What does that mean? Is Warren one? Play with all those questions and use it as a frame work for establishing who Warren is now. Being both Death and Life now, Marvel can play with both sides of this and really make Warren a fascinating and important character.