Originally Posted by
Cyke
I'm not saying they should be lessened. It needn't be a competition; in fact, a competition is one of the more harmful way of approaching diversity (then you get into "the Diversity Olympics" and try to trump one's pain and loss over another). However, a Black Panther movie in conjunction with the history of black film would go to show the different facets of life there are in the real world, since entertainment is often about how reality is viewed. And the point that Dagman made is based on historical reactions to blacks on film; and considering hostile, racist reactions of the past, you can't blame someone for imagining defensively; shutting it down/sweeping it under the rug is often the classic response to such race-based posts.
With that said, as much flack as Wesley Snipes gets for saying he helped start the Marvel movie empire, I'm very much in agreement with him (though not in the way he puts it, admittedly). Spawn was created by a white artist -- but that was very much a conscious creative choice that came with its own set of story options and thus adds to the pantheon of formidable black comic figures... just like Stan Lee and Jack Kirby's motivation to make the Black Panther back in the 60s. If someone makes a movie about a minority disabled hero (Hello, Silhouette!), then bring it on! Because they exist in real life too and belong side by side with other people up on screen. But none of that reduces the importance of the past, because the present is built on it. It's also not going to override other films like Capt. Marvel because everyone, and I do mean everyone, has a place and an audience to fill.
Sure, i'm hoping it'll be good too, but if it is, I imagine that race, progress, and representation would play a role there. That's not to say it'll be good just because it's minority based, but if it IS good, those are necessary components to the character that won't/can't be swept under the rug.
(and Steel is just a mess. Nobody ever brings that up in the list of positive "Important [insert population here] Movies.")