General omnibus & hardcover discussion vol. II

[TomSlick]

Paper Girls v1
Descender v1
Black Science v2
Sunstone v2
Walking Dead Omni v7

Are the new HCs for those who dont care to scroll

Thanks!
I'm down for Black Science and TWD v. 7. I'm also going to give Descender a shot. Never heard of it but Lemire is pretty decent.

[OldManBrian]

I saw a Green Valley hardcover in there somewhere but didn't see anything about it being deluxe/oversized.

[awayne83]

Thanks!
I'm down for Black Science and TWD v. 7. I'm also going to give Descender a shot. Never heard of it but Lemire is pretty decent.

Descender is great. Probably in my top 5 atm.

[pud333]

While I was away, delivery person brought me some good stuff. I am happy with how my Marvel collection is coming along now that I've decided to get back into Marvel.

[ER Prest]

Paper Girls v1
Descender v1
Black Science v2
Sunstone v2
Walking Dead Omni v7

Are the new HCs for those who dont care to scroll

Picking up those first four, nice. Been waiting on, well, all of them really

[FluffySheep]

http://edelweiss.abovethetreeline.co...alogID=4167129

some new image stuff

I've been desperate for a Descender deluxe for a while now! I almost gave up on it and nearly bought the TPBs this week but held off. So glad I did now.

I'm still disappointed that Spread hasn't been given the deluxe treatment yet though.

[Raffi Ol D'Arcy]

http://edelweiss.abovethetreeline.co...alogID=4167129

some new image stuff

Glad to see Copperhead back on target. I'm hoping for a Deluxe edition at some point.

[Balakin]

While I was away, delivery person brought me some good stuff. I am happy with how my Marvel collection is coming along now that I've decided to get back into Marvel.

so many good stuff! Loved Phonogram even though it was some serious hipster bs but I really don't mind it Started reading DD v1 a few days ago and it is just as good as I remembered. Brubaker is really an addictive writer.

[OldManBrian]

I'll be interested in hearing everybody's opinion on Descender when it comes out. I was reading it in singles but dropped it after about 14 or 15 issues. Nguyen's art is ok but I don't love it as much as some and I kind of got tired of it. The biggest problem for me though was the story telling. I thought conceptually it was very good and the first arc started strong but not long after that it started to get just very boring for me and I didn't really care or feel any attachment to the characters. Maybe this is one of those books that just reads better in larger chunks.

[TomSlick]

I'll be interested in hearing everybody's opinion on Descender when it comes out. I was reading it in singles but dropped it after about 14 or 15 issues. Nguyen's art is ok but I don't love it as much as some and I kind of got tired of it. The biggest problem for me though was the story telling. I thought conceptually it was very good and the first arc started strong but not long after that it started to get just very boring for me and I didn't really care or feel any attachment to the characters. Maybe this is one of those books that just reads better in larger chunks.

15 issues is a pretty big chunk, so if you didn't like it by then I doubt it will get better. It's a blind buy for me. Lemire is a hit or miss writer. Some stuff I really like and some of his stuff bores me to tears.

[The Whovian]

I'll be interested in hearing everybody's opinion on Descender when it comes out. I was reading it in singles but dropped it after about 14 or 15 issues. Nguyen's art is ok but I don't love it as much as some and I kind of got tired of it. The biggest problem for me though was the story telling. I thought conceptually it was very good and the first arc started strong but not long after that it started to get just very boring for me and I didn't really care or feel any attachment to the characters. Maybe this is one of those books that just reads better in larger chunks.

I tried it, but didn't really care for it. It just isn't my cup of tea.

[The Flicker Fade]

I'll be interested in hearing everybody's opinion on Descender when it comes out. I was reading it in singles but dropped it after about 14 or 15 issues. Nguyen's art is ok but I don't love it as much as some and I kind of got tired of it. The biggest problem for me though was the story telling. I thought conceptually it was very good and the first arc started strong but not long after that it started to get just very boring for me and I didn't really care or feel any attachment to the characters. Maybe this is one of those books that just reads better in larger chunks.

Bad art, cliche story. Not for me.

[JPAR]

I'll be interested in hearing everybody's opinion on Descender when it comes out. I was reading it in singles but dropped it after about 14 or 15 issues. Nguyen's art is ok but I don't love it as much as some and I kind of got tired of it. The biggest problem for me though was the story telling. I thought conceptually it was very good and the first arc started strong but not long after that it started to get just very boring for me and I didn't really care or feel any attachment to the characters. Maybe this is one of those books that just reads better in larger chunks.

I'll skip it too.

[LordJulius]

While I was away, delivery person brought me some good stuff. I am happy with how my Marvel collection is coming along now that I've decided to get back into Marvel.

Awesome stuff there. Need to get Knightfall at some point too.

[awayne83]

Bad art, cliche story. Not for me.

Yeesh. With reviews like this, it's a wonder the series stays afloat.