Originally Posted by
AmazingSpiderFan
It's actually a terrible idea. In the comics Tandy is about as privileged as it gets. She's a blonde haired, blue-eyed white woman from the upper class. It's pretty hard to get more privileged than that -- having grown up white, upper class, and having several blonde-haired, blue-eyed sisters, I'd argue that upper class white women are even more privileged than upper class white men, since upper class white women tend to have their own money and, unlike upper class white males, are not expected to work. Like ever. At all. All three of my sisters treated their careers like hobbies, and abandoned those careers once they had kids because being a mommy was more fun (especially since they can afford nannies to do the unfun stuff like changing diapers). And my brothers-in-law are all expected to support them, they all feel entitled to being supported. They live lives of pure luxury from cradle to grave.
Meanwhile, Tyrone is about as unprivileged as it gets. Poor, black and male? That's about as bad as it gets in America. At least if you're poor, black and female you can probably get welfare, and are like 1000 times less likely to die or end up in prison. I mean if you look at law enforcement statistics, blacks are 3 times more likely to be stopped and frisked by cops, resulting in higher arrests rates, higher incarceration rates, etc. But what often goes unmentioned is that a man is 12 times more likely to be stopped and frisked than a woman. The entire law enforcement system in America is basically designed to keep black men down.
When you swap their backgrounds, you bring them much, much closer to being equally privileged. Tandy may be a poor, but she's white, female and attractive, which means she's a very low priority for police harassment and has a very good chance of making it out of poverty. Tyrone may be black, but he's male and upper-class, which insulates (if not immunizes) him from the worst effects of racism.
Basically Cloak and Dagger has already neutered its ability to speak meaningfully about privilege before the show has even started, which is a shame, because one thing the comic did very well was...talk about privilege. But this Tandy can't really dress down this Tyrone for his privilege when he can just shut her down with "What do you know about oppression, white girl?" And it's not like Tyrone can dress down Tandy for her privilege, because she's poor and he's rich, and she can just shut him down with accusations of class privilege.