Is Schism one the worst ideas ever that effected the franchise?

[AcesX1X]

She has far too much fun with humans to get rid of them. Although that assumes that Cyclops' side would actually be anti-human or just anti-integration.

on the first day of class, emma attacked the school with a hologram of a sentinel to teach the children a lesson.

[Optic Rage!]

Schism was more about both personal problems and lifestyle.I agree with Wolverine about how children can't be raised as soldiers they need a life too.Scott was right too about how there were dangers out there and they needed to be ready.But the thing is Scott never realized what Wolverine was trying to say.Wolverine didn't suggest to let kids go and have picnic everyday, the thing was Wolverine just wanted a friendlier and more better place and he wanted children to have a life.

TBF rigging the island they lived on with bombs and threatening to blow the whole place up probably wasn't the best approach to getting the kids to leave and reason with Scott.

[Mr. Brightside]

TBF rigging the island they lived on with bombs and threatening to blow the whole place up probably wasn't the best approach to getting the kids to leave and reason with Scott.

I want a what if? where they listen to him, the island blows up, the sentinel reheals as it was programmed to do, then it hunt the x-kids one by one to troll the adults. Seems plausable.

[JaggedFel]

Yet another person forgetting Icarus betraying the x-men to peddle wrong "facts" in an argument........

She was in charge and the kids died on her watch. She is a telepath maybe she should have paid more attention to what Icarus was up to.

that bus wasn't her fault, and the new x-men are all still alive last time i checked. they survived the purifiers, necrosha and the avengers assault on utopia.

The bus was her idea, does not take rocket science to figure a bus in broad daylight is an easy target. Honestly, the survival rate looks good because there were so many of them to start with.

[JaggedFel]

TBF rigging the island they lived on with bombs and threatening to blow the whole place up probably wasn't the best approach to getting the kids to leave and reason with Scott.

Yeah that was stupid

[Mr. Brightside]

She was in charge and the kids died on her watch. She is a telepath maybe she should have paid more attention to what Icarus was up to.

Then the argument would be "Oh, see!!! She's trespassing on their privacy!!! How is she a teacher!!!!" Emma and the students were all victims. Unless you support Rachel scanning all the kids minds over at the JGS and Emma n co. doing the same at the NXS. Blaming the victims............

The bus was her idea, does not take rocket science to figure a bus in broad daylight is an easy target. Honestly, the survival rate looks good because there were so many of them to start with.

It was also the idea that it would be a surprise and it was planned last minute unannounced to further trick anyone. It was a good plan with a traitor that ruined it.

[AcesX1X]

The bus was her idea, does not take rocket science to figure a bus in broad daylight is an easy target. Honestly, the survival rate looks good because there were so many of them to start with.

schools have buses, it's not emma's fault radical terrorists launched a missle at it. she was trying to escort them to safety.

[ExodusCloak]

The bus was her idea, does not take rocket science to figure a bus in broad daylight is an easy target. Honestly, the survival rate looks good because there were so many of them to start with.

Go and back and read those issues that came after. That idea succeeded, cemented Xavier's dream And Humans and mutant relations were better then ever. Nimrod knew this, made Stryker aware of the situation and they altered the future.

[Viteh]

How I miss Gillen's UXM. His run was just really good. It wasn't Journey Into Mystery good (that one is perfect), but it was still pretty damn good. I never felt it was too decompressed, or that anyone was acting out of character, or had plot induced stupidity. It was just great. I never felt like I had wasted my money buying UXM. Which is something I started feeling with Bendis right before BOTA.

[JaggedFel]

It was also the idea that it would be a surprise and it was planned last minute unannounced to further trick anyone. It was a good plan with a traitor that ruined it.

Really I dont think the surprise works if u are going to drive out the front door. U can just have purifiers sitting their in shifts with a rocket launcher waiting.

schools have buses, it's not emma's fault radical terrorists launched a missle at it. she was trying to escort them to safety.

This is mutant school though, I expect better then a standard bus. Most buses are never going to be under attack but the Xavier School Bus...

[JaggedFel]

How I miss Gillen's UXM. His run was just really good. It wasn't Journey Into Mystery good (that one is perfect), but it was still pretty damn good. I never felt it was too decompressed, or that anyone was acting out of character, or had plot induced stupidity. It was just great. I never felt like I had wasted my money buying UXM. Which is something I started feeling with Bendis right before BOTA.

I liked the Roster but to me it never lived up to the hype, the strongest x-men team ever assembled never won a fight.

[Mr. Brightside]

Really I dont think the surprise works if u are going to drive out the front door. U can just have purifiers sitting their in shifts with a rocket launcher waiting.

But they didn't/weren't until someone ratted them out. Keep trying to put blame on anyone not called icarus, it's pretty funny...

[Magneto]

X-Men mean being a family. So yeah, Aaron event simply is the opposite of what the X-Men are and should be stopped at once.

[AcesX1X]

This is mutant school though, I expect better then a standard bus. Most buses are never going to be under attack but the Xavier School Bus...

the plan would have worked, see exoduscloak response (which you ignored him completely btw).

[Mikekerr3]

Anyone who thinks Schism was one of the worst things to happen to the franchise clearly hasn't read much of the actual franchise. The idea was great, the execution, not so much. I've enjoyed it while it lasted but i'm ready to move on to a new story.

Wolverine written in character would have been one of Scott's biggest supporters in a schism like split, as written through all the decimation era. And i don't really buy Storm as a ''think of the children'' type character.

Ideologically the perfect split would have been Cyclops, Wolverine, Cable, Storm VS Xavier, Kitty, Emma and Kurt.

Xavier is the bone that stated sending children into combat with the very first X-book