A Community Review thread?

[Mighty Roman]

I've recently had an interesting idea for a new thread for the CBR CE forum. Recently, when I was asking about Warren Ellis' Thunderbolts, someone posted a link to a review he made on this forum. So I thought that maybe we should make a community review thread, where we review the CE's that we've been reading. Would anyone be up for such a thread?

[victorxd1999]

I used to do a feature where I would post a review every week (Thunderbolts was one of those) but I've neglected that feature the last 2 months. I might start it up again if I can find the time..

[Batmil]

I used to do a feature where I would post a review every week (Thunderbolts was one of those) but I've neglected that feature the last 2 months. I might start it up again if I can find the time..

Stop slacking my friend!

on: very nice idea indeed, I know there are some people here (for example Victor) who know how to write an excellent review! Maybe we can post some criteria for a review (sorta like a template) and have someone make a list of stuff people want reviewed and those who'd like to review it?

[Shinglepants]

I don't have a way with words like some of you fine people, so wouldn't contribute any actual reviews, but I would certainly read them. I did enjoy Victors reviews when they were happening.

[NZ_InFerno]

Its a great idea, the format of victors(and others) reviews in the weekly review threads was pretty good reading with a couple of pics and a paragraph or two.

It could either be all in one thread eg. Comminity Review thread or individual threads per review eg. Community Review: Planetary.

Here's certainly been posters who write mini reviews in the various threads already, there's talent out there.

[Diamond]

I used to help victor whenever he couldn't make it on time, but between university and my writing in another blog (check it out if you speak Spanish! http://www.zonanegativa.com/) I haven't had a lot of time lately. I'd try to get more reviews if victor finds some time, though. Not that I want to put pressure on him, buuuuuut...

Its a great idea, the format of victors(and others) reviews in the weekly review threads was pretty good reading with a couple of pics and a paragraph or two.

It could either be all in one thread eg. Comminity Review thread or individual threads per review eg. Community Review: Planetary.

Here's certainly been posters who write mini reviews in the various threads already, there's talent out there.

I think it's better to stick with victor's formula of individual threads. A main thread would get too convoluted.