Should Wanda go on trial for for her actions? Or should Doom go on trial for his actions?

[Kirby Krackle]

Whatever. I know I'm not going to change anybody's outlook. If you want to be mad at some made up people, go right ahead. I'm sure it will serve
you well in life.

I've never and I will never understood how anyone could hold a personal grudge with a fictional character. It's an odd concept to me.

[AcesX1X]

if wanda maximoff were to go to trial, i think it should be a PANEL of judges and not one singular judge. it should also be international.

for the defense, i think matt murdock is the best to represent her. she-hulk cannot be on her counsel since she was in particular victimized by scarlet's mad attack on the avengers.

for the prosecution, i would like to suggest vange whedon. she is a mutant and one of the lucky few to retain her powers after the m-day attack.

[dragonmp93]

But it is the truth. Did you come to CBR at first because you were having a good time learning your way around the Marvel Universe and wanted
to talk to other enthusiastic people, or did you look for a bunch of angry folks who seem to hate the comics and are ready to fight with other fans
over this stuff? I think the enthusiasm is great. One of the most awesome ways to pass an afternoon is reading a bunch of comics and getting
excited about what happens, but why allow something to fester in your heart for years and build up a huge resentment? Aren't you actually ruining
the experience for yourself by holding onto these things?

You know, for me, the resentment is part of the fun.

I've never and I will never understood how anyone could hold a personal grudge with a fictional character. It's an odd concept to me.

Well, its better than holding a grudge against a real person, isnt it ?.

[Mary Jay]

I've never and I will never understood how anyone could hold a personal grudge with a fictional character. It's an odd concept to me.

And still it happens all the time in so many threads. We all have favorite characters which we love, I think it's only natural that we get invested in their story.

But I admit I don't understand the grudge that some people hold against fictional characters as if they'd been personally offended by them.

[Knives]

I feel sorry for any character that Bendis writes but does not have a great love for. If he loves the character they are all set, if he doesn't they might as well get the bandages ready.

I fully agree you can see when he hates a character.

But I think it happens to many writers.

I think people are exaggerating about the hatred of fans for Wanda.

[Ravin' Ray]

I think people are exaggerating about the hatred of fans for Wanda.

if you consider the fact that a heated Wanda trial thread was started in the X-books forum before this…

[Star_Jammer]

if you consider the fact that a heated Wanda trial thread was started in the X-books forum before this…

And the many threads before that.

In recent memory (read:a few months ago), there was a total of 5 threads across the forums dedicated to Wanda hate. Not exaggerated at all.

[dragonmp93]

And the many threads before that.

In recent memory (read:a few months ago), there was a total of 5 threads across the forums dedicated to Wanda hate. Not exaggerated at all.

Well, not in this fórum, at least.

[Emma's Midriff]

Wanda didn't get a lot of hate until Remender got ahold of her and made her unbearable.

[Ravin' Ray]

Wanda didn't get a lot of hate until Remender got ahold of her and made her unbearable.

This statement gives credence to the position that it all lies with the writer, and that give Wanda a writer who would set her on a path of full contrition and redemption then the hate would subside.

[Iron Maiden]

Wanda didn't get a lot of hate until Remender got ahold of her and made her unbearable.

Nah. It was just added a couple of logs to a bonfire that was already blazing. A lot of readers didn't accept that in CC it was obvious that Marvel would not pursue the trial route.

[People Of The Earth]

Well, not in this fórum, at least.

Depends.
The X-Boards have been hating her literally for YEARS, and from time to time, it pours in this forum as well.
The CBR reboot made it less potent than before, but it's there.

[Knives]

if you consider the fact that a heated Wanda trial thread was started in the X-books forum before this…

Think it's normal some fans have something against Wanda or Steve Rogers because of what happened in some previous events as usual some do not like Scott.

When you really like a character do you identify becomes attached to everything he is when something or someone who destroys or threatens to destroy everything he represents is normal that some get angry. For example Namor during AVX attacked Wakanda and free Thanos and the other villains was responsible for the destruction of the city so fans of Black Panther should not feel much affection for Namor.

But do not think most want his death or that she does not have a chance at redemption. Steve Rogers and Wanda are heroes who have saved many lives and saved the world but want them to account for their errors in judgment is far from irrational.

Even though I am Scott fan and think he is right in his crusade does not mean he should not be judged by their mistakes (although I believe it would be an unfair trial).

[Emma's Midriff]

This statement gives credence to the position that it all lies with the writer, and that give Wanda a writer who would set her on a path of full contrition and redemption then the hate would subside.

I think so. In any case, I think it might have been a bad idea to, after an event where the X-men were forced to play the villains in order for the Avengers to be the heroes, to have the person who has done more damage to the X-men than almost anyone else insult the X-men the one X-man's face in front of the grave of their dead leader.

Not the way to build good will with fans.

Nah. It was just added a couple of logs to a bonfire that was already blazing. A lot of readers didn't accept that in CC it was obvious that Marvel would not pursue the trial route.

It didn't help that CC didn't make any sense. I certainly didn't notice a lot of Wanda-hate until Uncanny Avengers started. The worst I saw was people saying it was Wanda's fault the Phoenix showed up during AvX (which is true).

[People Of The Earth]

This statement gives credence to the position that it all lies with the writer, and that give Wanda a writer who would set her on a path of full contrition and redemption then the hate would subside.

Any writer doing that would be accused of throwing the mutants under the bus and marysueing the character.
Look at how CC was - and still is ! - downright rejected and ignored by some fans who are angry with Wanda.
She can't say nor do anything without some people badmouthing her.