Originally Posted by
Sardorim
No, Rachel dominated her in a fight. However she turned her back after beating No Girl to focus on Spider-Man and No Girl got in a cheap shot and assaulted Rachel from behind to erase her memory of who Peter was. It was all in all very bad writing and one of the worst story arcs in X-History as the writer made it a point to badmouth and demonize the X-Men while having Peter be a total hypocritical moron that was way out of character.
The writer also wanted to push No Girl at the cost of Rachel, Storm and the such and it backfired hard as the writer hit them with the idiot stick and wrote them way OOC to try and prop up the trash character that is No Girl.
It was cowardly and pathetic, No Girl should have been expelled for what she did or at least given more than detention as Rachel ended up being 100% right and No Girl was aiding Sinister which got people hurt, caused a ton of damage and No Girl was unapologetic for her actions.