I think the design is solid, but also that Chiang's stylized art is a pretty bad fit for it.
I could never get over Green Arrow's Robin Hood hat. I do however agree about this thread producing some solid illustration of the subjectiveness of style, as a lot of the later posts have looked pretty awful for me.
Question-Sage-Promo-2.jpg
Does The Question's face mask count as part of his costume? If so, he's a shoo-in for this thread, even although he's not strictly a DC comics design job.