Favorite Bat-Family member

[Jackalope89]

I think Bruce suffers from the “snap-back” effect more than the other characters, even when their attempts to grow up have... issues.

Bruce is more dependent on “style” of characterization for making him appear dynamic.

Dick can actually claim to have “grown” into something else for just about every decade in the modern era: from Robin as a sidekick to Robin in college as his own man to Robin as Titans leader to Nightwing as Titan’s leader to Nightwing as a solo hero to Batman to Agent Grayson.

While not as long as Dick's, Jason can claim similar (when not under a writer who, once again, puts him at odds with Bruce while rivaling Bruce as Edgelord). There was the redhead phase while under Morrison but, that's best left forgotten and left out completely.

[Stars & Stripes]

Seeing as Harper/Bluebird wasn't on the poll when first made, I just chose Kate.

[Superboy-Prime]

I don't see Terry McGinnis anywhere. C'mon, who wouldn't pick Batman Beyond?

[MajorHoy]

I don't see Terry McGinnis anywhere. C'mon, who wouldn't pick Batman Beyond?

. . . raises hand . . .

[Superboy-Prime]

. . . raises hand . . .

You're saying you would or wouldn't pick him?

[MajorHoy]

You're saying you would or wouldn't pick him?

Wouldn't necessarily pick him.

He'd be much, much lower on my priority list. Not even in my Top Ten of "Bat-Family members".

[Superboy-Prime]

Wouldn't necessarily pick him.

He'd be much, much lower on my priority list. Not even in my Top Ten of "Bat-Family members".

I'm talking more about personal enjoyment rather than priority. He's not in main continuity after all. But, uh, Terry is definitely in the top six Bat-Family members. Just below Jason Todd, Bruce Wayne, Dick Grayson, Damian Wayne, and Tim Drake.

[Tzigone]

Yeah, Terry's not really on my radar. I mean, I did like the show at first (well, the Terry part, nothing that happened with the original characters). Never read the comic because I was done with the idea by then. But he's alternate-reality-future version to me, not part of the family in this world in main DC reality (no matter what DC says), and certainly not of the same family as the others, given the difference in eras .

[Superboy-Prime]

Yeah, Terry's not really on my radar. I mean, I did like the show at first (well, the Terry part, nothing that happened with the original characters). Never read the comic because I was done with the idea by then. But he's alternate-reality-future version to me, not part of the family in this world in main DC reality (no matter what DC says), and certainly not of the same family as the others, given the difference in eras .

That's true. Jace Fox feels like canon Terry McGinnis to me.

[MajorHoy]

I'm talking more about personal enjoyment rather than priority. He's not in main continuity after all. But, uh, Terry is definitely in the top six Bat-Family members. Just below Jason Todd, Bruce Wayne, Dick Grayson, Damian Wayne, and Jason Todd.

On your list maybe, but not mine.
(Hell, I voted for James Gordon on this poll.)

And on your list, did you just name both the post-CoIE and pre-CoIE versions of Jason Todd?

[Superboy-Prime]

On your list maybe, but not mine.
(Hell, I voted for James Gordon on this poll.)

And on your list, did you just name both the post-CoIE and pre-CoIE versions of Jason Todd?

Thought I put Tim Drake there.

You voted for Jimbo? Commissioner Gordon is your favorite Bat-Family member? For realzies?

[MajorHoy]

Thought I put Tim Drake there.

You voted for Jimbo? Commissioner Gordon is your favorite Bat-Family member? For realzies?

I didn't know there were people who actually used the word "realzies" . . .

[Superboy-Prime]

I didn't know there were people who actually used the word "realzies" . . .

What's the use in acting all serious on a comic book forum? Being totally tubular is the way to go.

[MajorHoy]

REMINDER: Thread originally began in June 2015.
-------------------------------------------------

With 241 people having voted,

* Dick Grayson = 79 votes
* Jason Todd = 39 votes
* Bruce Wayne = 38 votes
* Tim Drake = 20 votes
* Cassandra Cain = 15 votes
* Barbara Gordon = 12 votes
* Stephanie Brown = 10 votes
* Selina Kyle = 9 votes
* Alfred Pennyworth = 6 votes
* Kate Kane = 6 votes
* Helena Bertinelli = 4 votes

All other choices still have fewer than four votes.

[MajorHoy]

REMINDER: Thread originally began in June 2015.
-------------------------------------------------

With 249 people having voted,

* Dick Grayson = 82 votes
* Jason Todd = 39 votes
* Bruce Wayne = 39 votes
* Tim Drake = 22 votes
* Cassandra Cain = 15 votes
* Barbara Gordon = 13 votes
* Stephanie Brown = 10 votes
* Selina Kyle = 9 votes
* Alfred Pennyworth = 6 votes
* Kate Kane = 6 votes
* Helena Bertinelli = 5 votes

All other choices still have four or fewer votes.