Originally Posted by
elgrey
Just my opinion, obviously, but I don't think the ball is in Scott's court on the issue because he is not the only person who has made decisions that have led to the current situation. The Avengers chose to have him incarcerated without trial for a crime he committed as a consequence of being possessed due to their interference with a cosmic entity. Then they chose to leave him in a prison where they knew his life was in imminent danger instead of taking him off to Avengers Tower or putting him into the custody of the other X-Men or finding some other solution that didn't involve risking his life. Both the X-Men as represented by Logan and the Avengers as represented by Tony Stark, instead chose to walk away from a place they knew to be corrupt and dangerous to mutants and to leave Scott locked up in it to be murdered. Scott chose to become a fugitive instead of waiting around to be shived and is now a wanted criminal according to them and to S.H.I.E.L.D. although other people who have murdered people while possessed are not considered wanted criminals by the Avengers or S.H.I.E.L.D., ironically including some Avengers.
Scott and his team is doing what the X-Men have always done - trying to get to newly emerging mutants before their powers damage others or they are attacked by anti-mutant forces and then to help train them to control their powers. Him doing so has become particularly fraught with danger because he is being targeted by the evil sentinel controller who keeps siccing giant death robots on him, which can lead to damage to people and property, and because the Avengers have shown up mob-handed to grab him, including take a Hulk into a small Australian suburb, and because there has been a conspicuous lack of anyone else bothering to rescue newly emerging mutants from their powers manifesting/trigger happy policemen, except for Kitty and the O5, who are now also working out of the NXS.
There are several things other people could do. A team from the JGS could make it their priority to assist/rescue/contain newly emerging mutants whose powers might be dangerous/who might be persecuted by government forces or local police. They are the first X-Men who have not done that in addition to running a school, after all. Then Scott could stop risking arrest trying to save mutants because someone else would be doing the job.
The Avengers could choose to stop declaring Scott a wanted criminal for committing a crime while possessed, while being happy to hang out with Avengers who have committed crimes while possessed whom they do not feel the need to hunt down and arrest. They could even do something to help mutants themselves while the Uncanny Avengers team that Rogers formed for that purpose is unavoidably detained off-world and so unable to fulfill the assisting mutants part of its mandate. S.H.I.E.L.D. could stop arresting/interrogating/intimidating Scott's pupils in their pursuit of imprisoning Scott, which might calm things down considerably.
The way I see it Scott is the only person in the equation who is doing what Xavier-following X-Men have always done, he's just having to do it out of a grotty mutant torture facility instead of a nice comfortable school because the Avengers chose to declare him a criminal and the other X-Men have all turned their backs on him.
Had he not been denounced as a criminal for committing a crime while possessed, there could have been some conversations between Scott and the Avengers about what was going to happen in the wake of new mutants being born and some mutually agreed policy could possibly have been reached about how to proceed. It's very difficult to see how that conversation can happen now after the Avengers have been visibly indifferent to giant robots trying to kill Scott while happy to put their resources into trying to hunt him down and recapture him, and being okay about S.H.I.E.L.D. terrorizing kids to do it. It's very difficult to see how their actions could in any way lead him to find them trustworthy. Especially as they have consistently refused to accept that there is currently one law for mutants and one law for humans and that by upholding a law which, while not being inherently prejudiced against mutants, is being implemented far too often by people with an anti-mutant bias they risk becoming part of the problem. Eva told them that to their faces back in UXM v3 #3 of how she was attacked just for being a mutant and they ignored her completely, preferring to arrest Scott than to do anything to make the world a safer place for emerging mutants.
Realistically, if Scott is in a place where he feels that he is the only advocate that mutants have and that if he does nothing mutants will die, and that he can't trust the law to protect them because it hasn't in the past, then the people who have been failing to make him feel otherwise have to shoulder some of the blame.
The Avengers have only been consistent about wanting to arrest him. They haven't suggested any alternative to his methods or given him assurances about caring to guarantee the safety of new mutants themselves. Nor have the JGS. S.H.I.E.L.D. still have sentinels, a weapon designed to hunt down and kill mutants. They could stop having sentinels as part of their arsenal. They could make a public commitment to safeguarding mutants. Those would not be unreasonable actions if they really do believe that mutants are entitled to the same rights as humans. But they haven't really done anything, as yet, to make a mutant who has been declared an outlaw and who wants to keep mutants safe feel that he has anything to gain from working with them. Who, really, is going to expect a man to submit himself to the authority of people who are happy to work with murderers but call him a criminal if he doesn't want to wait around in the corrupt prison they left him in to be murdered? Who really expects Scott to perceive the Avengers as people with any moral authority whatsoever? Or the JGS? Given that Logan nearly murdered Scott himself in prison, never mind the matter of all Logan's past crimes?
From Scott's perspective, if he stops doing what he's doing, mutants die. I would think the first step to be taken by people who want Scott to stop doing what he's doing, would be to give clear proof that an infrastructure is in place more efficient than his that will guarantee the safety and protection of new mutants and will give them training afterwards. Otherwise, then he is all that new mutants have to keep them safe and therefore to not keep doing what he is doing, from Scott's perspective, would be a dereliction of his duty that will inevitably lead to mutant and human casualties that it lies within his power to prevent.