Time to Create an All New Brotherhood to fight the All New X-Men

[The Big G]

Last week we learned that Oya and Genesis will be joining the All New X-Men. While a step in the right direction, we want more of the true X-Kids/Students. So what do Teenage Heroes need more than proper sex ed? Rivals! Atagonists! Bad Guys?

So I present too you my idea for an ALL NEW Brotherhood of Mutants. Former X-Students left to fend for themselves. The X-Men have failed them one too many times. And because of it they had to suffer at the scientifcally horrendus hands of Mr. Sinsiter. (Gillen's version)

Hope Summers
Hellion
Pixie as Nightmare
Indra
Surge
Mercury
Rockslide

[Anduinel]

I could go for most of that team so long as they're treated as antagonists due to differing idealogies and not actual villains. Rockslide's never going to turn on the X-Men, though. If he forgave Summers after Messiah Complex, he's a lifer. Have Dust as the elemental power instead and I think it works better. Also not sure the NXM kids would follow Hope; she never really bothered forging a bond with any of them.

For more of a typically villainous Brotherhood, I'd likely pick:

Quire - masterminds the whole thing; that business about caring for other people didn't really work out for him, and I can see him being disillusioned enough to go full villain this time
Animax - girl is awesome and has so many issues, let's have her work them out via violence
Broo - this one hurts to write, but I still feel like he's destined to go dark side
Match - he's always been a hot head and tends to charge into things chin first
Purple Girl - fangirl turned political terrorist, great for creating human shields
Velocidad - guy's probably got 20 years or less left on the planet thanks to his powers; doubt he has his head on straight

[The Big G]

I could go for most of that team so long as they're treated as antagonists due to differing idealogies and not actual villains. Rockslide's never going to turn on the X-Men, though. If he forgave Summers after Messiah Complex, he's a lifer. Have Dust as the elemental power instead and I think it works better. Also not sure the NXM kids would follow Hope; she never really bothered forging a bond with any of them.

True, but I think of the situation for them was dire enough, they could follow hope. That's why had this intial idea of them being captured by Sinister, and they rally together to escape.

[Grey]

I like the idea of a new brotherhoods for the anxm

[AcesX1X]

blackbolt, medusa, gorgon, triton, lockjaws

[Darkgreed]

Dust
Transonic
Velocidad
Tin man
Surge
Match
Hazmat
Finesse

[nx01a]

New Brotherhood...
Tempus
Raze [if he sadly still exists]
Quire
Animax

Either them or throw all of Bendis' new students into a Brotherhood.

blackbolt, medusa, gorgon, triton, lockjaws

Perfect.

[ButterRum]

Kenji Uedo, plz. A shame with whatever happened to him.

[Harpsikord]

Hmmm.

Eva Bell
Kenji Uedo
Surge
Mach 2
Match
Quentin Quire
and Animax.

Kenji Uedo, plz. A shame with whatever happened to him.

What even DID happen to him after Storm's solo?

[Rising7]

I would follow suit with the O5 and include a young Toad and Blob.
Maybe Ultimate Toad now that Ultimate crossover characters are on the table.
Led by Mudbug, to fulfill the obvious inevitability of his destiny to rise to the stature of top shelf X-villain!

[Ambaryerno]

Last week we learned that Oya and Genesis will be joining the All New X-Men. While a step in the right direction, we want more of the true X-Kids/Students. So what do Teenage Heroes need more than proper sex ed? Rivals! Atagonists! Bad Guys?

So I present too you my idea for an ALL NEW Brotherhood of Mutants. Former X-Students left to fend for themselves. The X-Men have failed them one too many times. And because of it they had to suffer at the scientifcally horrendus hands of Mr. Sinsiter. (Gillen's version)

Hope Summers
Hellion
Pixie as Nightmare
Indra
Surge
Mercury
Rockslide

Keep the NXM out of this!

[Kisinith]

Beast
Havok
Aurora
Tempus
Kenji Uedo
Quentin Quire

I'm ok with having a new team of Brotherhood to oppose the X-Men but... I'd rather see the Hellfire Club rehabilitated. Say by Shaw, Pryor, Selene, Shadow King and Lady Mastermind (Martinique). Their first act can be to horribly dismember every remnant of the brats.

[ciscostudent561]

Toad
Blob
Mystique
Pyro
Avalanche
Bendis

[donpricetag]

I was hoping Magneto would be given a Brotherhood boook. But I think the anti X-Men super villain team notion is played. Being bad for the sake of being bad is really outdated. I always hated the "Evil" part of the name. Besides, Magneto's way of doing things don't really work with Xavier's dream, but a revamped version of the Brotherhood that takes the place of X-Force? Would have worked for me.

The current roster would have been perfect IMO, sans Psylocke and insert Polaris. Maybe add Quinton Quire who might get a kick out of being an outlaw. Quinton with Magneto as a mentor? He'd probably turn into the next Magneto. Hellion maybe? I always thought his growth was stunted after Schism.

[donpricetag]

Toad
Blob
Mystique
Pyro
Avalanche
Bendis

LOL

If I had to make a roster out of what's available now?
Exodus
Frenzy
Toad
Mimic
Prime Sentinel

And they need a motivation beyond being bad and fighting he X-Men. My roster has some pseudo villains that have been labeled good or even X-Men as well as villains. In other words, give them a story beyond attacking the X-Mansion. For instance, their goals aren't global domination or robbing a bank, but as they are trying to accomplish thier objectives, it comes into conflict with X-Men and that's how the melee/ rivalry sparks between the factions.