What an underwhelming crowned queen, arguably the least deserving crowning in Drag Race HerStory. Now let me be clear, I don't think Trixie is a bad person to have as a crowned queen, she's living Ru's message, and is doing big things; in ten years time when no-one knows how she won, her post-show record will imply she was a good choice... BUT... on Drag Race she is utterly underwhelming. So it's maybe more accurate to say she's deserving of the crown, just not deserving based on the season.
I'm seeing a lot of people compare her victory to Sasha Velour's and that bugs me. A LOT. 1) Sasha was a very strong contender throughout Season 9. She was in the Top 3 first episode, was very high for many challenges (including Snatch Game, the Roast, the Make Over), she won the Puppets and she should have won the Rainbow Ball. She had the best unicorn, was the only one praised on the ribbon performance, her cowboy killed and her rainbow flag was EPIC. Shea's dress was stunning, it was gag worthy, yes it was "over, you are overrrrr" but it had NOTHING to do with a rainbow. As Michelle said "not one colour of the rainbow. Not one." How can Bob be in the bottom 2 for using cardboard not paper for the Book Ball (when it's part of the book), but Shea won for completely ignoring the criteria??? Anyway, point is Sasha did great throughout the season, Trixie did not. So the comparison already doesn't work. 2) Sasha had two wins and no bottom 2, Trixie had two wins and TWO times in the bottom. She has the lowest score card of any other winner. The same is not true of Sasha, not even close. I believe Jinx and Bebe (before Trixie) had the lowest, with two wins and one time bottom 2. Also Trixie is the ONLY crowned queen to be in the bottom twice. 3) ignoring the fact that Sasha should have won the Rainbow Ball and then had three wins and the top score going into the finale, it doesn't matter. She went in NOT the front-runner (as did Trixie); and that is almost more exciting. And then Sasha had to lipsync. She went in the underdog, the one with the less good score, so basically the only way she could win was delivering not just a bloody good lipsync, she'd have to deliver one of the best lipsyncs of the show... AND SHE DID AND THEN SOME. She gave us (arguably) the most iconic lipsync in 11 Seasons. THAT'S how she got the crown. She just didn't just "do well", she slayyyyyed.
The same is not true of Trixie. Shangela did the best in the challenge, she did the best on the final runway and Kennedy did the best in the lipsync. Trixie didn't even have the score card to fall back on; HELL Trixie didn't even get the most votes from the other queens (she got 7 points, Kennedy got 8 points)... it just... ugh! Had Trixie slayed the challenge, the runway, got the most votes and the lipsync, fine, not ideal, but fine. It would have redeemed the choice. But considering Ben's score, considering Shangela... it just wasn't good enough that Trixie didn't even steal it. She's not like Sasha, Sasha stole it fair and square, she turned it out. Trixie didn't. Nothing she did was iconic. HOW is she a crowned queen and ye not be iconic at any moment? Shangela had Mariah, that bubble on the runway, her lipsyncs. Ben had... well, everything. Trixie's best moments were the Fake Bitch, the red for filth bookworm and... I mean, that was it. And neither of them were "iconic." Trixie is brilliant at comments to the camera, humour off set, but... I just think it's a great shame the crowned queen is so underwhelming IN THE SHOW. Outside, fine. But in the show, she wasn't first, she wasn't even second, she was tied third with Bebe. In fact if we go off money won in the run up, Trixie had $0. Shangela $25,000, Bebe and Kennedy $10,000. In every possible way, Trixie did not have the win. Even Aja had $2,000
SIDE NOTE: I don't blame the "Jury of Your Q****s" because that wasn't about Shangela or Trixie, that was there to stop Bebe. It makes perfect sense. It's the only way to make sure Bebe didn't get into the final two, because every queen would give the chance to someone who didn't already have the crown. |