All New Marvel Collected Editions

[bob.schoonover]

Incredible Hulk Vol 3 fell down to rank 78 this year.



My number #2 of Classic Hawkeye ranked at 599 in this poll. That's out of 635 total. My only rationalization is that the mapping for Hawkeye split the volumes weird and everyone voted for the Solo Avengers era Hawkeye. And that ranked all the way up at...436.

I would never ask TigerEyes or Omar to go through the work of marking all the ties out, but I am curious how bunched up the bottom of the list is. That is, how many are at 10 or fewer points, how many are below 50 points, stuff like that. What I really want to know is how many sickos like me were voting in the obscure X-Men sector of the selection . . .

[Raffi Ol D'Arcy]

Incredible Hulk Vol 3 fell down to rank 78 this year.



My number #2 of Classic Hawkeye ranked at 599 in this poll. That's out of 635 total. My only rationalization is that the mapping for Hawkeye split the volumes weird and everyone voted for the Solo Avengers era Hawkeye. And that ranked all the way up at...436.

Where are you getting the chart positions below 60 from? Am I missing something? Are these available somewhere?

[bob.schoonover]

Where are you getting the chart positions below 60 from? Am I missing something? Are these available somewhere?

Patreon subscribers got the whole list. I won't post the whole thing but I'll happily look up a couple of options if you want - the list is just rank-ordered, so there's no real guessing how many points anything had or how much "space" there is between, say, 500th and 300th place.

[The Lucky One]

Patreon subscribers got the whole list. I won't post the whole thing but I'll happily look up a couple of options if you want - the list is just rank-ordered, so there's no real guessing how many points anything had or how much "space" there is between, say, 500th and 300th place.

If you’re willing to share, I’d be curious to know roughly where New Mutants by Zeb Wells charted. It’s a fantastic, highly underrated (and surprisingly impactful to X-Men continuity) run that’s always my number one vote, but I suspect most folks missed it the first time around and don’t know how great it is.

[bob.schoonover]

If you’re willing to share, I’d be curious to know roughly where New Mutants by Zeb Wells charted. It’s a fantastic, highly underrated (and surprisingly impactful to X-Men continuity) run that’s always my number one vote, but I suspect most folks missed it the first time around and don’t know how great it is.

146. It's a shame the tpbs are pricey (at least they were when I last looked) because it seems like something I'd like to read in some fashion

[Raffi Ol D'Arcy]

Patreon subscribers got the whole list. I won't post the whole thing but I'll happily look up a couple of options if you want - the list is just rank-ordered, so there's no real guessing how many points anything had or how much "space" there is between, say, 500th and 300th place.

Ah, that makes sense. Thank you Bob

Could you please let me know how my non-top 60 charted:

Planet of the Apes Magazine
Captain Mar-Vell Vol. 2
Marvel Universe by Lee Weeks
Captain Britain & MI13
Spider-Man Noir

And, if not too much trouble, also these:

GA Captain America Vol. 3
Agent Venom SpaceKnight
Hickman's SHIELD
Iron Fist: Return to K'un-Lun
Shang -Chi Modern
Iron Man by Micheline Vol. 2

[Rincewind]

Ah, that makes sense. Thank you Bob

Could you please let me know how my non-top 60 charted:

And, if not too much trouble, also these:

Planet of the Apes Magazine RANK 188
Captain Mar-Vell Vol. 2 RANK 182
Marvel Universe by Lee Weeks RANK 452
Captain Britain & MI13 RANK 125
Spider-Man Noir RANK 310



GA Captain America Vol. 3 RANK 283
Agent Venom SpaceKnight RANK 189
Hickman's SHIELD RANK 73
Iron Fist: Return to K'un-Lun RANK 565
Shang -Chi Modern RANK 352
Iron Man by Micheline Vol. 2 RANK 211

[Rincewind]

FYI, the bottom 10 choices that received 0 votes are:

Chill (1971-1972)
Atlas Era Jungle Adventure
Captain America: Sam Wilson (2015-2018)
Hawkeye: Clint Barton, The Return (2006-2011)
Marvel Universe by Reginald Hudlin
SHIELD: Agents of SHIELD by Waid & Guggenheim (2014-2016)
Spider-Island (ASM + Companion)
Squadron Supreme (2013-2017)
The Human Torch & The Thing by Slott & Kesel
X-Men: ResurrXion - Astonishing X-Men (2017 - 2018)

[Raffi Ol D'Arcy]

Planet of the Apes Magazine RANK 188
Captain Mar-Vell Vol. 2 RANK 182
Marvel Universe by Lee Weeks RANK 452
Captain Britain & MI13 RANK 125
Spider-Man Noir RANK 310



GA Captain America Vol. 3 RANK 283
Agent Venom SpaceKnight RANK 189
Hickman's SHIELD RANK 73
Iron Fist: Return to K'un-Lun RANK 565
Shang -Chi Modern RANK 352
Iron Man by Micheline Vol. 2 RANK 211

Many thanks Rincewind

Very very surprised how low some of these ranked, not even making the top 150, let alone the top 100. Previous chart regulars such as Captain Britain & MI13 and IM by Micheline Vol. 2 were way low. I'm personally tired of having the Top 60 swamped with X-titles.