All New Marvel Collected Editions

[NZ_InFerno]

Got the DnA GOTG Omnibus last week after about 4 weeks shipping from the UK(wtf) and it was worth the wait! Great upgrade from the HCs. Dare I say that the quality seems to be just as good as a couple of years ago before the thin-paper gate.

Looking forward to reading it, and the Hickman Avengers/Secret Wars OHCs I got as well.

I think I've re-caught the comics bug, as I won an Auction for a book I'd sold off previously

[SJNeal]

I think I've re-caught the comics bug, as I won an Auction for a book I'd sold off previously

Welcome (back) to the dark side...

[TomSlick]

This was my TOP TEN:

1. Daredevil by Denny O’Neill, Klaus Janson, David Mazzucchelli & Others (DD #192-218, #220-225, Marvel Fanfare #27, MTU #140-141, Moon Knight #13 & any other relevant Marvel Fanfare & MTU appearances)



2. Captain America (Silver Age) Vol. 3 (#149-192, Annuals)

3. Ultimate Spider-Man Vol. 2

4. New Avengers by Bendis Vol. 2

5. Daredevil Shadowland (Dark Reign The List: Daredevil, Daredevil Vol. 2 #501-512 & After The Fall, Shadowland #1-5, Shadowland Tie-ins: Blood On The Streets #1-4; Moon Knight #1-3; Power Man #1-4; Street Heroes – 7 issues; Thunderbolts #148-149, and Daredevil Reborn #1-4 and possibly material from DD #500 and pgs. 4-5 from Black Panther: The Man Without Fear #513)




6. Daredevil (Silver Age) Vol. 2



7. Wolverine Vol. 2 (#11-31, Annuals, MCP appearances & other mini-series)

8. Iron Man by David Michelinie Vol. 2 (#216-250, Annuals 8,9)

9. Iron Fist (Marvel Premiere #15-25, Iron Fist #1-15, MTU #63-64 and any relevant MCP & MTU appearances)

10. Golden Age Captain America Vol. 2 (#13-24)


Each year, I will keep voting for the Daredevil run by Denny O’Neill, Klaus Janson, David Mazzucchelli & Others and just maybe one day it will make it.

We had a lot of similarities. I think I'd like to see the cover for issue # 200 serve as a potential omnibus for DD

[OldManBrian]

Didn't have time to post this earlier, but here was my votes, where they finished in parentheses.

1) Spider-Man: Alien Costume Saga/DeFalco (NR)
2) Punisher by Rucka (42)
3) Thunderbolts by Busiek (11)
4) Civil War v1 (NR)
5) Shadowland (31)
6) Ultimate Spider-Man v2 (13)
7) Runaways by BKV (44)
8) Amazing Spider-Man v4 (5)
9) Uncanny X-Men v4 (1)
10) Daredevil by Nocenti (12)

I was surprised Civil War was unranked. I'd love a set of this under the condition it's all placed in proper chronological reading order, unlike the box set that was separated by different titles. I also expect it would sell very well.

[Yaggi_Rck]

Here are my votes:

1. X-FORCE by Kyle & Yost (#57)
2.AMAZING SPIDER-MAN by Straczynski & Romita Jr. (#39)
3. WOLVERINE by Jason Aaron vol.2 (#33 TIE)
4. SECRET AVENGERS by Rick Remender (N/A)
5. X-MEN by Brian Michael Bendis vol.1 (N/A)
6. WOLVERINE by Hama & Silvestri (#38 TIE)
7. DAREDEVIL by Nocenti vol. 1 (#12)
8. ULTIMATE SPIDER-MAN by Bendis vol. 2 (#13)
9. ULTIMATE X-MEN by Mark Millar (N/A)
10. VENOM by Rick Remender (N/A)

This was definitely FUN

[Captain Craig]

You do realise you lost 2 votes as the Secret Ballot did not take into consideration reprints? This was all about new Omnibuses.

Well I do now. Eagerness to vote=lack of fully recalling the rules.

[Dougtron]

I'd buy 44 of the Omnis on the list. I suppose I'm easy to please.

1 Uncanny X-Men Vol. 4 AKA by Claremont/JRJR - Buy
2 New Mutants, Volume 1 - Buy
3 X-Men: Post-Massacre / Pre-Fall - Buy
4 Incredible Hulk by Peter David, Vol. 1 - Would buy if we knew we were getting the whole run.
5 Amazing Spider-Man, Vol. 4 - Buy
6 Excalibur, Vol. 1 by Claremont/Davis - Buy
7 Fantastic Four, Vol. 4 - Buy
8 Avengers, Vol. 3 - Pass
9 New Avengers by Bendis, Vol. 2 - Buy
10 Punisher Max by Garth Ennis, Vol. 1 - Pass
11 Thunderbolts by Kurt Busiek, Vol. 1 - Buy
12 Daredevil by Ann Nocenti, Vol. 1 - Pass
13 Ultimate Spider-Man, Vol. 2 - Pass
14 Miracle Man - Buy
15 X-Factor (2006) by Peter David, Vol. 1 - Buy
16 ROM, Vol. 1 - Maybe a buy
17 New Warriors, Vol. 2 - Buy
18 Infinity War - Buy
19 Avengers by Roger Stern, Vol. 1 - Buy
20 Doctor Strange (Silver Age), Vol. 2 - Buy
21 Moon Knight by Moench, Vol. 1 - Maybe
22 Sensational She-Hulk by John Byrne - Buy
23 Incredible Hulk (Silver Age), Vol. 2 - Pass
24 Amazing Spider-Man by Micheline and Bagley - Buy
25 X-Men Legacy by Mike Carey, Vol. 1 - Buy
26 Ghost Rider (1973), Vol. 1 - Pass
27 Namor The Sub-Mariner by John Byrne - Pass
28 Wolverine (1988), Vol. 2 - Buy
29 Spectacular Spider-Man by JM Dematteis - Buy
30 She-Hulk by Dan Slott - Buy
31 X-Factor (1986) - Maybe. would prefer integrated with other X-books
31 Shadowland - Buy
32 Silver Surfer (1987) Vol. 1 AKA by Steve Englehart - Buy
33 Iron Man by Michelinie, Vol. 2 - Pass
33 Wolverine by Aaron, Vol. 2 - Buy
34 Alpha Flight, Vol. 2 - Maybe a buy
35 Micronauts, Vol. 1 - Pass
36 Generation X, Vol. 1 - Buy
37 X-Factor (1986) by Peter David - Buy
38 Wolverine (1988), Vol. 3 - Buy
38 Avengers by Hickman, Vol. 2 - Buy
39 Amazing Spider-Man by JMS - Buy
40 Avengers West Coast, Vol. 4 - Buy
41 Black Panther by Priest, Vol. 1 - Buy
42 Punisher by Greg Rucka - Buy
43 Superior Spider-Man - Buy
44 Runaways by BKV - Buy
45 Captain America by Mark Gruenwald, Vol. 1 - Maybe
46 Killraven - Hard pass
47 Marvel 1970's Horror Anthology (haunts of horror, chamber of darkness, monsters unleashed, legion of monsters) - Pass
48 Doctor Strange by Roger Stern - Buy
49 Captain America, Volume 3 - Pass
50 Ghost Rider (1990), Vol. 1 AKA by Howard Mackie - Buy
51 Amazing Spider-Man: Brand New Day, Vol. 1 - Buy
52 Incredible Hercules - Buy
53 Thor: God of Thunder by Aaron & Ribic - Buy, depending on what it collected
54 Conan, The Barbarian, Vol. 1 - Pass
55 X-Force Vol. 3 AKA Cable & X-Force, Vol. 1 - Buy
56 Namor, The Sub-Mariner (Silver Age), Vol. 1 - Pass
57 X-Force by Kyle & Yost - Buy
58 Captain Marvel by Peter David, Vol. 1 - Buy
59 House of M - Pass
60 What If? (1977), Vol. 1 - Pass

[Raffi Ol D'Arcy]

We had a lot of similarities. I think I'd like to see the cover for issue # 200 serve as a potential omnibus for DD

Cool. I'd be interested to see your top ten

Btw, I considered the cover to Daredevil #200 by John Byrne but I thought it just a little too "brutal" for an Omnibus cover. It's a pretty good cover, however.

[Judge Dredd]

So I got the Bendis Guardian's omnibus for 33, a book seller on ebay put a lot of copies on at first they did it for 33 I was able to grab one before the bumped the price to the 60. How is the back half of his run, and the Avengers Assemble portion with Thanos? As that is alos in the omnibus, read the first part of the run and it was okay, but could not turn down that deal.

[milton75]

Personally if New Mutants Omnis were in the offing, I would want all issues, plus the mini-series of the likes of Fallen Angels, X-Terminators and even Firestar included.

Any chance this would ever be considered?

[OldManBrian]

Cool. I'd be interested to see your top ten

Btw, I considered the cover to Daredevil #200 by John Byrne but I thought it just a little too "brutal" for an Omnibus cover. It's a pretty good cover, however.

That's what DM variants are for! I'd buy it, though I'd buy it no matter what was on the cover.

[The Lucky One]

Personally if New Mutants Omnis were in the offing, I would want all issues, plus the mini-series of the likes of Fallen Angels, X-Terminators and even Firestar included.

Any chance this would ever be considered?

X-Terminators was already in the Inferno OHC; whether it would also be in a hypothetical second NM omni, I don't know. (I would guess yes, since most of the X-Terminators joined the Muties soon afterward.) Fallen Angels seems likely, since it covers what Sunspot and Warlock were doing while they were gone, and there's precedent for it (the last UXM omni including the first Wolverine miniseries.)

I would say the Firestar mini is the least likely to be included. Both because she ended up not really being an X-character, and because it takes place over the course of years, so issues one and two would have to be in the first omni, and then three and four in the second, or something like that. It would be kind of weird. Also, the New Mutants are barely in it. But that said, it's always possible!

[The Whovian]

I would buy the following:

Full list with placements from last year:

1 Uncanny X-Men Vol. 4 AKA by Claremont/JRJR (was 1)
2 New Mutants, Volume 1 (was 2)
3 X-Men: Post-Massacre / Pre-Fall (was 16)
7 Fantastic Four, Vol. 4 (was 8)
15 X-Factor (2006) by Peter David, Vol. 1 (was 30)
16 ROM, Vol. 1 (was 25)
19 Avengers by Roger Stern, Vol. 1 (was 49)
25 X-Men Legacy by Mike Carey, Vol. 1 (was 51-56)
30 She-Hulk by Dan Slott (NEW)
31 X-Factor (1986), Vol. 1 (was 13)
37 X-Factor (1986) by Peter David (was 38)
44 Runaways by BKV (NEW)
53 Thor: God of Thunder by Aaron & Ribic ( NEW)
58 Captain Marvel by Peter David, Vol. 1 (NEW)
59 House of M (NEW)
67.5 Academy X/New Mutants by Defillipis and Weir (NEW)
67.5 Uncanny X-Men by Kieron Gillen (NEW)
Avengers: Galactic Storm (was 51-56)

[jm21]

Krisis - I've just read your #59 HoM write-up; great job!
http://crushingkrisis.com/2017/05/ho...-omnibus-2017/

Just a thought; have you accounted for HoM: Avengers, Civil War & Masters of Evil miniseries too in the proposed page counts?
The 2 AoA omnibus collected later material too, so I'd be upset if Marvel collected the same HoM OHC material again as omni without these 3 additional miniseries. Also potential Spider-verse / Secret Wars material (although I've not read these 2, so not sure how relevant?)
Tough call because you start moving into a 3-book split at some point; HoM + Companion + Decimation

A pure Decimation Omnibus could collect the post-HoM Claremont & Milligan material though (Uncanny #466-474 / X-Men #177-187, to bridge up to Brubaker & Carey taking over) - for those wanting a clean HoM-divide in the collected material.

[FlashingSabre]

Yay, new Krisis post!