All New Marvel Collected Editions

[bob.schoonover]

Fall 2024 Catalog is up

[Rincewind]

New cover for Decimation omnibus.

And Road to Onslaught is split into multiple volumes. Contents for volume 1 are: X-Men Prime #1, Uncanny X-Men #322-328, Annual '95, X-Men (1991) #42-47, Annual '95, X-Men Unlimited (1993) #8-9, Sabretooth (1996) #1, Wolverine/Gambit: Victims #1-4, Starjammers #1-4

[Rincewind]

[Rincewind]

1 Daredevil by Ann Nocenti
2 Spectacular Spider-Man by J. M. DeMatteis
3 Amazing Spider-Man Vol 6
4 Moon Knight: The Modern Era
5 X-Men: The Messiah Trilogy
6 X-Men: Dawn of X Vol 1
7 Civil War
8 Akira (Colored Marvel Epic Line)
9 X-Force by Kyle/Yost
10 Punisher by Greg Rucka
11 Alpha Flight Vol 2
12 New Avengers by Bendis Vol 2
13 X-Men: X-Cutioner's Song
14 X-Men by Mike Carey Vol 1
15 Amazing Spider-Man: Big Time
16 Doctor Strange Vol 3
17 Spider-Girl Vol 1
18 Agent Venom
19 GI Joe: The Original Marvel Years Vol 1
20 Invincible Iron Man by Matt Fraction Vol 1
21 Generation X Vol 1
22 Indiana Jones: The Original Marvel Years
23 Spectacular Spider-Man Vol 2
24 X-Men: Onslaught Aftermath
25 Spider-Man by Michelinie and Bagley Vol 2
26 Exiles Vol 1
27 Amazing Spider-Man: Identity Crisis (Clone Saga Aftermath)
28 X-Men - Inferno Aftermath
29 Marvel Team-Up Vol 1
30 Hulk by Bruce Jones
31 Spider-Man: Black Costume Saga Aftermath
32 Spider-Man: Brand New Day Vol 2
33 Amazing Spider-Man: Renew Your Vows
34 Transformers: The Original Marvel Years
35 2001: A Space Odyssey
36 X-Men: Age of Krakoa by Keiron Gillen
37 X-Men: Legacy by Mike Carey
38 Ultimate Spider-Man Vol 5
39 Ultimate Fantastic Four Vol 1
40 Silver Surfer by Steve Englehart (vol 2)
41 Alien vs. Predator: The Original Years Vol 1
42 Avengers Vol 6
43 Avengers by Roger Stern Vol 1
44 Amazing Spider-Man: The Gauntlet
45 Punisher War Journal
46 Web of Spider-Man Vol 1
47 Daredevil by Dennis O'Neil
48 The 'Nam Vol 1
49 Old Man Logan
50 X-Men by Al Ewing
51 New X-Men: X-Men Academy by Kyle/Yost
52 Fantastic Four Vol 6
53 Scarlet Spider (tie with 54)
54 Doom 2099 (tie with 53)
55 Black Widow: Modern Years Vol 1
56 Hawkeye: Kate Bishop (tie with 57)
57 Dark Avengers (tie with 56)
58 Daredevil Vol 4
59 Thunderbolts Vol 4 (Ellis & Gage)
60 Ghost Rider Johnny Blaze Vol 1

[Steroid]

Man Generation-X was so close to making the top 20. Biggest surprise on the list for me is Avengers by Roger Stern being so low on the list. I think ppl are starting to give up on it ever getting made.

[Rincewind]

My top pick is Indiana Jones, which came in at #22 just missing the top 20. It was #42 last year, so glad to see the interest has increased.

[Rincewind]

From the livestream:
this year's poll had 1595 votes. Last years had about 600. They have heard the complaints about voting site and are working on in improving it before the next poll.
The next poll will be DC omnibus/absolute reprints, and in May will be the most wanted DC omnibus poll.
There were 634 omnibus choices listed. 625 received at least one vote.
337 choices received a 1st place vote.
153 received at least one vote for every rank from 1 to 10.
42% of the top 60 are new this year
27% of the top 60 is Spider-Man related
23% of the top 60 is X-Men related
17% of the top 60 are Silver/Bronze age material that has been collected in Marvel Masterworks
17% of the to p60 are from the past 10 years
10% of the top 60 are licensed characters.

[Raffi Ol D'Arcy]

Thanks Rincewind for posting the results and stats

Five of my votes made it into the top 60:

18. Agent Venom
33. Amazing Spider-Man: Renew Your Vows
40. Silver Surfer by Steve Englehart (vol 2)
47. Daredevil by Dennis O'Neil
58. Daredevil Vol 4

The five that didn't make it were:

Planet of the Apes Magazine
Captain Mar-Vell Vol. 2
Marvel Universe by Lee Weeks
Captain Britain & MI13
Spider-Man Noir

I didn't vote for a lot of Spidey stuff which I wanted but believed would chart as a lot of people would vote for them and they did.

I do hope we get an extended list i.e. 61-100, or at least a bubbling under ten.

[nx01a]

My picks that made it...
5 X-Men: The Messiah Trilogy
21 Generation X Vol 1
59 Thunderbolts Vol 4 (Ellis & Gage)

[Gaastra]

Sad no ultraverse. Our big chance to let marvel know we want them, and they didn't get voted.

Indy and gen x missing by one and two votes is an ouch, but nice spider-girl made it in.

Note the alf thing is a running gag on Omar. He is not the biggest alf fan but is sent alf stuff by the other comic youtubers as a gag and they remind him alf is canon! What's funnier is alf still got a high vote even if it didn't make it in!

[Rincewind]

A few more stats for the poll:
Last year's top 61 most wanted omnibus list had 15 books announced to be published.

Of the books from last year's list that have now been announced, 6 subsequent volumes made the list this year. They are:
Amazing Spider-Man by Michelinie/Bagley Vol 1 now Vol 2
Fantastic Four Vol. 5 now Vol 6
X-Men: Road to Onslaught now Onslaught Aftermath
Ultimate Spider-Man Vol. 4 now Vol 5
Spider-Man: The Alien Costume Saga now Black Costume Saga Aftermath
Daredevil Vol. 3 now Vol 4

13 books from last years poll dropped out of the top 60. They are:
32. Amazing Spider-Man by Tom DeFalco
33. Iron Man by Michelinie/Layton
41. Punisher by Mike Baron
43. Incredible Hulk by Bill Mantlo
45. Fantastic Four: Heroes Return
47. Namor: The Sub-Mariner (Silver Age)
48. Uncanny X-Men by Kieron Gillen
51. Darkhawk
53. Uncanny X-Men by Matt Fraction
54. All-New X-Men by Brian Michael Bendis
55. Incredible Hulk Vol 3
56. Eternals by Kieron Gillen
57. Star Wars: Poe Dameron

That leaves 21 new entries compared to last year's poll. (some of these might have made prior year polls before dropping off last year and returning this year)
8 Akira (Colored Marvel Epic Line)
13 X-Men: X-Cutioner's Song
19 GI Joe: The Original Marvel Years Vol 1
27 Amazing Spider-Man: Identity Crisis (Clone Saga Aftermath)
32 Spider-Man: Brand New Day Vol 2
33 Amazing Spider-Man: Renew Your Vows
34 Transformers: The Original Marvel Years
35 2001: A Space Odyssey
36 X-Men: Age of Krakoa by Keiron Gillen
37 X-Men: Legacy by Mike Carey
41 Alien vs. Predator: The Original Years Vol 1
42 Avengers Vol 6
44 Amazing Spider-Man: The Gauntlet
45 Punisher War Journal
47 Daredevil by Dennis O'Neil
48 The 'Nam Vol 1
50 X-Men by Al Ewing
55 Black Widow: Modern Years Vol 1
56 Hawkeye: Kate Bishop (tie with 57)
57 Dark Avengers (tie with 56)
59 Thunderbolts Vol 4 (Ellis & Gage)

[Rincewind]

Chart movement from last year (* previous volume was on last year's poll and announced, current volume is new to this year):
1 Daredevil by Ann Nocenti 0
2 Spectacular Spider-Man by J. M. DeMatteis 3
3 Amazing Spider-Man Vol 6 1
4 Moon Knight: The Modern Era 10
5 X-Men: The Messiah Trilogy 1
6 X-Men: Dawn of X Vol 1 44
7 Civil War 9
9 X-Force by Kyle/Yost 4
10 Punisher by Greg Rucka 7
11 Alpha Flight Vol 2 17
12 New Avengers by Bendis Vol 2 -1
14 X-Men by Mike Carey Vol 1 -12
15 Amazing Spider-Man: Big Time 43
16 Doctor Strange Vol 3 8
17 Spider-Girl Vol 1 23
18 Agent Venom -6
20 Invincible Iron Man by Matt Fraction Vol 1 0
21 Generation X Vol 1 0
22 Indiana Jones: The Original Marvel Years 20
23 Spectacular Spider-Man Vol 2 32
24 X-Men: Onslaught Aftermath 1*
25 Spider-Man by Michelinie and Bagley Vol 2 -17*
26 Exiles Vol 1 9
28 X-Men - Inferno Aftermath 18
29 Marvel Team-Up Vol 1 -2
30 Hulk by Bruce Jones 6
31 Spider-Man: Black Costume Saga Aftermath -1*
38 Ultimate Spider-Man Vol 5 -9*
39 Ultimate Fantastic Four Vol 1 0
40 Silver Surfer by Steve Englehart (vol 2) -25
43 Avengers by Roger Stern Vol 1 -34
46 Web of Spider-Man Vol 1 3
49 Old Man Logan -23
51 New X-Men: X-Men Academy by Kyle/Yost 10
52 Fantastic Four Vol 6 -30*
53 Scarlet Spider (tie with 54) -16
54 Doom 2099 (tie with 53) 5
58 Daredevil Vol 4 -6*
60 Ghost Rider Johnny Blaze Vol 1 -29

[Captain Craig]

I was surprised that Incredible Hulk vol.3 didn't chart as I feel that series really is doing well that far into its run.

Granted, I also didn't vote for it cause I felt it was more of a certainty along the lines of FF vol.6, ASM vol. 6 and DD vol. 4....guess not.