All New Marvel Collected Editions

[Rincewind]

The results are in.

[Raffi Ol D'Arcy]

The results are in.

1 Uncanny X-Men Vol 5
2 Daredevil Nocenti
3 Star Wars Gillen 38-75
4 Amazing Spider-Man Micheline/Bagley
5 Daredevil Silver Age vol 2
6 Amazing Spider-Man Brand New Day
7 X-Men Carey
8 Superior Spider-Man
9 Amazing Spider-Man Vol 6
10 Spider-Man Alien Saga
11 Spectacular Spider-man Dematteis
12 Incredible Hulk SA2
13 Avengers Stern
14 Immortal Hulk
15 X-Men Messiah Complex
16 Alpha Flight Vol 2
17 X-Force Yost
18 Fantastic Four Vol 5
19 Captain America Gruenwald
20 X-Men Inferno Aftermath
21 Invincible Iron Man Fraction
22 Star Wars Poe
23 Doctor Strange Vol 3
24 Moon Knight Ellis/Lemire/Modern
25 Daredevil 292-342
26 Civil War
27 Avengers Vol5
28 New Avengers Vol 2 Bendis (Secret Invasion)
29 Silver Surfer Englehart
30 Indiana Jones
31 Amazing Spider-Man Defalco
32 Star Wars High Republic
33 Iron Man Micheline
34 Sub-Mariner SA
35 Generation X
36 Captain Marvel David
37 Venom Remender
38 Punisher Rucka
39 Marvel Team Up Vol 1
40 Secret Wars Hickman 2015
41 Old Man Logan
42 X-Men SA3
43 Ultimate Spider-Man Vol 3
44 Thunderbolts Vol 3
45 Daredevil Oneill
46 (TIE) Jessica Jones New Materials
46 (TIE) Rom
47 X-Men Road to Onslaught
48 X-Factor Vol 3
49 Wolverine Vol 4
50 Ghost Rider (1990s Era)

[Raffi Ol D'Arcy]

Once again Omar has shared his disbelief at the high positions in the Omnibus poll of Silver Age material. I'm beginning to suspect that he thinks everyone only wants X-Men and 90s Marvel in Omnibus format.
Again, he talks about the sales of the Hulk and Daredevil being determining factors. Both Vol 1"s, based on Diamond figures, were big sellers but from my understanding because there was a high number published there remained quite a number of "backcopies". It's obvious collectors want Vol. 2 of Hulk and Daredevil, positions 12 and 5, respectively, speak volumes. He also expressed his surprise at the interest of Star Wars materiał. Why is this strange? Star Wars has always been quite popular and the current material has been liked and praised. The Star Wars Omnibuses (bar the Ewoks and Original Marvel Years) went OOP relatively quickly.

[Rincewind]

I'm surprised Amazing Spider-Man and the Alien Costume Saga both made the list. Since they cover the same time period, there would be a lot of double dipping between these.

[newparisian]

Of these, I would buy:

1 Uncanny X-Men Vol 5
3 Star Wars Gillen 38-75
6 Amazing Spider-Man Brand New Day
7 X-Men Carey
8 Superior Spider-Man
14 Immortal Hulk
15 X-Men Messiah Complex
17 X-Force Yost
21 Invincible Iron Man Fraction
24 Moon Knight Ellis/Lemire/Modern
26 Civil War
28 New Avengers Vol 2 Bendis (Secret Invasion)
36 Captain Marvel David
38 Punisher Rucka
40 Secret Wars Hickman 2015
41 Old Man Logan
43 Ultimate Spider-Man Vol 3
48 X-Factor Vol 3

So happy Fraction's Iron Man is ranked high-ish.

[doolittle]

I'd be in for these. That's a lot of money.

1 Uncanny X-Men Vol 5
2 Daredevil Nocenti
4 Amazing Spider-Man Micheline/Bagley
7 X-Men Carey
9 Amazing Spider-Man Vol 6
10 Spider-Man Alien Saga
11 Spectacular Spider-man Dematteis
13 Avengers Stern
15 X-Men Messiah Complex
17 X-Force Yost
19 Captain America Gruenwald
20 X-Men Inferno Aftermath
29 Silver Surfer Englehart
31 Amazing Spider-Man Defalco
35 Generation X
39 Marvel Team Up Vol 1
40 Secret Wars Hickman 2015
42 X-Men SA3
45 Daredevil Oneill
47 X-Men Road to Onslaught
49 Wolverine Vol 4
50 Ghost Rider (1990s Era)

[bob.schoonover]

3 Star Wars Gillen 38-75
7 X-Men Carey
8 Superior Spider-Man
10 Spider-Man Alien Saga
11 Spectacular Spider-man Dematteis
13 Avengers Stern
19 Captain America Gruenwald
24 Moon Knight Ellis/Lemire/Modern
31 Amazing Spider-Man Defalco
36 Captain Marvel David
44 Thunderbolts Vol 3
45 Daredevil Oneill

Just these for me - someone (more than one, really) on the Masterworks forum has a lovely "all three books" mappings for ASM/SSM/WoSM between the Stern omni and McFarlane/Michelinie that would be INCREDIBLY enticing that I hope ends up happening

[Raffi Ol D'Arcy]

These would probably be my day one purchases:

2 Daredevil Nocenti (I have the Epics and a lot of the singles but I'm a DD completist)
3 Star Wars Gillen 38-75
4 Amazing Spider-Man Micheline/Bagley
5 Daredevil Silver Age vol 2 (I have the MMWs but as above)
6 Amazing Spider-Man Brand New Day
10 Spider-Man Alien Saga (I have the TPBs, but would upgrade)
11 Spectacular Spider-man Dematteis
13 Avengers Stern
18 Fantastic Four Vol 5
19 Captain America Gruenwald
22 Star Wars Poe
25 Daredevil 292-342 (I have these in Epics and singles but as above)
27 Avengers Vol5
28 New Avengers Vol 2 Bendis (Secret Invasion)
29 Silver Surfer Englehart
31 Amazing Spider-Man Defalco
32 Star Wars High Republic
33 Iron Man Micheline
45 Daredevil Oneill (I have the singles but as above plus one of my fave DD runs)

Maybes:

1 Uncanny X-Men Vol 5
9 Amazing Spider-Man Vol 6
14 Immortal Hulk
21 Invincible Iron Man Fraction (I have the 2 OHCs but am missing the rest)
26 Civil War
30 Indiana Jones
37 Venom Remender
39 Marvel Team Up Vol 1 (I have the MMWs)
42 X-Men SA3
49 Wolverine Vol 4

Man, too much money!

[Rincewind]

First Day Buys
3 Star Wars Gillen 38-75
6 Amazing Spider-Man Brand New Day
8 Superior Spider-Man
16 Alpha Flight Vol 2 (on my top ten)
30 Indiana Jones (on my top ten)
38 Punisher Rucka
43 Ultimate Spider-Man Vol 3
44 Thunderbolts Vol 3 (on my top ten)

Maybe pile
21 Invincible Iron Man Fraction
28 New Avengers Vol 2 Bendis (Secret Invasion)
46 (TIE) Jessica Jones New Materials
46 (TIE) Rom

[Rincewind]

Most wanted Epic Reprints

[Raffi Ol D'Arcy]

Most wanted Epic Reprints

The Complete LIST:

#20 Avengers 5: This Beachhead Earth
#19 Daredevil 2: Mike Murdock Must Die!
#18 Iron Man 15: Doom
#17 Daredevil 1: Man Without Fear
#16 Daredevil 15: Last Rites
#15 Fantastic Four 3: The Coming of Galactus
#14 Doctor Strange 8: Triumph and Torment
#13 Star Wars: Legacy 1
#12 X-Men 6: Proteus 14
#11 Avengers West Coast 2: Lost in Space-Time
#10 X-Men 5: Second Genesis
#9 Moon Knight 1: Bad Moon Rising
#8 Star Wars: New Republic 4
#7 Thor 17: In Mortal Flesh
#6 Punisher 2: Circle Of Blood
#5 Daredevil 13: A Touch of Typhoid
#4 Amazing Spider-Man 15: Ghosts of the Past
#3 Amazing Spider-Man 4: The Goblin Lives
#2 X-Men 4: It’s Always Darkest Before the Dawn
#1 Amazing Spider-Man 17: Kraven’s Last Hunt

More evidence that people want/need SA Daredevil in collected format.

[Johnny_Dark]

He also expressed his surprise at the interest of Star Wars materiał. Why is this strange? Star Wars has always been quite popular and the current material has been liked and praised. The Star Wars Omnibuses (bar the Ewoks and Original Marvel Years) went OOP relatively quickly.

Probably because in the previous years Star Wars have not been that present in the ballot.

[Near Mint]

someone (more than one, really) on the Masterworks forum has a lovely "all three books" mappings for ASM/SSM/WoSM between the Stern omni and McFarlane/Michelinie that would be INCREDIBLY enticing that I hope ends up happening

So pleased to see this get a mention here! These are the suggested volumes and mappings (credit to Kets in the MMW Forum for originating):

Spider-Man: The Alien Costume Saga Omnibus
(Amazing Spider-Man #252 – 263; Annual #18; Marvel-Team-Up #141 – 150; Annual #7; Peter Parker, the Spectacular Spider-Man #90 – 100; Annual #4; Web of Spider-Man #1)

Spider-Man: The Death of Jean DeWolff Omnibus
(Amazing Spider-Man #264 – 274; Annual #19; Spectacular Spider-Man #101 – 115; Annual #5; Web of Spider-Man #2 – 15; Annual #1)

Spider-Man: The Unmasking of the Hobgoblin Omnibus
(Amazing Spider-Man #275 – 289; Annual #20; Spectacular Spider-Man #116 – 127; Annual #6; Web of Spider-Man #16 – 30; Annual #2; Spider-Man Versus Wolverine #1)

Spider-Man: Till Death Do Us Part Omnibus
(Amazing Spider-Man #290 – 295; Annual #21; Spectacular Spider-Man #128 – 136; Annual #7; Web of Spider-Man #31 – 34; Annual #3; Marvel Graphic Novel #46: Parallel Lives; Marvel Age #54; What If? Vol. 2 #17, 20, 21)


...and as a bonus (especially for those of us still feeling burned about the absence of any follow-up to Spider-Man Tombstone Volume 1):

Spectacular Spider-Man by Gerry Conway and Sal Buscema Omnibus
(Spectacular Spider-Man #137 – 175; Annual #8 – 10; Web of Spider-Man #54 – 55; Annual #6; Amazing Spider-Man Annual #24; Spider-Man/Doctor Strange: The Way to Dusty Death #1)


If you would love some comprehensive mid-80s Spidey omni goodness, please consider including these in your picks when the annual survey comes around again!

[Rincewind]

^
I’d prefer that the last volume include Web of Spider-Man #35-53 and #56-70, Annual #4-5. There” s about 10 issues of non Conway stories, but I don’t want any orphaned issues.

[SJNeal]

The Complete LIST:

#20 Avengers 5: This Beachhead Earth
#19 Daredevil 2: Mike Murdock Must Die!
#18 Iron Man 15: Doom
#17 Daredevil 1: Man Without Fear
#16 Daredevil 15: Last Rites
#15 Fantastic Four 3: The Coming of Galactus
#14 Doctor Strange 8: Triumph and Torment
#13 Star Wars: Legacy 1
#12 X-Men 6: Proteus 14
#11 Avengers West Coast 2: Lost in Space-Time
#10 X-Men 5: Second Genesis
#9 Moon Knight 1: Bad Moon Rising
#8 Star Wars: New Republic 4
#7 Thor 17: In Mortal Flesh
#6 Punisher 2: Circle Of Blood
#5 Daredevil 13: A Touch of Typhoid
#4 Amazing Spider-Man 15: Ghosts of the Past
#3 Amazing Spider-Man 4: The Goblin Lives
#2 X-Men 4: It’s Always Darkest Before the Dawn
#1 Amazing Spider-Man 17: Kraven’s Last Hunt

More evidence that people want/need SA Daredevil in collected format.

Wow, not one of my choices made the list! Lol