All New Marvel Collected Editions

[Raffi Ol D'Arcy]

Yeah, but seriously, I mean has Mephisto EVER looked like that anywhere besides JRjr's DD books? Not that I know of. So random. Just like everything else in the book. I really enjoyed reading it, and I even liked most of the art, but man is it an oddball outlier to most any other DD tale.

Remember, this is Ann Nocenti. She mixes in religious, political and activist topics in her stories and then more. It really is "out there".

[Raffi Ol D'Arcy]

We're closing in on the final Ten Most Wanted Omnibuses:

#20 PUNISHER by GREG RUCKA

#19 INCREDIBLE HULK SILVER AGE VOLUME 2

# 18 DOCTOR STRANGE SILVER AGE VOLUME 2

#17 (TIE) INFINITY WAR*

#17 (TIE) SPIDER_MAN by JM DEMATTEIS

#16 IRON MAN by DAVID MICHELINIE VOLUME 2

#15 DEFENDERS

#14 THOR by JASON AARON

# 13 AVENGERS by ROGER STERN VOLUME 1

#12 DAREDEVIL by ANN NOCENTI VOLUME 1

#11 THUNDERBOLTS by KURT BUSIEK

[Raffi Ol D'Arcy]

The Final Top Ten:

#10 MIRACLEMAN

#9 X-FACTOR (2006) by PETER DAVID

#8 WOLVERINE VOLUME 2

#7 CONAN THE BARBARIAN

#6 FANTASTIC FOUR SILVER AGE VOLUME 4

#5 INCREDIBLE HULK by PETER DAVID VOLUME 1

#4 EXCALIBUR VOLUME 1

#3 AMAZING SPIDER_MAN SILVER AGE VOLUME 4

#2 NEW MUTANTS VOLUME 1

#1 UNCANNY X-MEN VOLUME 4

[Graphic Autist]

AMAZING SPIDER_MAN SILVER AGE VOLUME 4

Wouldn't ASM be beyond Silver Age at this point?

[Raffi Ol D'Arcy]

These just missed the Top 60....

Gwenpool
Captain America by Gruenwald
Darkhawk
Marvel Team Up
Thor (Jane Foster)
Warlock by Starlin
Marvel Horror
X-Men the Hidden Years
What If (1990s)
Savage Sword of Conan
Scarlet Spider by Kyle Yost
Old Man Logan

....in that order

[Raffi Ol D'Arcy]

Wouldn't ASM be beyond Silver Age at this point?

Yes, definitely Bronze Age material.

[Captain Craig]

These just missed the Top 60....

Gwenpool
Captain America by Gruenwald
Darkhawk
...
...
....in that order

Darkhawk was one of mine and it was 3 positions away from ranking. I'm good with that.

[awayne83]

Wouldn't ASM be beyond Silver Age at this point?

Yes, definitely Bronze Age material.

Well death of Gwen is generally considered end of marvel silver age, so a bit of both really if we're splitting hairs

[Brewman]

Posted over in the Most Wanted Thread as well but...

1. Uncanny X-Men
2. New Mutants Vol 1
3. Amazing Spider-Man SA Vol 4
4. Excalibur Vol 1
5. Hulk PAD Vol 1
6. FF SA Vol 4
7. Conan the Barbarian
8. Wolverine Vol 2
9. X-Factor PAD 2006
10. MiracleMan
11. Thunderbolts by Busiek
12. Daredevil by Nocenti v1
13. Avengers by Stern v1
14. Thor by Aaron v1
15. Defenders
16. Iron Man by Michelinie v2
17. (Tie) Spider-Man by DeMatteis
17. (Tie) Infinity War
18. SA Dr Strange v2
19. SA Incredible Hulk v2
20. Punisher by Rucka
21. AVENGERS VOLUME 4
22. MOON KNIGHT v1
23. GHOST RIDER (BRONZE) VOLUME 1
24. BLACK PANTHER by CHRISTOPHER PRIEST
25. ULTIMATE SPIDER-MAN VOLUME 2
26. ALPHA FLIGHT VOLUME 2
27. GENERATION X
28. SILVER SURFER by ENGELHART
29. X-FORCE VOLUME 3
30. SUPERIOR SPIDER-MAN
31. ASM by JMS v1
32. New Avengers v2
33. ASM by Slott v1
34. Namor by Byrne
35. X-Factor (1986) by David
36. ASM by MICHELINIE and BAGLEY
37. ROM VOLUME 1
38. WOLVERINE by LARRY HAMA
39. SHE HULK by JOHN BYRNE
40. Silver Age Cap v3
41. Fantastic Four (heroes reborn)
42. She Hulk by Slott
43. House of M
44. ASM by DeFalco
45. Daredevil v2
46. X-Factor (1986)
47. Cosmic Universe by Starlin
48. Sub-Mariner SA Vol 1
49. (TIE) New Warriors Vol 2
49. (TIE) Ditko Monsterbus
50. Xtreme X-Men
51. X-Men: Crossroads
52. Moon Knight (2006)
53. Dr. Strange by Stern
54. What If?
55. Micronauts
56. AVENGERS WEST COAST V4
57. INFINITY CRUSADE
58. CAPTAIN MARVEL (1999) by PETER DAVID
59. INVINCIBLE IRON MAN BY MATT FRACTION
60. (TIE) DAZZLER COMPLETE
60. (TIE) X-MEN LEGACY BY MIKE CAREY

[Andru]

Still cannot believe we even have to keep voting for a New Mutants Omnibus. Make the damn thing already Marvel!

[Brewman]

Still cannot believe we even have to keep voting for a New Mutants Omnibus. Make the damn thing already Marvel!

If it doesn't happen with the movie release I call SHENANIGANS!!!

[Rimmer]

I find it interesting that for the MMW-port omnibuses, a lot made the list for the next volume (uncanny, ASM, Hulk, Dr Strange, FF, Cap, Avengers), a few others did not: Mainly Thor and Iron Man. Now Thor just had a volume, so I guess everyone's okay with a break, but it's interesting how there's been no movement on an IM omnibus for literally YEARS. The argument of "he doesn't have a movie coming out" is somewhat valid, but it hasn't stopped other titles from still getting an omni here or there, plus IM has been IN several movies that just didn't say "Iron Man" on the title card.

I realize some of the early IM stuff is kinda rough to get through, but like in the MMWs, you have to get through the rough to get to better stuff.

I wonder if part of this is the fact that IM omnibuses vols 1 + 2 have BOTH been OOP for a looooong time and go for way-too-high prices on aftermarket - could that have killed all interest in the omnibuse line continuing? Everyone's just okay to go the MMW and/or Epic route from here on out?

[Yaggi_Rck]

I find it interesting that for the MMW-port omnibuses, a lot made the list for the next volume (uncanny, ASM, Hulk, Dr Strange, FF, Cap, Avengers), a few others did not: Mainly Thor and Iron Man. Now Thor just had a volume, so I guess everyone's okay with a break, but it's interesting how there's been no movement on an IM omnibus for literally YEARS. The argument of "he doesn't have a movie coming out" is somewhat valid, but it hasn't stopped other titles from still getting an omni here or there, plus IM has been IN several movies that just didn't say "Iron Man" on the title card.

I realize some of the early IM stuff is kinda rough to get through, but like in the MMWs, you have to get through the rough to get to better stuff.

I wonder if part of this is the fact that IM omnibuses vols 1 + 2 have BOTH been OOP for a looooong time and go for way-too-high prices on aftermarket - could that have killed all interest in the omnibuse line continuing? Everyone's just okay to go the MMW and/or Epic route from here on out?

I get what you mean, but even as a Thor fan, I wouldn't see the point in having a "Thor vol.4" made of silver age material, it just wasn't that good (even the final issues of the original Stan Lee run were kind of a drag; too much repetition). Arguably, the only story fitting in between tha Lee/Kirby Omni's and Simonson's that COULD be considered 'Omnibus-worthy' (pun intended), was the Eternals Saga.

[TomSlick]

On one hand I wish they'd publish the whole list but on the other . . . . damn I'd have to mortgage the house

1. Uncanny X-Men
2. New Mutants Vol 1
3. Amazing Spider-Man SA Vol 4
4. Excalibur Vol 1
5. Hulk PAD Vol 1
7. Conan the Barbarian
8. Wolverine Vol 2
9. X-Factor PAD 2006
10. MiracleMan
11. Thunderbolts by Busiek
13. Avengers by Stern v1
16. Iron Man by Michelinie v2
17. (Tie) Spider-Man by DeMatteis
17. (Tie) Infinity War
20. Punisher by Rucka
22. MOON KNIGHT v1
23. GHOST RIDER (BRONZE) VOLUME 1
24. BLACK PANTHER by CHRISTOPHER PRIEST
26. ALPHA FLIGHT VOLUME 2
27. GENERATION X
28. SILVER SURFER by ENGELHART
31. ASM by JMS v1
33. ASM by Slott v1
34. Namor by Byrne
35. X-Factor (1986) by David
36. ASM by MICHELINIE and BAGLEY
37. ROM VOLUME 1
38. WOLVERINE by LARRY HAMA
39. SHE HULK by JOHN BYRNE
41. Fantastic Four (heroes reborn)
42. She Hulk by Slott
43. House of M
44. ASM by DeFalco
45. Daredevil v2
46. X-Factor (1986)
47. Cosmic Universe by Starlin
48. Sub-Mariner SA Vol 1
49. (TIE) New Warriors Vol 2
49. (TIE) Ditko Monsterbus
50. Xtreme X-Men
51. X-Men: Crossroads
52. Moon Knight (2006)
53. Dr. Strange by Stern
54. What If?
55. Micronauts
56. AVENGERS WEST COAST V4
57. INFINITY CRUSADE
58. CAPTAIN MARVEL (1999) by PETER DAVID
59. INVINCIBLE IRON MAN BY MATT FRACTION
60. (TIE) DAZZLER COMPLETE
60. (TIE) X-MEN LEGACY BY MIKE CAREY

[Graphic Autist]

I may be retarded, but do the results of this poll actually help a book coming to reality?

I am thoroughly confused, but the excitement about this poll leads me to question my intelligence.