All New Marvel Collected Editions

[TomSlick]

His Scalped is a helluva lot better than anything he's written for Marvel. His Marvel stuff reaks of phoning it in and selling out for some easy money.

Agreed although I enjoyed his first Thor OHC

[Peter Parker]

Agreed although I enjoyed his first Thor OHC

Thought it was one of the better Thor runs ever.

[Johnatellodi]

Anyone picking up the Amazing Spider-Man volume 1 ohc by Slott?

I tuned out of his run after Superior ended. Was the Amazing run any good?

[Peter Parker]

Anyone picking up the Amazing Spider-Man volume 1 ohc by Slott?

I tuned out of his run after Superior ended. Was the Amazing run any good?

I'm torn on it. IMHO Slott's ASM run is going downhill after the first 3/4ths of Superior, but at the same time I have all of the HC/OHC from Big Time on but that first OHC is a double dip with Spider-verse...ugh.

[Dayle88]

It was okay. The ANAD run has been better as long as you are cool with accepting that they've given Peter Parker all of Tony Stark's story traits.

[Johnatellodi]

I'm torn on it. IMHO Slott's ASM run is going downhill after the first 3/4ths of Superior, but at the same time I have all of the HC/OHC from Big Time on but that first OHC is a double dip with Spider-verse...ugh.

Right? Dude was on fire for most of Superior and it all really started to peeter out around Goblin Nation.

[Peter Parker]

Right? Dude was on fire for most of Superior and it all really started to peeter out around Goblin Nation.

I see what you did there.

I figured once he started dividing up with Silver Surfer, ASM suffered. SS has been very good.

[legion_quest]

I see what you did there.

I figured once he started dividing up with Silver Surfer, ASM suffered. SS has been very good.

It's been a very good Doctor Who fan fic

[Dayle88]

It's been a very good Doctor Who fan fic

That doesn't make sense; good and Dr Who don't belong in the same sentence.

[Johnatellodi]

I see what you did there.

I figured once he started dividing up with Silver Surfer, ASM suffered. SS has been very good.

Good point about Silver Surfer effecting the workload.

I seem to remember an interview in which Dan Slott was slightly lamenting the quick release pace that the Spider-Man has to keep. It's not hard to imagine his fatigue and how that effects the story.

[Thesanmich]

I'm torn on it. IMHO Slott's ASM run is going downhill after the first 3/4ths of Superior, but at the same time I have all of the HC/OHC from Big Time on but that first OHC is a double dip with Spider-verse...ugh.

Haven't dived into Slott's Spidey work, it's up their on my backlog for sure, but news of the Spider-verse OHC and ASM deluxe 1 overlapping makes me not want to pick up the latter.

[Ivan P91]

but that first OHC is a double dip with Spider-verse...ugh.

Haven't dived into Slott's Spidey work, it's up their on my backlog for sure, but news of the Spider-verse OHC and ASM deluxe 1 overlapping makes me not want to pick up the latter.

The overlap with Spider-Verse will be in Vol 2:

Vol 1: 1-6, 1.1-1.5, Annual 1
Spider-Verse: 7-15, SSM 32-33
Vol 2: 7-18, SSM 32-33

Vol 1 does overlap with Original Sin Companion (issues 4-6), however.

[Balakin]

That doesn't make sense; good and Dr Who don't belong in the same sentence.

You! YOU!

[Mr`Orange]

I'm going to get the first deluxe when I order the second Black Panther complete collection and get that Wordery 10% a bit later. I just saw that it will all be collected in five deluxes as well which is always a plus to have an entire run in one format if I like it.

Black Panther, another great series, I'm so glad they are releasing this.

The Deluxe edition is a good way forward, nice packaging and you get a good chunk of story, I hope you enjoy it.

[Peter Parker]

The overlap with Spider-Verse will be in Vol 2:

Vol 1: 1-6, 1.1-1.5, Annual 1
Spider-Verse: 7-15, SSM 32-33
Vol 2: 7-18, SSM 32-33

Vol 1 does overlap with Original Sin Companion (issues 4-6), however.

Ah thanks for the clarification. That is a hell of a double dip!