Replace 2 members of Extraordinary X-men

[SchismOfMadroces]

To be honest I cant swap just 2, I just can't my roster would be something like this

Colossus is perfect as is. I even dig his gigantuousness.
Nightcrawler is lovely as well.
Illyana is EVERYTHING to me, so she stays.
Old Man Logan -I'd love to see Chamber active again.
Marvel Girl - I'd enjoy Karma stepping up as resident telepath.
Storm - That HAIR tho
Iceman - His arc is something I'm looking forward to so I'll keep him.
Anole (Vic Borkowski) - I like the kid.
Forge - If I had to swap in a different general problem solver, I'd swap in Doug Ramsey. I love Doug.
Cerebra - DANGER. I love Danger.

I can also get behind this lineup!

[nx01a]

Who's govenor general howlett?

Alt. Hercules' gay lover, bless them.

[crimsontt]

Jeen replaced by Rachel
Old man logan replaced by original 616 Wolverine.


buut, my ideal rosters would be (loosely based on the recent roster shake up)

Extraordinary

- Storm
- Marvel Girl (Rachel)
- Wolverine
- Colossus
- Nightcrawler
- Shadowcat

Back up members

- Banshee
- Beast

Psylocke as frequent guest. this team is composed of her best friends among the x-men)

Uncanny

- Magneto
- Psylocke
- Cyclops
- Mystique
- Fantomex
- Sabretooth (inverted)
- Danger

Astonishing instead of All new all different >> entirely new team. (I completely hate the concept of the o5 stealing original 616 characters' spotlight)

- Havok (leader)
- Iceman
- Gambit
- Rogue
- Dazzler
- Polaris
- Angel (rid of Archangel persona, retaining its powers)

[Celestialbodies]

Is there any requirement to have decent sales on the book with some of these substitutions? Guess not since it's a fantasy thread, but this is supposed to be the flagship title. Just sayin'...

I was thinking this as well!!!

[AHall88]

Replace Nightcrawler with Pixie and Colossus with Warpath.

Not that I dislike those two, I just like Pixie and Warpath better.

[Ambaryerno]

I'd completely have fun with Laura as Wolverine by putting her on Extraordinary in place of anyone except Old Man Logan, but NOT pull her out of All-New (and for extra giggles I'd have her turn up in Uncanny, too, and maybe one of the Avengers-side books). And at some point there would be a panel of an exhausted and exasperated Laura wondering aloud, "How did Logan DO this?!" Then Old Man Logan would turn to her and say, "Darlin', even *I* don't know how I used to do that."

[MYCMTSC]

Is there any requirement to have decent sales on the book with some of these substitutions? Guess not since it's a fantasy thread, but this is supposed to be the flagship title. Just sayin'...

Logan is the only A-List mutant IMO and this is also the age of new faces carrying long-lasting books and grabbing headlines. Storm and Wolverine are the only essentials for me and the rest, for better or worse, could be replaced by a myriad of other faces.

My lineups, based purely on what I think would be fun to read about:

Extraordinary X-Men:
Storm
Old Man Logan
Jubilee
Chamber
Rockslide
Iceman
Magik

Year two or three: Add Cyclops (because I need a break)

Uncanny X-Men:
Magneto
M
Psylocke
Archangel
Sabretooth

Mystique (supporting cast until year two or three; because I need a break but her story needs build up to be set on course)

Earth's Mightiest X-Men (because AN is an abomination):
Rogue
Cannonball
Sunspot
Manifold
Lady Star-Lord (LOL)
Bling
Moonstar

Year Two or Three: Add Emma Frost (because I need a break)

[soyokaze]

Remove Storm replace with Laura
Remove Old man Logan replace with Daken

I'd like to see "Collisions & Chemistry" between Daken and Teen Jean. or a "Search for Truth (Dark Wolverine #81)".

[motherofpearl1]

Magik with Rogue, Teen Jean with Rachel.

[datugu]

I love Old Man Logan, but I think he is better in solo... And Iceman I would love more he is with his younger self rediscovering himself... I feel they should have worked more in the "I'm gay but I don't want to admit it"... I think his younger self is helping him a lot!!!

I would replace OML with Warpath, Iceman stay (even if I would love see him team with his younger self), Jeen replace her with Rachel or Jubilee... I think it will be a bigger impact to OML to see Jubilee than Jeen... and I hate they decided to make her his new "daughter"...

My lineups, based purely on what I think would be fun to read about:

Extraordinary X-Men:
Storm
Old Man Logan
Jubilee
Chamber
Rockslide
Iceman
Magik

This team would have been great!!!