Originally Posted by
Unfinishedsentenc
Honestly, I think any character can be great when put in the hands of a good writer. Favorite Clayface of mine is Basil Karlo, and I've always saw him as someone who yearns for perfection and attention, and would do anything to get it. And since he craves the spotlight, to be the center of the scene, even if he's this horrifying, almost inorganic monster and absolutely ruined externally, as long as he has that spotlight, he's content. That reflects on his past his past as a failing actor too. I think he can challenge Bruce just as psychologically as well as physically, and brings out the desire in all of us to be someone else (and sometimes anyone else rather than yourself). Don't know if he's be written that way, but I believe that you can find personal meaning and emotional weight behind any power or gimmick that may appear on the surface. I'd like to see a story where Clayface has the entire city staring at him, everyone at his utter disposal . . . and he decides to use the opportunity to show them all how good of an actor he is. He isn't happy with himself, is the point. You can find a way to connect to any character I think.
Bane comes from a place of pure hell. When he was a child, he survived that hell by using his wits (evidenced by the "master strategist" title), and then he found venom and used that to overcome any opposition in his life. Soon, he got addicted and became a shell of his former self, at least in some ways. He's about perseverance, but the means he uses to persevere definitely seem to clash with Bruce's. He represents those who are given nothing in life, and then find something to make them better, stronger, but eventually let that very thing that helps them . . . destroy them all over again. He seeks out Batman out of that need, the need to persevere, to succeed in any and all challenges, even when he either doesn't need to or literally can't. Maybe looking back on his life of imprisonment and pain is just too much, so instead he continues to try and conquer everything in the world, so he doesn't have to consider the times where he's lost. As much as he is about masculinity and dominance, he is also just as much about addiction and self-control.
And KM is about desperation. Simply and clearly. Sometimes, the villains don't have to have this tragic backstory or private ideology or philosophy to their actions. Moth to me is just about that yearning for respect and entitlement (hence the fact that he modeled his suit and weapons off of the most popular and well-respected guy in Gotham -- Batman). He would die for a chance to be among the ranks of influential guys like Joker or Penguin and, most importantly . . . he would kill to have that chance as well.