The rival stables are filling up. Which side would ultimately come out on top?
Ground rules:
- Think more about the real-life actors and less the roles they play
- Single combat, no weapons or gadgets, in an octagon, two actors enter, one leaves under their own power (fight till knockout or submission)
- We're only counting the actors from the shared live-action movies of Warner (starting with MAN OF STEEL) and Disney (starting with IRON MAN).
- No television (sorry Stephen Amell and Grant Gustin and Krysten Ritter)
- No Fox movies (sorry Ryan Reynolds and Hugh Jackman)
- No stuff that pre-dates the DCEU or MCU (sorry Eric Bana and Tobey Maguire and Brandon Routh and Christian Bale)
- Teams have to be even, which is tough because there are literally a dozen (12) MCU movies already out to choose from for Team Disney, and technically still only 1 DCEU movie out, though we are counting the actors in BVS
OJ, SS, and the confirmed actors in movies not yet officially named for Team Warner
-
- Avoid the likely curb-stomps: pit a David against another David and a Goliath against another Goliath
On Team Warner/DC:
Henry Cavill (Superman)
Ben Affleck (Batman)
Gal Gadot (Wonder Woman)
Jason Momoa (Aquaman)
Ezra Miller (the Flash)
Ray Fisher (Cyborg)
Dwayne Johnson (Black Adam)
Jesse Eisenberg (Lex Luthor)
Jared Leto (the Joker)
Will Smith (Deadshot)
Chris Pine (Steve Trevor)
On Team Disney/Marvel:
Chris Evans (Captain America)
Robert Downey Jr (Iron Man)
Chris Hemsworth (Thor)
Mark Ruffalo (Hulk)
Scarlett Johansson (Black Widow)
Jeremy Renner (Hawkeye)
Samuel L. Jackson (Nick Fury)
Chadwick Boseman (Black Panther)
Tom Hiddleston (Loki)
Tom Holland (Spider-Man)
Chris Pratt (Starlord)
Dave Batista (Drax)
Paul Rudd (Ant-Man)
That's just for starters.
Team Disney has way more actors to pick from that, and Team Warner will obviously pick up a lot more down the road.
So, let's begin.
Match #1
Henry Cavill vs. Chris Evans
The colorful muscle-bound boy scout quarterbacks from each squad.
Henry is listed at 6'1" and 32 years old, while Chris is listed at 6'0" and 34 years old. Basically the same in height and age.
This one would be close, I think. Captain America is every bit as physically demanding a role as Superman is for an actor. I haven't seen either of their non-superhero roles very much. I'm thinking Cavill is stronger and more durable, but Evans is a better fighter. If they met in the octagon, I think ... honestly I don't know. Coin-flip. Screw it, I'ma say Henry Cavill wins, just by a hair. What do you think?
If you like, make up your own Disney Marvel actor vs Warner DC actor fight and try to follow the ground rules.