Captain America vs Captain America

[Lord Falcon]

Movieverse Steve Rogers with all his usual gear takes on comic Steve Rogers naked.

[Stigmazilla]

Movieverse Steve Rogers with all his usual gear takes on comic Steve Rogers naked.

No expert but I think MCU is stronger the shield just lynches it

[rhyvurg]

No expert but I think MCU is stronger the shield just lynches it

I wouldn't be so sure. MCU Cap threw his shield and dented tank armor. Comic cap threw his shield and it went through a large delivery truck, lengthwise, including the engine block.

[The Drunkard Kid]

Comic Steve is also much faster and significantly more skilled, so even if we spot MCU Steve a significant strength edge, he's not going to land a hit and will be taking pressure point strikes and the like in every pass. Not to mention that he can easily dodge/intercept the shield if it's thrown.

[rhyvurg]

Comic Steve is also much faster and significantly more skilled, so even if we spot MCU Steve a significant strength edge, he's not going to land a hit and will be taking pressure point strikes and the like in every pass. Not to mention that he can easily dodge/intercept the shield if it's thrown.

Don't forget experience, he has well over a century of combat under his belt thanks to Kang's Groundhog Day shenanigans.

[Pendaran]

Don't forget experience, he has well over a century of combat under his belt thanks to Kang's Groundhog Day shenanigans.

That's functionally meaningless honestly, things like that. There's really nothing that particularly demonstrates it in practice to some grand extent.

[The Dork Knight]

He's not much faster . And he's not so skilled as to overcome the stats advantage of an about as fast opponent . MCU Cap wins

[Anarchist]

Yeah, MCU Cap is one of the very rare instances of a movie version being more powerful than the mainstream version.

[MidTierHero]

MCU Cap hasn't done anything that 616 Cap isn't capable of, to the best of my recollection.

[zhris]

Since the shield is the signature weapon for both, it may be a moot point; one Cap throws it, the other catches it. In my head, I see them trading it back and forth. Does he have any other specific toys besides the shield?

[The Drunkard Kid]

He's not much faster . And he's not so skilled as to overcome the stats advantage of an about as fast opponent . MCU Cap wins

Not more skilled?

MCU Cap is good, but he hasn't pulled off anything like standard CBPH martial artist tomfoolery like cartwheeling through multiple streams of gunfire and energy blasts from every direction, dropping low end metas with pressure points, doing shield throws that make MCU Cap look like he's just messing around with a frisbee, etc...

Not to mention that MU Cap has several times the experience as MCU Cap at fighting opponent's on that level, even discounting temporal shenanigans.

[Cthulhu_of_R'lyeh]

Captain America takes it decisively.

[Pendaran]

Not to mention that MU Cap has several times the experience as MCU Cap at fighting opponent's on that level, even discounting temporal shenanigans.

Again, I'm increasingly thin on this as a relevant concept to.. much of anything really, outside of, I suppose, scenario matches where a broader knowledge of things might impact potential plans for dealing with things, or having to face people with especially funky powers and weaknesses, or how well one uses one's funky powers. This is a straight up fight, neither person involved is especially much capable of esoterica.

[Hiromi]

Captain America takes it decisively.

I don't know I think Captain America loses 10 out of 10 times here

[Cthulhu_of_R'lyeh]

I don't know I think Captain America loses 10 out of 10 times here

Fair enough, Captain America's feats are all over the place, and I can't remember where he's pegged hereabouts. So a 10/10 for Captain America is definitely possible.