About madelyne pryor

[jeanandscott]

Was madelyne's feelings to scott really true or only something atumatic to make a son ?
I remember phoenix told to scott madelyne was never really in love with him
and also she had an affair with alex and seemed to be in love with him

[ZNOP]

Was madelyne's feelings to scott really true or only something atumatic to make a son ?
I remember phoenix told to scott madelyne was never really in love with him
and also she had an affair with alex and seemed to be in love with him

Madelyne Jennifer Pryor

[jeanandscott]

Madelyne Jennifer Pryor

This don't really explain a lot
like she had a lot of lovers but at end still seemed obssesed with scott but at end she ended up saying she never really loves scott
Maybe this was just a writter's mistake and I'm thinking too much in this lol sorry

[ZNOP]

Here ya go! You need to read or reread "Inferno" again. Canon clearly states that Mr. Sinister programmed Madelyne to fall in love (She didn't have a choice in the beginning) with Scott Summers (See: Uncanny X-Men #241, and X-Factor v1 #38) -- but, with the rebirth of her genetic template Jean Grey; Scott flat leaving her and their baby when he learned of her return, her attempted murder by the Marauders combined with the manipulative machination of N'astirh and S'ym that programming was broken and she went Dark Phoenix on everyone... If Maddie ended up saying she never really loved Scott, there were several damn good reasons why.

[Anodyne]

In the beginning Madelyne honestly believed her feelings were real, as Claremont intended. She knew nothing of Sinister's machinations til much later.

As for Maddie and Alex, he was there for her when she needed someone; but I don't believe she would have acted on her feelings without the demonic influence. They were both on the rebound.

When did Phoenix tell Scott that Madelyne never really loved him?

[ZNOP]

In the beginning Madelyne honestly believed her feelings were real, as Claremont intended. She knew nothing of Sinister's machinations til much later.

Isn't that what I just said

[jeanandscott]

In the beginning Madelyne honestly believed her feelings were real, as Claremont intended. She knew nothing of Sinister's machinations til much later.

As for Maddie and Alex, he was there for her when she needed someone; but I don't believe she would have acted on her feelings without the demonic influence. They were both on the rebound.

When did Phoenix tell Scott that Madelyne never really loved him?

Uncanny X-Men issue 511
Phoenix says something like "Madelyne Pryor" but since Phoenix could be just lying to scott to make him mad I got confused
So at end Madelyne really never loved Scott, it's kinda confusing given hte fact she still seems obssesed with im (to the point of pretending to be Emma only to make sex with him)

[Ricochet Rita]

Was madelyne's feelings to scott really true or only something atumatic to make a son ?

Canon clearly states that Mr. Sinister programmed Madelyne to fall in love (She didn't have a choice in the beginning) with Scott Summers

In the beginning Madelyne honestly believed her feelings were real, as Claremont intended. She knew nothing of Sinister's machinations til much later.

Being a clone genetically programmed to love somebody doesn't mean that your feelings are not true --just means (as ZNOP stated) that you have scarcely a choice to feel otherwise. Ergo: Madelyne really loved Scott. As a matter of fact, what I doubt is that Scott really loved Madelyne.

[Bronze Badger]

ZNOP is being recognized as some of authority? The guy who uses Comic Sans? What a time to be alive.

[ZNOP]

Uncanny X-Men issue 511
Phoenix says something like "Madelyne Pryor" but since Phoenix could be just lying to scott to make him mad I got confused
So at end Madelyne really never loved Scott, it's kinda confusing given hte fact she still seems obssesed with im (to the point of pretending to be Emma only to make sex with him)

There is no precedence for the Phoenix Force ever being a lying cosmic entity.

ZNOP is being recognized as some of authority? The guy who uses Comic Sans? What a time to be alive.

It's a comic book forum, therefore I use the "Comic Sans MS" font... Don't hate just because I'm consistent

[Ricochet Rita]

ZNOP is being recognized as some of authority? The guy who uses Comic Sans? What a time to be alive.

I'm not recognizing ZNOP as authority. I'm just saying that I agree with his/her post. Maybe I made a bad choice using the word 'state'?

[ZNOP]

No, you didn't make a "bad choice" -- your being trolled solely for agreeing with me.

[Anodyne]

Being a clone genetically programmed to love somebody doesn't mean that your feelings are not true --just means (as ZNOP stated) that you have scarcely a choice to feel otherwise. Ergo: Madelyne really loved Scott. As a matter of fact, what I doubt is that Scott really loved Madelyne.

For that matter, do any of us really get to choose with whom we'll fall in love? We can choose whom we'll marry (or have an affair with), but IMHO we can't control whom we'll find attractive.

[DDD]

ZNOP is being recognized as some of authority? The guy who uses Comic Sans? What a time to be alive.

You're back♥♥♥