Yeah, I don't know if anyone recalls this, but originally, All-Star Superman was supposed to have a redesigned version of the S - and this version was actually seen!
In the earliest preview of #1, as I recall it, you could see Superman wearing this variation of the shield, but only there - once later previews came out, and the actual comic, the redesigned shield had been replaced.
As I understand it, both Morrison and editorial changed their mind on it, but I think Quitely was still for it - and apparently the S-shield at the end of All-Star, the backwards one on the big vault-door, is it?
Doe ANYONE have pictures of this? Especially some before and after -shots from the previews and the published page? Would be awesome to see.