Your Unpopular/Controversial Opinions on the X-Universe

[yogaflame]

To be fair, it's not like you're gonna catch something from him, his healing factor essentially sterilizes them.

[Hizashi]

Here’s another one: the free love, polyamory thing is not a good thing — for the X-Men as a whole at the least.

[Zelena]

To be fair, it's not like you're gonna catch something from him, his healing factor essentially sterilizes them.

I doubt his “healing factor” sterilizes the surface of his body.

[yogaflame]

If he has a mutant healing factor that let's him shrug off all known diseases, most toxins, and regenerate from grievous injuries, you really think he's harboring staph or e coli?

[Zelena]

If he has a mutant healing factor that let's him shrug off all known diseases, most toxins, and regenerate from grievous injuries, you really think he's harboring staph or e coli?

I was thinking about viruses but I’m not a specialist… I heard it was safe to eat cockroaches: they have a very efficient immune system…

[Havok83]

More of a small take: any depictions of Logan using his claws to eat/cook/prepare food is crazy. Those things have been in A: his arms, most of the time, B: in other people half the time and C: never been cleaned ever.

Laura does that sh-t too

To be fair, it's not like you're gonna catch something from him, his healing factor essentially sterilizes them.

Its still nasty.

[yogaflame]

I was thinking about viruses but I’m not a specialist… I heard it was safe to eat cockroaches: they have a very efficient immune system…

In some stories Logan's blood is given to sick, or even recently dead people to heal them. He doesn't carry any viruses or other pathogens, if anything it might boost your immune system for a hot second.

[SpiderClops]

More of a small take: any depictions of Logan using his claws to eat/cook/prepare food is crazy. Those things have been in A: his arms, most of the time, B: in other people half the time and C: never been cleaned ever.

Yeah, that really disgusts me. Not to mention that canonically(even if the artists forget it many times) the claws break through his skin to come out and always draw blood.

[Tunasammiches]

Here’s another one: the free love, polyamory thing is not a good thing — for the X-Men as a whole at the least.

Why? Please explain.

[Hizashi]

Why? Please explain.

Does it make sense for some characters? Sure, probably. Does it make sense for it to be the norm with everyone? No, not at all. If the point is to make the reader unsettled about how things are being run in Krakoa, then it’s successful. If however, this is meant to be some normal thing moving forward, it makes no sense to me. Characters can’t simply go from happy and fulfilled with monogamy to all-in on polyamory.

[Striderblack01]

Here’s another one: the free love, polyamory thing is not a good thing — for the X-Men as a whole at the least.

Has, uh...

Has there been a fourth Krakoan law passed about polyamory?
Because if so, I am in!

[gonnagiveittoya]

Yeah while Krakoa has been basically a party island the poly stuff has pretty much only been Emma, Scott, Jean and Logan. Everyone else's relationship status seems (from what I've seen) more or less the same.

[Hizashi]

Has, uh...

Has there been a fourth Krakoan law passed about polyamory?
Because if so, I am in!

No, no law. I mean, that would make it worse...

[comicboy12]

A lot of the titles on krokoa (the quiet council, red queen, Spring, the great captains etc.....) sound really dumb and pompous

[Hizashi]

Yeah while Krakoa has been basically a party island the poly stuff has pretty much only been Emma, Scott, Jean and Logan. Everyone else's relationship status seems (from what I've seen) more or less the same.

I’ve only really been picking up X-Men and I guess I just had a vibe that it was more prevalent — still, even if it’s absolutely only them, it doesn’t make sense. Has Emma even been involved in any way? I thought it was a triangle situation.