Your Unpopular/Controversial Opinions on the X-Universe

[Beetle]

and he fixxed it as he still had it in Cable's series. Regardless, he still did not have a flesh arm. He couldnt have been restored via resurrection as he had 2 flesh arms in Uncanny X-men

I think he was fully flesh when he came back in Uncanny X-Force, I just assumed that the Mummudrai hunting cult that brainwashed him after Cable and Hope left him in the future figured out how to replace his arm before sending him back to kill Cassandra Nova

[PrezValentine]

Speaking of which, how did Bishop lose his cybernetic arm and get a flesh one?

He died in the future where he was stranded and the guys from The Order brought him back with magic. They probably also helped him recover his arm and eye, as the issue where this is shown seems to imply, since he has both after they took him in and trained him.

[Rev9]

and he fixxed it as he still had it in Cable's series. Regardless, he still did not have a flesh arm. He couldnt have been restored via resurrection as he had 2 flesh arms in Uncanny X-men

What I mean is even if he had metallic arms, maybe resurrections allow for tweaking of augmentations.If he wanted his arms normal,he could have just told Xavier and that
Was it.Wolverine possibly could also be restored without adamantium,but he is not worth much without it ,so Wolverine probably doesn't want to get rid of it

[Havok83]

What I mean is even if he had metallic arms, maybe resurrections allow for tweaking of augmentations.If he wanted his arms normal,he could have just told Xavier and that
Was it.Wolverine possibly could also be restored without adamantium,but he is not worth much without it ,so Wolverine probably doesn't want to get rid of it

and I dont think you get what Im saying. Bishop's arm was fixxed before the Resurrection protocols were a thing in the books so thats definitely NOT how his arm got fixxed.

I think he was fully flesh when he came back in Uncanny X-Force, I just assumed that the Mummudrai hunting cult that brainwashed him after Cable and Hope left him in the future figured out how to replace his arm before sending him back to kill Cassandra Nova

He died in the future where he was stranded and the guys from The Order brought him back with magic. They probably also helped him recover his arm and eye, as the issue where this is shown seems to imply, since he has both after they took him in and trained him.

Thanks! I never read through UXF so I assumed it was covered there but was unclear

[Ra-El]

Does Kid Cable still have the technovirus? If yes, why not bring him back without it? He would be more usefull to Krakoa if he could use the full extension of his powers.

[Harpsikord]

Does Kid Cable still have the technovirus? If yes, why not bring him back without it? He would be more usefull to Krakoa if he could use the full extension of his powers.

Based on his use of his Telekinesis in issue one of the new solo, he has been brought back without it.

[Havok83]

Does Kid Cable still have the technovirus? If yes, why not bring him back without it? He would be more usefull to Krakoa if he could use the full extension of his powers.

Yes he dos. Why would he be brought back without it? The narrative is that he is supposed to be the same character that grows up to be adult Cable, who did have it. It wouldnt make sense if he had a flesh arm and that would be a way for people to dismiss him as not being the real deal.

Based on his use of his Telekinesis in issue one of the new solo, he has been brought back without it.

He never died and he had the TO in X-Force

[Wiccan]

Yes he dos. Why would he be brought back without it? The narrative is that he is supposed to be the same character that grows up to be adult Cable, who did have it. It wouldnt make sense if he had a flesh arm and that would be a way for people to dismiss him as not being the real deal.

I think they mean "Why(from an in-story standpoint) doesn't he die to get resurrected with his full powers back?".

[Havok83]

I think they mean "Why(from an in-story standpoint) doesn't he die to get resurrected with his full powers back?".

Because Xavier isnt going around ordering mutants executed so he can bring them back more powerful nor are others volunteering that. That comes with its own questionable moral and ethical issues. There is also the fact that this Cable being around in and of itself is a mess. Killing him and getting rid of the TO would create more of a continuity issue

FYI does anyone remember what the hell happened with him in that forgettable Fallen Angels mini. The art was dark and bad but Nathan was captured and it looks like his arms are flesh while shirtless. The wraith was calling him a machine and talked alot about mutants and technology and Im unclear if he removed the TO or what bc the art is unclear and the story didnt make sense

[Slicknickshady]

Marauders and X-Force have been pretty good.

I enjoy both but I can’t help but always go back to the main universe. The are having to do things that follow Hickman’s plans. So the good moments in all these books are overshadowed at least to me by Hickman. That’s on me and not the authors of these Dawn of X books. But it doesn’t matter how good the writing is or how cute some moments are if the plot turns you off. Maybe it’s because I had high expectations with seeing that Moira was gonna be in it... and then they basically change everything about Moira.

As a Nightcrawler fan.. he may as well be dead with as little impact as he has had. Kitty another fave of mine is dead.. at least perceived or temporarily. Rogue another fave was asleep and has barely been around either. Yes she’s been in more then Nightcrawler and Kitty. But mostly as wallpaper.

Magma being back is a plus.

Roberto being out in space flirty with a disgusting alien.. terrible decision by Hickman. But this is can deal with but figured I’d put it out there.

I am excited for X Factor cause Eye Boy but my online run ins with Leah make me nervous for it. Just preparing myself for the Trevor transitioning to a women arc. It will make no sense for the character but watch her do that. Trevors just the sort of character Marvel would give Leah the ok to make a women.

Well see.

[Kingdom X]

I enjoy both but I can’t help but always go back to the main universe. The are having to do things that follow Hickman’s plans. So the good moments in all these books are overshadowed at least to me by Hickman. That’s on me and not the authors of these Dawn of X books. But it doesn’t matter how good the writing is or how cute some moments are if the plot turns you off. Maybe it’s because I had high expectations with seeing that Moira was gonna be in it... and then they basically change everything about Moira.

As a Nightcrawler fan.. he may as well be dead with as little impact as he has had. Kitty another fave of mine is dead.. at least perceived or temporarily. Rogue another fave was asleep and has barely been around either. Yes she’s been in more then Nightcrawler and Kitty. But mostly as wallpaper.

Magma being back is a plus.

Roberto being out in space flirty with a disgusting alien.. terrible decision by Hickman. But this is can deal with but figured I’d put it out there.

I am excited for X Factor cause Eye Boy but my online run ins with Leah make me nervous for it. Just preparing myself for the Trevor transitioning to a women arc. It will make no sense for the character but watch her do that. Trevors just the sort of character Marvel would give Leah the ok to make a women.

Well see.

I’m not even gonna try to dissect that last paragraph, but I hear you on Nightcrawler. Kitty played a big role in the beginning and I have a feeling that her story is gonna be really important after XoS.

[Will Evans]

I enjoy both but I can’t help but always go back to the main universe. The are having to do things that follow Hickman’s plans. So the good moments in all these books are overshadowed at least to me by Hickman. That’s on me and not the authors of these Dawn of X books. But it doesn’t matter how good the writing is or how cute some moments are if the plot turns you off. Maybe it’s because I had high expectations with seeing that Moira was gonna be in it... and then they basically change everything about Moira.

As a Nightcrawler fan.. he may as well be dead with as little impact as he has had. Kitty another fave of mine is dead.. at least perceived or temporarily. Rogue another fave was asleep and has barely been around either. Yes she’s been in more then Nightcrawler and Kitty. But mostly as wallpaper.

Magma being back is a plus.

Roberto being out in space flirty with a disgusting alien.. terrible decision by Hickman. But this is can deal with but figured I’d put it out there.

I am excited for X Factor cause Eye Boy but my online run ins with Leah make me nervous for it. Just preparing myself for the Trevor transitioning to a women arc. It will make no sense for the character but watch her do that. Trevors just the sort of character Marvel would give Leah the ok to make a women.

Well see.

Didn’t Leah hint the transitioning mutant would be one of the victims X-Factor team was going to investigate for resurrection. Since that’s their job.

[jwatson]

Yes he dos. Why would he be brought back without it? The narrative is that he is supposed to be the same character that grows up to be adult Cable, who did have it. It wouldnt make sense if he had a flesh arm and that would be a way for people to dismiss him as not being the real deal.



He never died and he had the TO in X-Force

I thought the techo organic virus was purged from him in the xforce story where be goes and saves Rachel and she used the askani powers to purge it from his girlfriend that was fully submerged in the techno organic virus and himself that was almost completely covered at the time.

[ARkadelphia]

I liked the Alpha Flight revival in the 90's. There was, at least to me, an insinuation that two of the team members - brothers were Wolverines children. I'm not sure if that was ever addressed again. Also I liked the art. Campbell Scott did the interiors and most of the covers, he started out doing some work for the Image line and did a issue or two of X-Men as well. I also liked the story, I found it engaging and the characters as well. I don't think it should be cancelled so soon. The costume designs were rather cool as well.

I for one would welcome an Alpha Flight revival with some of the 90’s characters included in addition to some of the classics, ESPECIALLY Radius and Flex.

[Havok83]

How ironic all those posts about disabled characters getting resurrected so that they can become normal and Leah answers that in this weke's BOTA podcast. Basically she says its wrong. X-men works as an allegory for disabilities too and it doesnt sit right with her that a disabled mutant has to die in order to become what others view as normal. Instead of these disable mutants needing to change in order to fit into society, Krakoa changes to fit their needs. They arent disadvantaged and there is nothing to fix. Readers may see their artificial limbs as a problem but the characters may not necessarily feel that way

I thought the techo organic virus was purged from him in the xforce story where be goes and saves Rachel and she used the askani powers to purge it from his girlfriend that was fully submerged in the techno organic virus and himself that was almost completely covered at the time.

Nah. He has the TO in his final shot of the series