Your Unpopular/Controversial Opinions on the X-Universe

[Hizashi]

Well, either way, there are a few arguably terrible ideas in Endgame and it should not be a template for the X-Men.

[SpiderClops]

I would kill for a movie like Endgame for X-Men.

[Woozie]

Why even bring up Endgame or Infinity War? They're not template Movies, they're bookends.

[Hizashi]

I would kill for a movie like Endgame for X-Men.

I don't know man, they straight up mishandled or misused all of the original Avengers.

Why even bring up Endgame or Infinity War? They're not template Movies, they're bookends.

Okay, then they were bad bookends and shouldn't be emulated/used as templates.

[PCN24454]

I feel like they inflated the power levels of mutants way too much.

[Ikari]

I feel like they inflated the power levels of mutants way too much.

Yeah it is getting hard to find mutants who are NOT Omega-level.

[Zelena]

I respectfully disagree, that's what AU's are for. Or maybe Marvel should copy DC's Earth One graphic novel concept - although admittedly only the Green Lantern series has been stellar, the rest mediocre to outright terrible.

The controversies spring from poor editorial decisions more than anything in my opinion.

Then I can settle for short-arc stories or standalone issues… and a “bible” about the comicverse. If there’s more than one creative team, the authors should do their homework.

[Woozie]

Okay, then they were bad bookends and shouldn't be emulated/used as templates.

You are a comic nerd, who is in the ULTRA minority. They're not going to listen to Mr 1 of maybe 60k people

[Kingdom X]

Then I can settle for short-arc stories or standalone issues… and a “bible” about the comicverse. If there’s more than one creative team, the authors should do their homework.

Isn’t this kinda what Milestone did? It would definitely lead to more consistent stories.

[comicboy12]

None of the current writers and artists on x-men could create a decent action sequence to save their lives. Everything's just gonna be boring splash pages and anticlimactic fights fans eat up because their it's their fav being "badass"

[Hizashi]

I feel like they inflated the power levels of mutants way too much.

This is true.

[Hizashi]

Then I can settle for short-arc stories or standalone issues… and a “bible” about the comicverse. If there’s more than one creative team, the authors should do their homework.

There should absolutely be more one-shot stories — not as separate $5+ books but just as a breather story in long runs.

[Hizashi]

You are a comic nerd, who is in the ULTRA minority. They're not going to listen to Mr 1 of maybe 60k people

Let me howl at the moons reflection.

[GMikey]

I would kill for a movie like Endgame for X-Men.

Believe it or not, a core of Marvel fans are aiming to do that...

Not necessarily the same narrative at all, but... collaborate on a narrative for the Avengers and X-Men, alongside GOTG, Spider-Man, and introducing, the Fantastic 4. Several hobbyist artists and animators are pitching in, and well... we're close to already a couple of shorts being uploaded. The goal is for fans to create our OWN Marvel narrative, according to the perspectives of fans. To make this cohesive as a narrative, a former instructor is helping with the vision, and structuring a story. It's awesome, and I believe this would give many fans... what we've all wanted, in some way, shape or form

[gonnagiveittoya]

More of a small take: any depictions of Logan using his claws to eat/cook/prepare food is crazy. Those things have been in A: his arms, most of the time, B: in other people half the time and C: never been cleaned ever.