Your Unpopular/Controversial Opinions on the X-Universe

[Hizashi]

I want to see a new Brotherhood that still believes in mutant dominance through force and wants nothing to so with Krakoa.

That would be cool.

[Starfish]

I prefer Hollow/Penance as her own character instead of a pointless alternate form of Monet.

[Adam-X]

I prefer Hollow/Penance as her own character instead of a pointless alternate form of Monet.

That should not be unpopular. Because, I so strongly agree it's not even funny. I brought that very thing up in the Penance/M thread.

[AdamFTF]

I prefer Hollow/Penance as her own character instead of a pointless alternate form of Monet.

Totally agree. I want to see Penance finally get her intended origin.

It's funny, we nearly got an autistic mutant heroine (M) and a deaf mutant heroine (Penance), but because of all the messing around with M and Penance, now we have neither.

[red winter]

Spider girl is a mutant.
Every one says she’s not despite that she was born with powers just like Franklin Richards who’s parents have powers

[Chris0013]

I may be the only one...but I want Aurora Dante to show up in 616.

[Wolverine12]

I may be the only one...but I want Aurora Dante to show up in 616.

Who is that?

[Chris0013]

Who is that?

Iceman's 1/2 sister from the Spider-Man and His Amazing Friends. Same universe Firestar originated in.

[Doom'nGloom]

This is one of the best x related media out there for the sheer ridiculousness.


It's the X-men/FF crossover we deserve. Okay, maybe the last part is a bit too much.

[Uncanny X-Man]

This is one of the best x related media out there for the sheer ridiculousness.


It's the X-men/FF crossover we deserve. Okay, maybe the last part is a bit too much.

OMG this is hilarious. Magneto sounds like an old man being taken away to a retirement home... by cops with their metal belts in their shiny metal cars.

[Chris0013]

This is one of the best x related media out there for the sheer ridiculousness.


It's the X-men/FF crossover we deserve. Okay, maybe the last part is a bit too much.

That is just horrific.

[rcaguy]

That is just horrific.

Ummm.....Aren't they standing on a planet mostly made of Iron? Wouldn't Magneto be able to sense if he had actually lost his powers?

[Chris0013]

Ummm.....Aren't they standing on a planet mostly made of Iron?

Not just that...but the metal cars and the guns the cops have and that Magneto did not try to do anything as the cops lead him away.

[Paragon]

Not just that...but the metal cars and the guns the cops have and that Magneto did not try to do anything as the cops lead him away.

Fail at something once, never try again. Clearly the defining trait of Magneto.

[Rev9]

I dont know if Hickman knows this but he doesn't need Xavier at all fir his story. Fixx has all those powers and more. That is the major flaw in his story.

To be fair didn't know or read on Fixx and the Xavier enforcers storyline,thanks to you I know who Fixx is and you are absolutely right , this story could easily be told through Fixx and you bring Xavier later on , but I guess who knows we may yet be surprised that life 10 is the golem of Moira running things as she was re-wired by Lilandra and Xavier to pull off a Social Darwinism experiment.Moira and the enforcers from life 11 could in to set Krakoa right ...