VOTE for your Favorite Villain turned Hero

[akiresu_]

1) Magneto
2) Legion
3) Warpath
4) Emma Frost
5) Rogue
6) Risque
7) Juggernaut
8) Quicksilver
9) Sabretooth
10) Danger

[Ricochet Rita]

After discussion, I had to take Karma of the list. She was blackmailed into helping het villainous uncle, but was 'forced'. Therefore she would not count.

Probably the same then is applicable for Banshee, I guess. let me know what you all think. (I hate those borderline situations haha)

Sorry!

That's what I thought. It's like saying that sex slaves are willingly prostitutes, when their owners are threatening them to kill their relatives if they don't pay their (unfair) debts.

I will wait, then, for some hours (later I'll be gone...).

[Bl00dwerK]

After discussion, I had to take Karma of the list. She was blackmailed into helping het villainous uncle, but was 'forced'. Therefore she would not count. Probably the same then is applicable for Banshee, I guess.

Edited my vote and replaced both, just in case...

[Confuzzled]

1. Dame Emma
2. Warpath
3. Sage
4. Legion
5. Rogue
6. Magneto
7. Callisto
8. Frenzy
9. Dr. Kavita Rao
10. Siryn

[nx01a]

So... No Banshee? Or X-23?

[Rivka]

01. Magneto
02. Emma Frost
03. Rogue
04. Frenzy
05. Quicksilver
06. Siryn
07. Danger
08. Sage
09. Random
10. Risque

(I consider the Scarlet Witch to still be a villain. )

Edited as I'm informed that neither Karima nor Karma qualify.

[Witchfan]

Scarlet Witch

[kp404]

1) Emma Frost

It is without question that she fills this role within the X-Men. She turned heroic and yet kept her personality. What a brilliant character who contributes so much to the X-Mythos.

Agreed. Emma Frost along with Rogue and Juggie are the best answers here

[forgotten_utopia]

1 Emma Frost
2 Rogue
3 Quicksilver
4 Scarlet Witch
5 Deadpool
6 Magneto
7 Caliban
8 Kid Omega
9 Danger
10 Callisto

[theoneandonly]

Nador was a villain indeed but in those he never encountered the X-Men I believe.

One I do doubt about is Revanche. Was she not a villain part of the Hand? I'm not sure.

He did come into contact with them and professor X even speculated that he was the first mutant.

[Master of Sound]

He did come into contact with them and professor X even speculated that he was the first mutant.

Not in the time WWII when he was a villain.....

[Wiccan]

1 - Scarlet Witch
2 - Rogue
3 - Magneto
4 - Quicksilver
5 - Kid Omega
6 - Legion
7 - Frenzy
8 - Callisto
9 - Siryn
10 - Danger

[theoneandonly]

Not in the time WWII when he was a villain.....

When was he portrayed as a villain in WW 2? As far as I know he was fighting on the side of Allies and was considered a hero then.

[JustAnotherFan]

1. Mimic
2. Changeling
3. Scarlet Witch
4. Sabretooth
5. Caliban
6. Legion
7. Frenzy
8. Kwannon
9. Marrow
10. Juggernaut

[JustAnotherFan]

Not in the time WWII when he was a villain.....

Namor wasn't a villain back in WWII? He was a hero back then. His main stint as a villain was when he returned in the 60's. And that's when he encountered Brotherhood of Mutants and X-Men (though I'm not sure if he actually fought X-Men alongside Brotherhood).


And as for Banshee, Karma, Northstar (and rest of Alpha Flight) and most of the Morlocks (not including the most well known ones like, Masque, Sunder, Callisto and Caliban) I definitely don't consider them to have ever been real villains if we choose to not count those who were only antagonists for the X-Men and only fought X-Men because they were coerced or ordered or brainwashed to do so and not because they were actually opposed to X-Men or evil. And I think that it's good to draw the line there because if we counted among the former villains turned heroes everyone who ever was a part of villain team or fought X-Men for whatever reason (coercion, brainwashing, etc.) the we would have to count half the X-Men in there.