VOTE: Favorite good guy became bad

[Master of Sound]

Most good guys who are part of the X-verse who turned bad, only did it for a short time and due to other factors, being influenced, possessed or forced into attacking the X-Men. There was done a voting thread about those, of which the results are revealed this week.

But there are also those who choose to change. Like WWII heroes Stonewall, Commando and Super Sabre, who volunteered becoming part of Freedom Force.

Or former X-Men Vulcan, or Bishop, who became enemies of their former teammates.

There are not many. So please submit a top 10 of favorites, or a top 5 if you really can not come up with 10.

These are the ones I could think of. If you have others, just add them to your top 10 and I'll add them to the list.

Amelia Voght
AoA Husk
AoA Iceman
AoA Nightcrawler
Bishop
Colossus as Acolyte
Crimson Commando
Esmé Cuckoo
Garrison Kane
Grizzly
Joseph
Lionheart
Madelyne Pryor (as Red Queen, THAT was her own choosing)
Mikhail Rasputin
Mortis
Rory Campbell becomes Ahab
Rusty Collins (Firefist), joining Acolytes
Skids, joining Acolytes
Stonewall
Strongguy, becoming Supreme Hell Lord
Super Sabre
Tier Sinclair
Ultimate Jean Grey
Ultimate Psylocke
Vulcan
Wallflower in House of M
Wither
Zero (Kenji)

[Mutant God]

Vulcan
Red/Goblin Queen
Mortis
Bishop
Wither
Zero
Joseph
Strong Guy
Molly Hayes (Battle of the Atom)
Tier Sinclair (if he counts)

[nx01a]

Additions and edits to come...

1. Colossus (joins Acolytes)
2. Bishop (tries to kill Hope)
3. Joseph (Brotherhood)
4. Wither (joins Selene)
5. Mikhail Rasputin (went crazy, brutal leadership of the Morlocks in alt. dimension)
6. Zero (tries to kill Hope)
7. Amelia Voght (joined Acolytes, worshiped Magneto's helmet)
8. Madelyne Pryor (Red Queen)
9. Esmé Cuckoo
10. Vulcan

[Master of Sound]

Vulcan
Red/Goblin Queen
Mortis
Bishop
Wither
Zero
Joseph
Strong Guy
Molly Hayes (Battle of the Atom)
Tier Sinclair (if he counts)

Strongguy? Did I miss something?

EDIT: I was informed he became a Hell Lord, so I have added him to the list.

[Master of Sound]

Additions and edits to come...

1. Colossus
2. Bishop
3. Joseph
4. Zero
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.

Colossus? If you mean his current change, we know it's under influence of Apocalypse. So....

[Anduinel]

Colossus? If you mean his current change, we know it's under influence of Apocalypse. So....

He did choose to join Magento, but it was a brief stint. Plus there's some question of if he was even in his right mind due to a head wound.

I'm having a hard time with this one. There are characters I like here, but their turns to villainy were largely done so badly...

[nx01a]

I'll add the specifics of the turns to villainy after each character's name.

He did choose to join Magneto, but it was a brief stint. Plus there's some question of if he was even in his right mind due to a head wound.

The X-Men healed his head wound 3 or so issues later in the final part of Fatal Attractions and Peter willingly returned to the Acolytes. His grief at Illyana's death, the deaths of his entire family, the Legacy Virus, and general disillusionment with Xavier's dream were to blame, not the X-Cutioner's cranial slice and dice.

[Ricochet Rita]

I wonder why this (insistent) wrong notion of 'atheist' as someone who 'believes in nothing' :/ .

[Master of Sound]

I'll add the specifics of the turns to villainy after each character's name.
The X-Men healed his head wound 3 or so issues later in the final part of Fatal Attractions and Peter willingly returned to the Acolytes. His grief at Illyana's death, the deaths of his entire family, the Legacy Virus, and general disillusionment with Xavier's dream were to blame, not the X-Cutioner's cranial slice and dice.

Yeah, but him joining the Acolytes did not make him a villain, right? He never even fought with the Acolytes.

[Master of Sound]

Molly Hayes (Battle of the Atom)
Tier Sinclair (if he counts)

These seem valid. I will add them to the list

[Taral-DLOS]

Was AoA Nightcrawler "bad"? I don't remember exactly what he did (I remember he betrayed the team, but I thought it was just to get home, not to do anything particularly villainous, unlike Vulcan and Bishop, who also became "enemies of their former teammates", but did villainous things). He's my #1 if he counts, but I don't know that he should count.


1. Bishop
2. AoA Iceman
3. Wither
4. Vulcan
5. AoA Husk
6. Wallflower (HoM)
7. Ultimate Psylocke
8. Rusty Collins
9. Ultimate Jean Grey
10. Joseph

[Taral-DLOS]

These seem valid. I will add them to the list

Molly Hayes shouldn't be valid. We learned in a subsequent arc that the Brotherhood in Battle of the Atom (except Raze) were being controlled/possessed by the young Xavier.

[Master of Sound]

Molly Hayes shouldn't be valid. We learned in a subsequent arc that the Brotherhood in Battle of the Atom (except Raze) were being controlled/possessed by the young Xavier.

Ohhh. I forgot. Sorry

[Anduinel]

2. Prodigy (in the New X-Men arc "Too Much Information", he was shown the potential consequences of being able to retain what he learns through his powers, and that was villainy. It was a fantasy scenario, but I think it should count).

I disagree. Not only did David not do anything villainous, the whole point of the story was to show David's fear of what he might do without a block on his powers.

[darkalamator]

1. Madelyne
2. AoA Iceman
3. Esme
4. AoA Husk
5. Wither
6. Rusty Collins
7. AoA Husk
8. Mikhail Rasputin
9. Joseph
10. Strongguy