Award for best Comic show tv casting of all time goes to.....

[numberthirty]

You know, I remember the song "Big, Bad John" but I'm pretty sure he was a mine worker, and I don't recall any reference to him being black?

Are you sure you're not confusing the song with the legend of John Henry?

Since he saves them from a mine collapse, it's a pretty safe bet he was a mine worker.

[Carabas]

Michale J white Bronze Tiger(dont know why they criminally underused him.)

He was so underused he didn't have a big enough part to see if he was cast well or not. Barely any lines at all.

[Mark Thrust]

Michael Chiklis as Vic Mackey.
Runner up:
Jason Alexander as George Costanza

[Midvillian1322]

He was so underused he didn't have a big enough part to see if he was cast well or not. Barely any lines at all.

He was in 3 or 4 episodes right? I liked every episode he was in, just wish he woulda be a main villian or a reformed sometime ally

[Midvillian1322]

Michael Chiklis as Vic Mackey.
Runner up:
Jason Alexander as George Costanza

Vic mackey? I didnt know the Shield was a comic, who wrote it?

Edit: Nvm your second choice was from Seinfeld.

[Totoro Man]

Vic mackey? I didnt know the Shield was a comic, who wrote it?

Edit: Nvm your second choice was from Seinfeld.

pretty sure Mark Thrust is an indie comics hipster who looks down on superheroes as childish. so... yeah. he's just ridiculing the thread concept for fun.

[Carabas]

He was in 3 or 4 episodes right? I liked every episode he was in, just wish he woulda be a main villian or a reformed sometime ally

Three episodes, in which he had all the presence and charisma and talking ability of a brick wall. And I don't want Ben Turner to be any kind of villain.

[Osiris-Rex]

Michael Chiklis as Vic Mackey.
Runner up:
Jason Alexander as George Costanza

I'm pretty sure Seinfeld wasn't based on a comic book. The title wasn't phrased that well, but I am pretty sure it meant TV shows based comic books, not TV comedy shows.

[Jim Kelly]

Nobody can argue that SEINFELD wasn't comic.

. . . Well, I guess you could--but I wouldn't think highly about your sense of humour.

[Midvillian1322]

Three episodes, in which he had all the presence and charisma and talking ability of a brick wall. And I don't want Ben Turner to be any kind of villain.

Well that would be ignoring a huge part of the characters past. Brainwashed or not hes done some horrible things. I thought Michalr Jai white was good as bronze tiger he was just always the secondary story whenever he showed up. Loved his interaction with the guy in the prison cell but he takes a backseat to Roys anger issues in that episode.

[Da Boat]

Yea I think Billy Bixby destroys everybody. He was the Robert Downey as Iron Man of his time, he elevated the part.

Both Adam West and Burt Ward were great as Batman and Robin.

JDM as Negan too. Lynda Carter.

Michael Rosenbaum as Luthor on Smallville.

Personally I'm not crazy about Benois and Cox as Supergirl and DD like most. I guess they are fine but they are not the image I have of their comic counterpart. Especially Cox(who I like as an actor) but I find him often too jolly and confident. I probably would have gone with Steve Pasquale for Murdock.

[SJNeal]

Tracy Scoggins as Cat Grant.

JK!

Although Calista Flockhart's portrayal was a high point for Supergirls 1st season.

[Sandy Hausler]

Lynda Carter - Wonder Woman.

Amen.

Sandy Hausler

[Rogue Star]

Adam West - Batman.

Yup yup yup.

[Rogue Star]

Yea I think Billy Bixby destroys everybody. He was the Robert Downey as Iron Man of his time, he elevated the part.

Both Adam West and Burt Ward were great as Batman and Robin.

JDM as Negan too. Lynda Carter.

Michael Rosenbaum as Luthor on Smallville.

Personally I'm not crazy about Benois and Cox as Supergirl and DD like most. I guess they are fine but they are not the image I have of their comic counterpart. Especially Cox(who I like as an actor) but I find him often too jolly and confident. I probably would have gone with Steve Pasquale for Murdock.

How about Lou Ferrigno as the Hulk? I remember watching him as a child and he was both fearful and irresistible to look at. And Lynda Carter looks waaaay better now than she did her younger years. Wow!