Have you tried some Visual Novels and/or Adventure style games, like The Walking Dead, Fable, or Dangan Ronpa 1 & 2?
Currently I'm on an Atlus kick. I sto- BORROWED my friends NDS and have spent about 20 hours bouncing between SMT: Strange Journey and both SMT: Devil Survivor games and going through Raidou Kuzunoha vs. the Soulless Army on my PS3, which means I've probably gotten 1% of the way through any single one of those games.
Notable impressions:
Strange Journey is now probably my favorite FPS ever, albeit by stretching the definition of "FPS" to its breaking point since its actually a turn based first person dungeon crawling RPG whose main character just happens to have a gun as a standard weapon type.
Switching between Kingdom Hearts 2.5 HD Remake's version of Birth By Sleep, with its fast paced and acrobatic combat combined with its beautiful colors makes Raidou Kuzunoha seem like a sluggish mess whose color palette was dropped in some mud. That being said, I'm still absolutely loving this game due to its 1920's-Japan aesthetics and the fact that I'm playing a detective that can use summoned spirits to help him with his detective work outside of combat. It's also probably the closest thing to a Dresden Files video game I can think of at the moment, and I'd probably love to see it get its own live-action TV series.