Page 175 of 175 FirstFirst ... 75125165171172173174175
Results 2,611 to 2,616 of 2616
  1. #2611
    Astonishing Member phantom1592's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    3,103

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by BBally View Post
    Don't know how controversial this opinion is but I felt both Curt Swan's art and Elliott S! Maggin's writing complimented each other so well, I dare say their dynamic almost rivals that of Siegel and Shuster themselves when it comes to Superman.
    I'm with you there. Swan and Maggin are amazing. In fact as far as controversial goes... I rank them higher than Siegel and Shuster by a lot. I honestly see S&S as designing a very adequate blueprint that the people who came after them turned into a true icon. Golden Age supes does nothing for me... Silver age and on is where he's at

  2. #2612
    Mighty Member Robanker's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2014
    Location
    San Jose, CA
    Posts
    1,770

    Default

    If praising Curt Swan and Maggin is controversial then it's time to put the chairs on the tables and close shop, boys. Time to find a new planet to live on where civilization hasn't fallen.

  3. #2613
    Astonishing Member manwhohaseverything's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2017
    Posts
    3,016

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Ascended View Post
    I find this is an issue with Clark quite often. He's a nuanced character with a lot of layers and depth, and not all those layers are bright and perfect and shiny. But he doesn't have big obvious flaws tacked onto him like most characters. Instead of "alcoholic" or whatever loud, obnoxious flaw you want to point at, Clark's are quiet, and harder to see past the "S" shield. His hypocrisy, his habitual lying, his arrogance.....this stuff doesn't stand out like Tony Stark breaking into a cold sweat if he even smells a beer, yknow?

    And of course, Clark's legend and image get in the way. A lot of people look at Batman and assume he's a hero right? Even though he's a huge asshole, a control freak, and abusive, people see a hero and subconsciously assume his actions are justified. Likewise, Clark's less-than-desirable traits often get ignored. He's Superman after all, so he can't be wrong right?
    It isn't that his flaws aren't obvious. It's quiet obvious. His flaws never bridge a connection to a larger audience because writer brush it aside do not use it as a struggle which clark keeps having to fight. The real never ending battle for truth. They want their saint or boyscout or whatever

    1. he dreams of a perfect life with a gal and a family. On a planet where he wouldn't be considered outsider. While in reality he keeps everyone at arms bay including the girl he loves and lies to.Then he wonders and cries about, why lois lane prefers superman who is honest, over clark kent the persona which is a big sham. He moans about his "solitude" . The entire persona makes it clear that the real clark kent who is called superman is bloody fraud. He himself is the reason he alone.
    2. As said, when he goes on around yammering about hopes and dream with a bullet proof skin. Sprouting or lecturing ideas loudly without understanding what people go through. (this is late silverage thing and something that became insufferable in postcrisis)
    3. He is vigilante. Who doesn't give a damn about laws or rules,if it is harmful to people. He isn't accountable. Neither does he answer to any authority. He is beast who breaks chains.
    4. He was a strongman who used to love a challenge.
    5. He has anger issues. Can get pissed off and be a tad bit excessive. Treat it like it is.
    6. Even, the family thing



    These are all his flaws. All things i get from books. But, clark is always given a pass. It isn't even through legitimate means. But, instead of making those apparent. Most writers don't bother tackling them. They just write it of so that they get an example, a saint, a boyscout for others.
    This is what normally happens. When someone points out how easy it is for clark to be brave because of the bulletproof skin and muscles made out of hotair from the sun that constantly gets stronger. His nonsensical answer is "i fight people stronger than me, all the time. You can do the same". Blah! Well good for him. But it ain't a bloody struggle for him to stay alive all the time. This is why superman is hard for many to connect with. Writing like this. He should have just stayed quiet and not proclaim anything. Atleast, look guilty or say quietly i do fight stronger people. But, Not as an accomplishment.
    clark being shitty about rejection

    They shift the blame like in the first instance to lois, to the world.. Etc. Which is absolute garbage . If you want connections it is your duty reach out,not of the others. Start treating clark kent for the fraud he is with his fake persona. Show clark as the wrong one. Don't go "the lois is just superficial and doesn't see clark" nonsense. Yes, there is some truth and lois is flawed but that isn't why clark is rejected. Clark's fortress of solitude is his own making both literally and figuratively.

    The yammering nonsense with bullet proof skin ala postcrisis . Nobody gives it back to him for that. I would love to see someone from his own corner go upto him and say "shut f--k up superman!!!If you want to save us, then save us. Don't pretend like you have the right to lecture me, when you don't know what it's like being me. do what you want. But,don't you dare lecture us from up there on mount olympus". Have him actually start to shut up, not try to be some example for others.

    He needs to be critiqued.Stop caricaturirising his philosophical adversaries and people who point out his flaws as "just bad guy" like sam lane who calls him out on being a beast without chains, Manchester black regarding broken system causing suffering superman even with power not doing anything but furthering it instead, Arion on a discussion about his choices in saving people and his thought processes.. Etc be genuine about these things. Make it compelling so that people find it engaging. Stop brushing things under the carpet.

    Start treating superman like a vigilante. He is. Sure, have daily planet as pro superman. But, there needs to be something of a reverse which biased like the former but has a point. My idea would be a daily star. There should be a tension between superman and police. There should be times when police does go after him. It should be an uneasy alliance with superman being friends with non-corrupt ones like turpin or sawyer. Superman isn't an ally of the law, only the people. If he is being touted as a brand for charities as stuff. Have him face the superficialness of that world.At worst, clark becomes bigger darkseid who destorys everything with his contempt for control. Clark keeps some chains and learns to tame himself. Have this be a real struggle with the flaw.

    Have him challenge himself to escape the existential boredom and give him a purposes. Yes, clark would always be on the look out for a purpose or a goal. Because otherwise an immortal guy like him would surely fall into the abyss of apathy. Him unlike vandal savage devotes himself to bettering himself instead of taking over the world.Have this be an actual struggle. If he gets obsessed he becomes brainiac.

    Superman has fangs,for better or for worse. Have him actually struggle with his fangs. Have hims struggle with his anger and excesses. Make it sympathetic so that people can actually understand. Not like the justice league cartoons where he gets passive aggressive without warnings. Stop treating like those fangs don't exist. Many writers do this. Especially if batman is in the room. Superman would absolutely get pissed if you tug on his cape for too long.Stop treating him like puppy,when he is dangerous. All great men are.

    Start blaming clark as a family man. If he messes things up with mon el or chris or conner or kara or jon. It is absolutely his fault. Give him shit for it. Don't pretend like he is the victim, when he is not the one who suffered. If mon el gets stuck in phantom zone by Clark's hand. It is absolutely on his hands.Stop erasing family so that he can be absolved. If clark fails to go after chris it is his fault. If clark doesn't accept conner or if jon gets stuck in a volcano in space, he is being shitty. Have him actually try to redeem himself. Don't brush it aside. This goes beyond just his kids to people that look upto him like dick, wally, now damian(not exactly. But those two have gotten closer) .. Etc. For instance, when goku was being shitty piccolo gave him hell for it. Goku actually had to redeem himself by sacrificing himself for his child. Start a treating a shitty dad like clark as the shitty dad. Have him actually take responsibility or atleast bring it up.

    The lost children


    To add to the conversation why batman is attractive to people and why people choose him as an example over clark.

    Clark is always perpetuating a saint image and trying to set an example. He fails. Bruce doesn't try and succeeds.
    Last edited by manwhohaseverything; Yesterday at 12:13 AM.

  4. #2614
    Father Son Kamehameha < Kuwagaton's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Posts
    7,462

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by BBally View Post
    Don't know how controversial this opinion is but I felt both Curt Swan's art and Elliott S! Maggin's writing complimented each other so well, I dare say their dynamic almost rivals that of Siegel and Shuster themselves when it comes to Superman.
    I think the best for Swan in general and Swanderson in particular was Dorfman, but everything clicked when Swan had Maggin and Oksner.

    Poor Shuster... I don't think he ever got a chance to become good as an artist. In fairness, can you imagine if Kirby stopped with superheroes when they first fizzled out? Shuster will always be a legend as a co creator, but he and Siegel were way before Jerry's prime when Superman first came about.
    Welcome or welcome back! Please check out the updated
    CBR Community STANDARDS & RULES

  5. #2615
    Fantastic Member magha_regulus's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Posts
    380

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by manwhohaseverything View Post
    It isn't that his flaws aren't obvious. It's quiet obvious. His flaws never bridge a connection to a larger audience because writer brush it aside do not use it as a struggle which clark keeps having to fight. The real never ending battle for truth. They want their saint or boyscout or whatever

    1. he dreams of a perfect life with a gal and a family. On a planet where he wouldn't be considered outsider. While in reality he keeps everyone at arms bay including the girl he loves and lies to.Then he wonders and cries about, why lois lane prefers superman who is honest, over clark kent the persona which is a big sham. He moans about his "solitude" . The entire persona makes it clear that the real clark kent who is called superman is bloody fraud. He himself is the reason he alone.
    2. As said, when he goes on around yammering about hopes and dream with a bullet proof skin. Sprouting or lecturing ideas loudly without understanding what people go through. (this is late silverage thing and something that became insufferable in postcrisis)
    3. He is vigilante. Who doesn't give a damn about laws or rules,if it is harmful to people. He isn't accountable. Neither does he answer to any authority. He is beast who breaks chains.
    4. He was a strongman who used to love a challenge.
    5. He has anger issues. Can get pissed off and be a tad bit excessive. Treat it like it is.
    6. Even, the family thing



    These are all his flaws. All things i get from books. But, clark is always given a pass. It isn't even through legitimate means. But, instead of making those apparent. Most writers don't bother tackling them. They just write it of so that they get an example, a saint, a boyscout for others.
    This is what normally happens. When someone points out how easy it is for clark to be brave because of the bulletproof skin and muscles made out of hotair from the sun that constantly gets stronger. His nonsensical answer is "i fight people stronger than me, all the time. You can do the same". Blah! Well good for him. But it ain't a bloody struggle for him to stay alive all the time. This is why superman is hard for many to connect with. Writing like this. He should have just stayed quiet and not proclaim anything. Atleast, look guilty or say quietly i do fight stronger people. But, Not as an accomplishment.
    clark being shitty about rejection

    They shift the blame like in the first instance to lois, to the world.. Etc. Which is absolute garbage . If you want connections it is your duty reach out,not of the others. Start treating clark kent for the fraud he is with his fake persona. Show clark as the wrong one. Don't go "the lois is just superficial and doesn't see clark" nonsense. Yes, there is some truth and lois is flawed but that isn't why clark is rejected. Clark's fortress of solitude is his own making both literally and figuratively.

    The yammering nonsense with bullet proof skin ala postcrisis . Nobody gives it back to him for that. I would love to see someone from his own corner go upto him and say "shut f--k up superman!!!If you want to save us, then save us. Don't pretend like you have the right to lecture me, when you don't know what it's like being me. do what you want. But,don't you dare lecture us from up there on mount olympus". Have him actually start to shut up, not try to be some example for others.

    He needs to be critiqued.Stop caricaturirising his philosophical adversaries and people who point out his flaws as "just bad guy" like sam lane who calls him out on being a beast without chains, Manchester black regarding broken system causing suffering superman even with power not doing anything but furthering it instead, Arion on a discussion about his choices in saving people and his thought processes.. Etc be genuine about these things. Make it compelling so that people find it engaging. Stop brushing things under the carpet.

    Start treating superman like a vigilante. He is. Sure, have daily planet as pro superman. But, there needs to be something of a reverse which biased like the former but has a point. My idea would be a daily star. There should be a tension between superman and police. There should be times when police does go after him. It should be an uneasy alliance with superman being friends with non-corrupt ones like turpin or sawyer. Superman isn't an ally of the law, only the people. If he is being touted as a brand for charities as stuff. Have him face the superficialness of that world.At worst, clark becomes bigger darkseid who destorys everything with his contempt for control. Clark keeps some chains and learns to tame himself. Have this be a real struggle with the flaw.

    Have him challenge himself to escape the existential boredom and give him a purposes. Yes, clark would always be on the look out for a purpose or a goal. Because otherwise an immortal guy like him would surely fall into the abyss of apathy. Him unlike vandal savage devotes himself to bettering himself instead of taking over the world.Have this be an actual struggle. If he gets obsessed he becomes brainiac.

    Superman has fangs,for better or for worse. Have him actually struggle with his fangs. Have hims struggle with his anger and excesses. Make it sympathetic so that people can actually understand. Not like the justice league cartoons where he gets passive aggressive without warnings. Stop treating like those fangs don't exist. Many writers do this. Especially if batman is in the room. Superman would absolutely get pissed if you tug on his cape for too long.Stop treating him like puppy,when he is dangerous. All great men are.

    Start blaming clark as a family man. If he messes things up with mon el or chris or conner or kara or jon. It is absolutely his fault. Give him shit for it. Don't pretend like he is the victim, when he is not the one who suffered. If mon el gets stuck in phantom zone by Clark's hand. It is absolutely on his hands.Stop erasing family so that he can be absolved. If clark fails to go after chris it is his fault. If clark doesn't accept conner or if jon gets stuck in a volcano in space, he is being shitty. Have him actually try to redeem himself. Don't brush it aside. This goes beyond just his kids to people that look upto him like dick, wally, now damian(not exactly. But those two have gotten closer) .. Etc. For instance, when goku was being shitty piccolo gave him hell for it. Goku actually had to redeem himself by sacrificing himself for his child. Start a treating a shitty dad like clark as the shitty dad. Have him actually take responsibility or atleast bring it up.

    The lost children


    To add to the conversation why batman is attractive to people and why people choose him as an example over clark.

    Clark is always perpetuating a saint image and trying to set an example. He fails. Bruce doesn't try and succeeds.
    This post made me clap!!! You get it!

  6. #2616
    Savior of the Universe Flash Gordon's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Posts
    7,638

    Default

    The problems Superman has of being "ineffective" are entirely manufactured. Superman is a fictional character, he can be as effective or ineffective as a creator wants. In order to make his stories relatable and appear in some semblance of a reality we recognize, he can't just redistribute wealth with his bare hands or clean the planet up in a night. To make matters worse, his narrative also has to fit into the larger shared universe of other DC characters. So he can never truly create the world that he would.

    That said, you don't have to acknowledge any of these problems to tell a good story. Once you do acknowledge them, the emperor just doesn't have any clothes ya know?

    Batman doesn't appeal to people because he's flawed or scary or whatever, Batman is just really damn cool. He's James Bond, Sherlock Holmes, Zorro, and Dracula all mixed into one dude. Comparing Superman to Batman is another manufactured problem. Both guys would have entirely different scales they operate on. Superman is more of a public figure, and champion of the people than an outright vigilante.
    Last edited by Flash Gordon; Yesterday at 08:02 AM.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •