I think that OPM thread scale , similar to the one your are using is actually a good way to rank enemies and menace
f9d9451913104866a835fd9c34f6dbea.jpg
Boy by that scale lot of X-men villain rank from demon to freaking god....sheesh
I won't bother to post who I think is top ten, all I'll say is Sabretooth would be number one on who I think is the most evil and twisted. Others may be way more powerful or have way more ambition, but Creed is like a predatory animal who killed just for the sake of it. Then there's stuff like this...
145937909173479.jpg
Mr. Sinister
Cameron Hodge
Dirtnap
Selene
Johnny Dee
Masque
Beast (AoA version)
Xorn
Feral
Sugarman
Siena Blaze
I disagree with Selene and Apocalypse to some extent. They were born in a different age with a different set of morals and their motivations particularly Apocalypse's are formed by that upbringing. They are products of the world they grew up in moreso than being pure evil. I would have people actually born in the modern age who still do evil things as more evil IMO.
In addition, in Selene's case the simple fact is people are food. Is it evil when you ate a steak dinner knowing a life was taken in order for you to enjoy it. Her acts are certainly evil in the context of human definitions but humans are just food for vampires at the end of the day.
It's hard for me to listen to someone not in my position. A caterpillar can't relate to what an eagle envisions.
Speaking of mutant vampires, where would Emplate rank in terms of evilness?
I'd rank the character between 6 and 10 I think that the character (despite his evilness) has a spark of goodness in him
To be fair, Cassandra Nova infiltrated and subjugated the Shi'Ar empire, a class 5 civilization with control over multiple galaxies. If she hadn't been so focused on just messing with Charles and his crew, she could have snuffed out a loooot of beings. Not quite universal threat, but very scary.
Let the flames destroy all but that which is pure and true!
If we talk about the most evil, we need to know which villains enjoy the most make people suffering.
Sinister or Nova for me.
Apocalypse, Bastion, Selene, Dark Beast, Sinister are some of the my favorite X-villains.
EDIT: Add Cassandra Nova too on this list.