Originally Posted by
gwangung
Yes, indeed it's broken. Even after repeated attempts with the Freedom Fighters and elsewhere, the character isn't looked on as viable.
Ergo, it's not the powers. It's the approach.
Folks need to think more about the reason for a Phantom Lady. Why does she exist? What niche does she fill? What was her appeal before? How can that translate into the now?
I don't think straightforward superheroics is the answer for this. Phantom Lady is supposed to be sexy...use her in a way that makes sense for her to be sexy and alluring. Maybe a psychological thriller, where she uses her abilities to spook the bad guy? Maybe it's time to be more noire-ish, to deal with sexuality and elusivesiveness? But pick something other than straight up costumes and fisticuffs, because she's not making a mark there...