I very much prefer the old one.
I can never quite figure what it is about his art that I don’t like. I grew up loving Davis and Perez and this is very much the same school of clean, smooth art. So I should love it.
His design sense is great for costumes and good for layouts too. His Hellfire Gala costumes were top notch.
But there’s just something plastic about the faces, the male characters in particular, as though they were dolls.