Which X-Force Is The Best X-Force?

[JB]

Humphries got some stuff right.

I was a fan of the art for that first arc.

[Askani5]

Kyle Yost was the best for me. It was pretty much everything I wanted in an XForce book.

[Rev9]

I think for me it's a toss up between the Clayton Crain lineup of Warparth,Angel,Domino,X23,Vanisher,Wolverine in around 2008 to 2009 that battled Selene and Bastion and the 2010 team of Wolverine,Psyloche,Angel,Deadpool and Fantomex that began in 2010 with Jerome Opena and Dean White.The former had a better story,the latter had better art. I still feel like this X force is not complete.Domino,Logan,Quentin are the only field operatives with Sage and Beast always on Krakoa.Im sure they'll add Colossus(but something is off about him) I would have preferred they recruit Mercury ,I always saw her abilities as a living weapon tailor made for Xforce.With Krakoan gates ,teleporters not really needed but a speedster like Quicksilver/Surge wouldn't hurt. Maybe this is leftfield but Shinobi Shaw's power set also screams Xforce to me.So my team in this Krakoan nation would be Wolverine,Domino,Kid Omega,Mercury, Quicksilver/Surge(one not both) and Shinobi Shaw

[shooshoomanjoe]

No contest: Liefeld's X-Force is the best.

[Su_Whisterfield]

No contest: Liefeld's X-Force is the best.

Mercy, please! I find those legs physically painful to look at. Anatomy, it’s not an optional extra.

[Vishop]

I have seen those pages from X-Men Sketchbook but they weren't appealing to me as Leinil Yu's.

[Frobisher]

Milligan and Allred.

[Vishop]

Milligan and Allred.

That book should have started with X-Statix on the first place. That run was a satirical version of X-Force.

[Frobisher]

That book should have started with X-Statix on the first place. That run was a satirical version of X-Force.

Oh yeah? Remind me how many members of Liefeld’s totally serious and non-self-parodying X-Force died in the first issue.

[Vishop]

Oh yeah? Remind me how many members of Liefeld’s totally serious and non-self-parodying X-Force died in the first issue.

None. But does it need it for some self-pitying and shock provoking experience in the first issue for X-Force? lol X-Force was already popular against the likes of Spidey or X-Men therefore they don't need it anyway to prove how good they are

[Hush]

Milligan and Allred.

Not only it's the best X-Force run but it's also the best X-Men spinoff of all time The X-Cellent can't come soon enough!

[Frobisher]

Not only it's the best X-Force run but it's also the best X-Men spinoff of all time The X-Cellent can't come soon enough!

Eiffel Tower!

[Vegan Daddy]

Milligan and Allred.

Not only it's the best X-Force run but it's also the best X-Men spinoff of all time The X-Cellent can't come soon enough!

By the time I finished that run I was fluent in DoopSpeak.

[Hush]

Eiffel Tower!

By the time I finished that run I was fluent in DoopSpeak.

[From The Shadows]

This one ^ ^

Poll is missing some runs.

I forgot these guys became X-Force for a time. I think I preferred them as X-Statix. That should be Niceza w/ Rob in the poll since he was the co-writer before completely taking over and rather quickly.

Its a toss up between Fabiens and Johns (as in Francis Moore). Perhaps the latter a bit more. Loved the road-tripping and the art. The art! Adam Pollina was a feast for the eyes.



I stopped reading the X-Books in 2006 so the bottom paragraph is partly to do with whats changed when I left.

I haven't read all K/Y or Remender yet, just a handful. But reading about the whole approach, poor ultra-violent saviors , ultra - killers "having" to kill because the others can't is a bit of a turn-off. Especially when they are seen as enjoying it. That's just so pathetic to me. I was so used to reading books like Punisher where he doesn't whine. Its all just so narcissistic. That may sound harsh... I dunno... From the little bit I actually read Remender is a good writer subtracting that. His dialogue is good and so are his beats and the story appeared interesting. Kyle/ Yost uhhh probably won't go near it because of one particular part that scared me away, lol, just... no. I only have a couple of those issues.