Which X-Force Is The Best X-Force?

[CGAR]

Remender got me on board but him having Psylocke helped. I liked Spurriers as well. It was different and not for everyone but I liked that he took his run in a different direction.
Humphries was garbage. He didn't execute anything correctly. KYOST was an awesome team. I did Necrosha but thats it.

[akiresu_]

Wish Spurrier's had more votes/general popularity !! But I can't complain too much, seeing as i myself voted for KYost.

[Tycon]

Wanted to vote for Spurrier but went w/ Kyle & Yost as well.

[MetalPsyc]

Definitely Remender. K&Y helped rejuvinated the the X-Force brand, but Remender put it on its height. The cast, the story, the action, the stake, Remender's X-Force is definitely the best X-Force for Me. I'd like to see this rendition on the big screen (plus Domino). Spurrier and K&Y run were also very good.

[MYCMTSC]

Original, post-Liefeld, post-Cable.

[Sundowhn]

Remender. Best overall story from beginning to end.

[Sundowhn]

Definitely Remender. K&Y helped rejuvinated the the X-Force brand, but Remender put it on its height. The cast, the story, the action, the stake, Remender's X-Force is definitely the best X-Force for Me. I'd like to see this rendition on the big screen (plus Domino). Spurrier and K&Y run were also very good.

You and me, both.

[Tazirai]

Humphries X-force was the ABSOLUTE worst!
Best part of Humphries run?

NO ONE REFERENCES IT! Like at All!

Well some in the LGBTQ community seem to think Psylocke is gay now. /shrug
She had sex with her boyfriend in a female body. Why? Humphries sucks. He also tried to retcon her history into her gaining her powers at 16, and her brother Being Captain Britain while she was a kid. She even had a damn poster on her wall of him in costume...GTFOH!
Storm was incompetent, Bishop was ... I don't know WTF he was.
Spiral was an Intergalactic Ninja? Instead of a badass Sorcery using Swordswoman from another dimension.
Puck was about right, Lol.

[JeanGreyForever]

Humphries X-force was the ABSOLUTE worst!
Best part of Humphries run?

NO ONE REFERENCES IT! Like at All!

Well some in the LGBTQ community seem to think Psylocke is gay now. /shrug
She had sex with her boyfriend in a female body. Why? Humphries sucks. He also tried to retcon her history into her gaining her powers at 16, and her brother Being Captain Britain while she was a kid. She even had a damn poster on her wall of him in costume...GTFOH!
Storm was incompetent, Bishop was ... I don't know WTF he was.
Spiral was an Intergalactic Ninja? Instead of a badass Sorcery using Swordswoman from another dimension.
Puck was about right, Lol.

I'm so glad I gave up on comics around this time. It must be even more jarring coming right after Remender's UXF where Betsy was imo the lead character.

[nnelg]

Liefeld - The Original, New Mutant-esque X-Men Paramilitary


KYost & Choi - Cyclops' Kill Squad


Remender - High-Stakes, "Don't Get Caught" X-Team (or A-Team)

I would like that Liefeld team in a book again.

[Tycon]

Humphries X-force was the ABSOLUTE worst!
Best part of Humphries run?

NO ONE REFERENCES IT! Like at All!

Well some in the LGBTQ community seem to think Psylocke is gay now. /shrug
She had sex with her boyfriend in a female body. Why? Humphries sucks. He also tried to retcon her history into her gaining her powers at 16, and her brother Being Captain Britain while she was a kid. She even had a damn poster on her wall of him in costume...GTFOH!
Storm was incompetent, Bishop was ... I don't know WTF he was.
Spiral was an Intergalactic Ninja? Instead of a badass Sorcery using Swordswoman from another dimension.
Puck was about right, Lol.

*bisexual but whatever

[DDM]

This one ^ ^

Correct answer.

#2 would be the Road Trip era team that really felt more like New Mutants 2.0. 3rd would be Spurrier I guess.

[Ricochet Rita]

Humphries X-force was the ABSOLUTE worst!
Best part of Humphries run?

NO ONE REFERENCES IT! Like at All!

Well some in the LGBTQ community seem to think Psylocke is gay now. /shrug
She had sex with her boyfriend in a female body. Why? Humphries sucks. He also tried to retcon her history into her gaining her powers at 16, and her brother Being Captain Britain while she was a kid. She even had a damn poster on her wall of him in costume...GTFOH!
Storm was incompetent, Bishop was ... I don't know WTF he was.
Spiral was an Intergalactic Ninja? Instead of a badass Sorcery using Swordswoman from another dimension.
Puck was about right, Lol.

When Marvel got stupid and greedy and put out two X-Force books at the same time Humphries was by far the worst of the two. I actually like Cable and X-Force but dropped Humphries book after two garbage issues. Then they cancelled both book for the Spurrier run which was even worse than Humphries.

Humphries was garbage.

Oh. Well, thanks anyway.

I was just curious because Spiral was in, but now I think I won't give it a try.

[cc008]

Oh. Well, thanks anyway.

I was just curious because Spiral was in, but now I think I won't give it a try.

Don't. The fact that it shares a title with Remender's book is almost offensive.

[WheelchairX]

Remender and Spurrier's are the only ones I've properly read through and I enjoyed both thoroughly:

Uncanny

• Great team
• Violent
• Great story arcs
• Loved Jerome Opena's art
• 'No one should know'

X-Force

• Great team
• Unique/Different
• Not tied into anything else
• Art suited the book
• Spurrier's voice for Nemesis
• Humour - especially Psylocke's sarcasm

Voting for Spurrier's run, since it is a great book which is totally underrated and under-appreciated.