The first time I can remember seeing her in a comic is from Crisis, but I’ve since read the one that appeared in All-Star Squadron. So whichever version that was is my answer.
Sandra Knight (Quality / DC comics) - 1st appeared Police Comics #1 (1941) from Quality Comics
Sandra Knight (Fox Features & Ajax-Farrell version) - appeared from 1947-1955
Dee Tyler - 1st appeared Action Comics Weekly #636 (1989) / died in Infinite Crisis #1 (2005)
Stormy Knight - 1st appeared in Crisis Aftermath: The Battle for Blüdhaven (2006)
Jennifer Knight - 1st appeared in Phantom Lady and Doll Man #1 (2012)
other (please specify in a separate post)
The first time I can remember seeing her in a comic is from Crisis, but I’ve since read the one that appeared in All-Star Squadron. So whichever version that was is my answer.
Last edited by Shadowcat; 03-18-2019 at 05:58 PM.
Comic-Watch Reviewer
Titles:
/Doctor Strange/Captain Marvel\Scarlet Witch\
/Iron Man/Captain Britain/Wasp\X-Men\
/JSA\/X-Treme X-Men\/WILDCATS\
https://comic-watch.com/author/baradtzgmail-com
If by "Crisis" you mean "Crisis on Infinite Earths", then that would be the first choice:Sandra Knight (Quality / DC comics) - 1st appeared Police Comics #1 (1941) from Quality ComicsDee Tyler, the second Phantom Lady from DC Comics, wouldn't show up until Action Comics Weekly #636 (January, 1989) which was a few years after CoIE (though Dee was the one killed off in the first issue of Infinite Crisis when Deathstroke gutted her with his sword).
Comic-Watch Reviewer
Titles:
/Doctor Strange/Captain Marvel\Scarlet Witch\
/Iron Man/Captain Britain/Wasp\X-Men\
/JSA\/X-Treme X-Men\/WILDCATS\
https://comic-watch.com/author/baradtzgmail-com
If you read the descriptions and the original post for this thread, you would hopefully understand the difference:The "Fox Features & Ajax-Farrell version" wasn't used by DC. They stuck with the original Quality Comics version that wore the yellow-and-green outfit. (The Fox Feature version seemed to have more "cheesecake" artwork.)
It's been a while since I last updated the count here, so . . .* Sandra Knight (Quality Comics/DC Comics [1972 - various periods]) = 27 votes (+3)
* Dee Tyler (DC Comics, 1989 - 2005) = 15 votes (+2)
* Stormy Knight (DC Comics 2006 - 2011?) = 6 votes (+1)
* Sandra Knight (Fox Features & Ajax-Farrell) = 2 votes (no change)
* Jennifer Knight (DC Comics 2012) = 1 vote (no change)
* other = 2 votes (no change)
And with 55 people having voted so far,* Sandra Knight (Quality Comics/DC Comics [1972 - various periods]) = 27 votes
* Dee Tyler (DC Comics, 1989 - 2005) = 16 votes
* Stormy Knight (DC Comics 2006 - 2011?) = 7 votes
* Sandra Knight (Fox Features & Ajax-Farrell) = 2 votes
* Jennifer Knight (DC Comics 2012) = 1 vote
* other = 2 votes
Two more people have voted, so with 57 people having now voted,* Sandra Knight (Quality Comics/DC Comics [1972 - various periods]) = 28 votes
* Dee Tyler (DC Comics, 1989 - 2005) = 17 votes
* Stormy Knight (DC Comics 2006 - 2011?) = 7 votes
* Sandra Knight (Fox Features & Ajax-Farrell) = 2 votes
* Jennifer Knight (DC Comics 2012) = 1 vote
* other = 2 votes
When I was young, I picked up an old back issue of the 1970's Freedom Fighters at a used book store....happened to have Phantom Lady on the cover.
(I still own it today)
PHANTOM 3.jpgDee from infinite crisis
With 62 people having now voted,* Sandra Knight (1940's Quality Comics/DC Comics [1972 - various periods]) = 29 votes
* Dee Tyler (DC Comics, 1989 - 2005) = 20 votes
* Stormy Knight (DC Comics 2006 - 2011?) = 7 votes
* other = 3 votes
* Sandra Knight (Fox Features & Ajax-Farrell) = 2 votes
* Jennifer Knight (DC Comics 2012) = 1 vote
Stormy Knight was the first version I read but I've seen a few of the 1941 comics.
Power with Girl is better.
Dee Tyler for me
"So you've come to the end now alive but dead inside."
With 68 people having voted,* Sandra Knight (1940's Quality Comics/DC Comics [1972 - various periods]) = 31 votes
* Dee Tyler (DC Comics, 1989 - 2005) = 21 votes
* Stormy Knight (DC Comics 2006 - 2011?) = 10 votes
* other = 3 votes
* Sandra Knight (Fox Features & Ajax-Farrell) = 2 votes
* Jennifer Knight (DC Comics 2012) = 1 vote
Well, we're up to 69 people having voted, and that person appears to have gone with the " other " option.* Sandra Knight (1940's Quality Comics/DC Comics [1972 - various periods]) = 31 votes
* Dee Tyler (DC Comics, 1989 - 2005) = 21 votes
* Stormy Knight (DC Comics 2006 - 2011?) = 10 votes
* other = 4 votes
* Sandra Knight (Fox Features & Ajax-Farrell) = 2 votes
* Jennifer Knight (DC Comics 2012) = 1 vote
But they didn't do the second part, which waswhat they meant with that vote.please specify in a separate post