What Collected Edition are you reading now?

[FluffySheep]

I read volume 1 some time ago and can't even remember what I thought of it...

It was alright. I didn't think it was terrible but it wasn't brilliant. I think it could've done more from the trans angle and maybe reduced the superheroing a bit. Volume 2 might be different though.

[FluffySheep]

After some recent purchases, I now have the brilliant dilemma of choosing which to read first between all 3 Black Science Premiere hardcovers or reading all 3 Invincible Compendiums.

[bob.schoonover]

After some recent purchases, I now have the brilliant dilemma of choosing which to read first between all 3 Black Science Premiere hardcovers or reading all 3 Invincible Compendiums.

I'm about half done with Black Science myself and burned through the 3 Invincible Compendiums last summer. Invincible moves much faster, so you'll feel the sense of progress more there.

[FluffySheep]

I'm about half done with Black Science myself and burned through the 3 Invincible Compendiums last summer. Invincible moves much faster, so you'll feel the sense of progress more there.

I know what you mean about Invincible. I did read the first compendium a while back and flew through it. I've not read compendiums 2 or 3 and I've not read a single issue of Black Science before.

[The Cheat]

After some recent purchases, I now have the brilliant dilemma of choosing which to read first between all 3 Black Science Premiere hardcovers or reading all 3 Invincible Compendiums.

Snap. Just finished Invincible and waiting for the 3rd BS hardcover to be delivered. Started on Paper Girls in the meantime to fill the wait.

[Chubistian]

I just received these BD for my birthday. Persepolis, Thorgal Integral 1, Blueberry Integral 3, published by Norma Editorial

Books.jpg

[Hellboydce]

Batman Black and White, a right chore, couldn’t finish it, on the eBay pile it goes

[Enigma]

It was alright. I didn't think it was terrible but it wasn't brilliant. I think it could've done more from the trans angle and maybe reduced the superheroing a bit. Volume 2 might be different though.

That's interesting because I bought it for that angle haha

[Foxy]

Read through all the The Boys TPB omnis since Wednesday, only 3 issues left for tonight.

This series is great and while I appreciate why certain changes were made to the TV show, as so often the source provides the more comprehensive experience. Definitely recommended (although I still need to see how it all ends tonight).

[The Cheat]

Finished the two Paper Girls hardcovers. Bought it based solely on Vaughan writing it, and it was pretty much what you'd expect. Very easy reading with some interesting ideas in there. Will probably pick up the next hardcover if there ever is one.

[Johnny Thunders!]

Just finished the Nance Collins Swamp Thing and that was terrific. It put me in the mood to read early Vertigo so I started reading my Hellblazer Original Sins trade. Better than I remembered. I just ordered the Dangerous Habits trade. I wonder how good the original Delano run is in retrospect.

[Nab432]

Just finished the Nance Collins Swamp Thing and that was terrific. It put me in the mood to read early Vertigo so I started reading my Hellblazer Original Sins trade. Better than I remembered. I just ordered the Dangerous Habits trade. I wonder how good the original Delano run is in retrospect.

Any further thoughts on Nancy Collins Swamp Thing? I’ve been close to pulling the trigger but it seems to have a divided reaction. Some people love it some people hate it.

[Johnny Thunders!]

I am a big fan of the character, love the original Len Wein Wrightson issues, can't say enough about the Moore run, and I really like the Millar and Soule recent runs.

It carries on from the Moore run with all the characters and mythology intact. I thought it read really well, nice balance of character stories and good old fashioned horror stories.

I read some of the controversy on the politics but, come on environmentalism good, racism bad,,, I don't see the problem.
I think its a good solid run, solid horror comic moments, great new characters to the universe, generally really well written.

[SJNeal]

Just finished the Nance Collins Swamp Thing and that was terrific. It put me in the mood to read early Vertigo so I started reading my Hellblazer Original Sins trade. Better than I remembered. I just ordered the Dangerous Habits trade. I wonder how good the original Delano run is in retrospect.

Personally, I like it better than the Ennis run. Then again I'm a fan of Delano's more cerebral writing style in general. If you like "Original Sins", I'd highly recommend the next volume "The Devil You Know".

[SJNeal]

Any further thoughts on Nancy Collins Swamp Thing? I’ve been close to pulling the trigger but it seems to have a divided reaction. Some people love it some people hate it.

While I haven't cracked open my copy yet, I read the run in singles years ago and I really enjoyed it.