The special rule knocks out the top 5 of my top 10. With the rule in place, my top 10 would look like:
1) Jason Todd
2) Mister Miracle (Scot Free)
3) Dick Grayson
4) Blue Beetle (Ted Kord)
5) Mera
6) Big Barda
7) Wally West
8) Jay Garrick
9)Cassandra Cain
10) John Stewart