Top X-Book update

[Confuzzled]

Iceman blows his comp away...

Too early to say for Astonishing tho

[Tycon]

Team Books:
1. Gen X
2. X-Men Blue ~ Astonishing X-Men
3. Weapon X
4. X-Men Gold

[Marvelboy1974]

For me:
*Generations Phoenix & Jean Grey was my most anticipated book of 2017
1) X-men Blue
2) Jean Grey
3) Astonishing
4) Iceman
5) X-men Gold

[DDM]

My ranking would be:

Teams
1. Generation X
2. X-Men Blue
3. Weapon X
4. Astonishing X-Men
5. X-Men Gold

Solos
1. Iceman
2. Jean Grey
3. All New Wolverine
4. Old Man Logan
5. Cable

[cc008]

Iceman is okay, but I don't like how Sina Grace writes Bobby. He's too femmy and obnoxious.

Yeah, the teen-speak can get annoying for sure

[Thievery]

For me X--men Blue is the best of the current titles based on sample size.

Astonishing X-Men 1 is my single favorite comic out of all the ResureXXion books, but one issue is to early to make a judgement on. I would be interested in seeing poll results after Astonishing is three or four issues into it's run. It has the most potential in my opinion.

I would rank Jean Grey, Gen X, and All New Wolverine closely after Blue.
I enjoy what I have read of Weapon X but it is hard for me to make a complete judgement as I cant follow the Totally Awesome Hulk crossover issues do to budget reasons.
Iceman is a good but not great book in my opinion.

[Offbeat]

I voted for Astonishing since I had to pick one because the combo of Roster + Plot + Writing.

Iceman and Blue are tied with Astonishing in quality though, in my opinion.

[Bl00dwerK]

Astonishing, are you kidding? That book was better in one issue than all the rest put together.

[Dante Milton]

Team: Gen-X
Solo: Iceman

Yeah, the teen-speak can get annoying for sure

I wouldn't say it's teen-speak, if anything it reads like dad jokes. That's my only real critique of the writing, that the jokes land flat.

[MYCMTSC]

1. Gen X
2. Astonishing
3. Iceman
4. X-Men Blue
5. AN-Wolverine
6. Old Man Logan
7. Jean Grey
8. Weapon X
9. X-Men Gold

[CoCoBandz]

Where Ororo Munroe aka Storm is... X-Men Gold.

But is she really even there though? Like can you honestly say that she's there?

[nx01a]

Blue started off the best but the minja/nutant [mutant ninja] issue and the Secret Empire issues have been underwhelming. Nowhere near as insipid as Gold but still bland in addition to the constantly shifting artists without a narrative purpose like Astonishing. Gold has the plus of superior artists. Astonishing #1 was honestly the best RessurXion intro issue of the lot. I can only hope it keeps up this quality but 1 issue isn't enough to adequately judge the quality of the book. Iceman has featured some great character work and laugh out loud humour but it feels forgettable. Jean Grey had potential but I'm not sure Hopeless is using the title as anything but a guest star vehicle.

My vote goes to Blue with the hope that it gets better again once Secret Empire is over and all the things previewed (Gen X, Xavier, etc.) come to pass.

1. Blue
2. Iceman
3. Gold
4. Jean Grey

[Heroine Addict]

Still too early to tell, I think. But between Blue & Astonishing for me, right now. My favor goes to the former tho, 'cause I'm more invested with what's goin' on there, at this time.

[forgotten_utopia]

Sorry since IVX and Civil war 2 I kinda gave up on marvel all together.

I am waiting for serious and legitimate changes. ResureX seemed to have potential, but it never impressed me that much.
The one book I was following was Champions, it was easy going, nice, and youthfull in the right sense. Ambitious too, but then it became meh all of a sudden.

So currently I am not reading comics.

They ruined it for me.

[cc008]

I wouldn't say it's teen-speak, if anything it reads like dad jokes. That's my only real critique of the writing, that the jokes land flat.

mm I don't know. Bobby sounds like a high schooler when he talks sometimes.. Either way, it's not always super enjoyable.