What Grade Would You Give Spider-Man: Renew Your Vows Right Now?

[Starrius]

That's the way I feel about any of the current Spidey related books. While I might not agree with some of their directions, the books are still not awful by any measure.

The thing is that some of the people that gave bad grades for Amazing Spider-Man did post about their grades, and that includes me.

the poll now has:

A - 8
B - 10
C - 9
D - 13
F - 6


None of the people that gave bad grades for Renew Your Vows has posted about their grades.

The poll now has:

A - 22
B - 18
C - 3
D - 3
F - 4

[TheCape]

B-, mostly because i don't like the premise of the Spider-Family, but the book made it work for the most part.

[Celgress]

The thing is that some of the people that gave bad grades for Amazing Spider-Man did post about their grades, and that includes me.

the poll now has:

A - 8
B - 10
C - 9
D - 13
F - 6


None of the people that gave bad grades for Renew Your Vows has posted about their grades.

The poll now has:

A - 22
B - 18
C - 3
D - 3
F - 4

I do have greater respect for those who give a reason for a poor grade than those who do not. If you hate a concept, fine. However, that does not mean the book itself is poorly executed.