Should Alternate reality characters be resurrected?

[blanchett]

There's been a handful of mutant characters to crossover to the main marvel universe and die. Presumably Cerebro has been "catching" these characters automatically. We know the council has forbid the revival of clones but these characters are not clones. They had full lives and some of them were allies unlike Madelyne Pryor who you could make the argument was an "enemy of the state". A few have no known counterpart and at least in the case of exiles Cyclops he's a different race to the 616 Cyclops.

I am sure I am missing someone but of the ones I could think of:

Dead with a counterpart

• Bloodstorm from Cullen Bunn's run
• Dazzler Thor from A-Force
• Shadow X from New Excalibur (Evil O5 and Xavier)
• Ultimate Quicksilver and Armor
• Age of Apocalypse Sunfire, Nightcrawler, Dark Beast, Iceman and Wildchild
• Old Man Logan
• Jean (Xorn)

Dead without a counterpart

• Ultimate Mach 2 and Guardian

Alive

• Exiles Cyclops and Wolverine

Should they be resurrected? How do you think each member of the council will vote??

[KimberlyP]

There's been a handful of mutant characters to crossover to the main marvel universe and die. Presumably Cerebro has been "catching" these characters automatically. We know the council has forbid the revival of clones but these characters are not clones. They had full lives and some of them were allies unlike Madelyne Pryor who you could make the argument was an "enemy of the state". A few have no known counterpart and at least in the case of exiles Cyclops he's a different race to the 616 Cyclops.

I am sure I am missing someone but of the ones I could think of:

Dead with a counterpart

• Bloodstorm from Cullen Bunn's run
• Dazzler Thor from A-Force
• Shadow X from New Excalibur (Evil O5 and Xavier)
• Ultimate Quicksilver and Armor
• Age of Apocalypse Sunfire, Nightcrawler, Dark Beast, Iceman and Wildchild
• Old Man Logan
• Jean (Xorn)

Dead without a counterpart

• Ultimate Mach 2 and Guardian

Alive

• Exiles Cyclops and Wolverine

Should they be resurrected? How do you think each member of the council will vote??

Mach-2 and Guardian are the only ones I’d care to see. Don’t need any duplicate characters, including Dark Beast.

[blanchett]

Mach-2 and Guardian are the only ones I’d care to see. Don’t need any duplicate characters, including Dark Beast.

I would like to see Dazzler Thor again because that was so bizarre. It was less about wanting to seeing them more to question the validity of not seeing them.

Basically if you end up stuck in 616 if your the counterpart of someone like say Wolverine or Jean why align with Krakoa if the protocols consider you less than mutant and you have less protections. I can't see an argument being made for example if 616 Wolverine dies, "you know we already have a spare"?

[TraneTrax]

Mach-2 and Guardian are the only ones I would want to see again. The mutants from the Ultimate universe have a different origin from our 616 mutants (I think they were artificially created by the government or something like that) so I want to see what happens when they get resurrected.

Guardian in particular has a great design and I want to see more of him.

[davetvs]

No, let them all stay dead and gone.

[Devaishwarya]

Absolutely and vehemently...NO!

[ZuLuLu]

Mach-2 and Guardian are the only ones I would want to see again. The mutants from the Ultimate universe have a different origin from our 616 mutants (I think they were artificially created by the government or something like that) so I want to see what happens when they get resurrected.

Guardian in particular has a great design and I want to see more of him.

These are the only two I think needs to be re-introduced.

I don't think they should resurrect their ultimate counterpart, just introduce a 616 version of them

[PetPigeon]

hell to the no

[Whim]

only if it sends them back to their reality ....

maybe a few that have established themselves here already .....

but for the most part definitely no.

[Jackraow21]

Absolutely not. And I say that as someone who loves Old Man Logan... maybe better than 616 Logan honestly. But no. Too messy.

[Will Evans]

I never cared for him but is Jimmy Hudson still alive?

[patch]

I tend towards case-by-case. By and large probably most (who have wandered into the main reality) shouldn't. But Rachel's a prime example here of an exception. She's definitely made 616 her home (and isn't some transient interloper), made significant contributions to this universe and for whom there isn't an existing/current counterpart.

[Wiccan]

If they don't have a 616 counterpart it'd just be cruel not to resurrect them...

[Rnap22]

No. We don’t need multiple versions of the same characters again. If they don’t have a counterpart, then just introduce them. Why would you bring back an alt reality of a person that already exists. The only place where that gets tricky would be Bishop, Rachel, Nate Grey and Cable. I think they’ve lived her long enough without being able to go back where they came.

[Synch340]

I never cared for him but is Jimmy Hudson still alive?

Jimmy Hudson is basically in character limbo. But I believe he's still alive. I would love to see 610 Guardian and Mach-5 resurrected if not a 616 versions of both of them.